The Gronwall Inequality

Ralph Howard · 2025

Read The Gronwall Inequality by Ralph Howard (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23639.txt.

Introduction

Ralph Howard wrote this mathematics paper, published in two thousand twenty-five, proving a broadened form of the Gronwall inequality. That classic inequality bounds how far apart two solutions of a differential equation can drift, given how their starting points and rules differ.

Howard's version works in any Banach space, with solutions moving through an open convex region. One solution follows one rule, the second another, and the second rule is Lipschitz with a fixed constant. The gap between the two rules along the path is capped by a known function of time. The conclusion is an explicit bound: the drift at any time is at most the starting gap plus the accumulated rule gap, both scaled by an exponential factor. Such bounds are workhorses for proving that equations behave well.

Catalog record

CREATORRalph Howard
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE5 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23639

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Gronwall Inequality
Ralph Howard

Abstract




1991 Mathematics Subject Classification
34A12, 34A34

1.
Introduction.

The Gronwall inequality as given here estimates the difference of
solutions to two differential equations
y^{\prime}(t)=f(t,y(t))
and

z^{\prime}(t)=g(t,z(t))
in terms of the difference
between the initial conditions for the equations and the difference
between
f
and
g
. The usual version of the inequality is when

f=g
, but there is little extra work involved in proving the more general
case
[
3
]
.

This note started life as note/homework problem on a web page for
an ordinary differential equation class in 1998. Since then
it has been referenced several times:

[
2
,
4
,
1
,
5
,
6
]
.
So it seemed worthwhile to put a copy on the
arXiv so that there is a version more permanent than
one on a personal web page. While I do not know of an
explicit reference to the inequality here, I very much doubt
it is original to me.

2.
The Inequality

Theorem 2.1

(The Gronwall Inequality)
.

Let
\mathbf{X}
be a Banach space and
U\subset\mathbf{X}
an open convex set in

\mathbf{X}
. Let
f,g\colon[a,b]\times U\to\mathbf{X}
be continuous functions and
let
y,z\colon[a,b]\to U
satisfy the initial value problems

(2.1)

\displaystyle y^{\prime}(t)

\displaystyle=f(t,y(t)),\quad y(a)=y_{0},

(2.2)

\displaystyle z^{\prime}(t)

\displaystyle=g(t,z(t)),\quad z(a)=z_{0}.

Also assume there is a constant
C\geq 0
so that

(2.3)

\|g(t,x_{2})-g(t,x_{1})\|\leq C\|x_{2}-x_{1}\|

and a continuous function
\phi\colon[a,b]\to[0,\infty)

so that

(2.4)

\|f(t,y(t))-g(t,y(t))\|\leq\phi(t).

Then for
t\in[a,b]

(2.5)

\|y(t)-z(t)\|\leq e^{C|t-a|}\|y_{0}-z_{0}\|+e^{C|t-a|}\int_{a}^{t}e^{-C|s-a|}\phi(s)\,ds.

Remark 2.2
.

The inequality (
2.4
) is a little awkward as it involves an
inequality along the solution
y(t)
which we may not know. But
we can replace (
2.4
) by the stronger hypothesis

(2.6)

\|f(t,x)-g(t,x)\|\leq\phi(t)\quad\text{for all}\quad x\in U

(which clearly implies (
2.4
)) and get the same result. Of course
this may mean using a choice of
\phi
that is larger than is needed
in (
2.4
).∎

Remark 2.3
.

Note we are not assuming
f
satisfies a Lipschitz condition and
therefore solutions to the initial value problem
y^{\prime}(t)=f(t,y(t))
,

y(a)=y_{0}
need not be unique. In this case the inequality can be
used to estimate
y(t)
by comparing it to the solution to

z^{\prime}(t)=g(t,z(t))
,
z(a)=y_{0}
with the same initial condition. In
this case the inequality becomes

\|y(t)-z(t)\|\leq e^{C|t-a|}\int_{a}^{t}e^{-C|s-a|}\phi(s)\,ds.

Then if we assume that the inequality (
2.6
) holds then
and
y_{1}^{\prime}(t)=f(t,y_{1}(t))
with
y_{1}(a)=y_{1}
then using the obvious
inequality
\|y(t)-y_{1}(t)\|\leq\|y(t)-z(t)\|+\|z(t)-y_{1}(t)\|
where

z^{\prime}(t)=g(t,z(t))
,
z(a)=y_{0}
we get
the inequality

\|y(t)-y_{1}(t)\|\leq e^{C|t-a|}\|y_{0}-y_{1}\|+2e^{C|t-a|}\int_{a}^{t}e^{-C|s-a|}\phi(s)\,ds.

This gives a version of the Gronwall inequality for differential
equations that do not satisfy a Lipschitz condition in terms of the
Lipschitz constant of a “nearby” differential equation that does
(where near is “nearby” is measured by the size of
\phi
).∎

Proof of Theorem
2.5
.

Let
x\colon[a,b]\to\mathbf{X}
be continuously differentiable.
Then the map
t\mapsto\|x(t)\|
is Lipschitz and
therefore absolutely continuous. Thus it is differentiable
almost everywhere, the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus applies,
and it is easily checked that
\dfrac{d}{dt}\|x^{\prime}(t)\|\leq\|x^{\prime}(t)\|
.
Whence, setting
x(t)=y(t)-y(t)
, using the
hypothesis (
2.4
), and (
2.3
),

\displaystyle\dfrac{d}{dt}\|y(t)-z(t)\|

\displaystyle\leq\|y^{\prime}(t)-z^{\prime}(t)\|

\displaystyle=\|f(t,y(t))-g(t,z(t))\|

\displaystyle\leq\|f(t,y(t))-g(t,y(t))\|+\|g(t,y(t))-g(t,z(t))\|

\displaystyle\leq\phi(t)+C\|y(t)-z(t)\|.

That is

\dfrac{d}{dt}\|y(t)-z(t)\|-C\|y(t)-z(t)\|\leq\phi(t).

Multiplication by the integrating factor
e^{-Ct}
yields

\dfrac{d}{dt}\left(e^{-Ct}\|y(t)-z(t)\|\right)\leq e^{-Ct}\phi(t).

Integrate this from
a
to
t
to get

e^{-Ct}\|y(t)-z(t)\|-\|y_{0}-z_{0}\|\leq\int_{0}^{t}e^{-Cs}\phi(s)\,ds.

This is equivalent to (
2.5
).
∎

The following is the standard form of the Gronwall inequality.

Corollary 2.4
.

Let
\mathbf{X}
be a Banach space and
U\subset\mathbf{X}
an open convex set in

\mathbf{X}
. Let
f\colon[a,b]\times U\to\mathbf{X}
be a continuous function and
let
y,z\colon[a,b]\to U
satisfy the initial value problems

(2.7)

\displaystyle y^{\prime}(t)

\displaystyle=f(t,y(t)),\quad y(a)=y_{0},

(2.8)

\displaystyle z^{\prime}(t)

\displaystyle=f(t,z(t)),\quad z(a)=z_{0}.

Also assume there is a constant
C\geq 0
so that

(2.9)

\|f(t,x_{2})-f(t,x_{1})\|\leq C\|x_{2}-x_{1}\|.

Then for
t\in[a,b]

(2.10)

\|y(t)-z(t)\|\leq e^{C|t-a|}\|y_{0}-z_{0}\|.

Proof.

In Theorem
2.1
let
f=g
. Then we can take

\phi(t)\equiv 0
in (
2.4
). Then (
2.5
) reduces
to (
2.10
).

Read the complete text