Modelling the impact of phenotypic heterogeneity on cell migration: a continuum framework derived from individual-based principles

Rebecca M. Crossley, Philip K. Maini, Ruth E. Baker · 2025

Read Modelling the impact of phenotypic heterogeneity on cell migration: a continuum framework derived from individual-based principles by Rebecca M. Crossley, Philip K. Maini, Ruth E. Baker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23545.txt.

Introduction

Rebecca Crossley, Philip Maini, and Ruth Baker model mixed cell crowds on the move in this 2025 paper. Cells migrate together in tumor growth, wound healing, and immune attacks. Real crowds mix cell types, each behaving differently.

Their framework starts from a model of single cells: random motion, growth, type switching, and response to surroundings, all set by each cell's phenotype. They then coarse-grain it into a smooth, continuum model of the whole crowd. The result is flexible and general, ready for many settings. It shows how small-scale cell rules write the large-scale invasion pattern. Biologists gain a bridge between cell detail and tissue outcome.

Catalog record

CREATORRebecca M. Crossley, Philip K. Maini, Ruth E. Baker
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE189 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23545

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modelling the impact of phenotypic heterogeneity on cell migration: a continuum framework derived from individual-based principles Rebecca M. Crossley, Philip K. Maini, Ruth E. Baker Abstract Collective cell migration plays a crucial role in numerous biological processes, including tumour growth, wound healing, and the immune response. Often, the migrating population consists of cells with various different phenotypes. This study derives a general mathematical framework for modelling cell migration in the local environment, which is coarse-grained from an underlying individual-based model that captures the dynamics of cell migration that are influenced by the phenotype of the cell, such as random movement, proliferation, phenotypic transitions, and interactions with the local environment. The resulting, flexible, and general model provides a continuum, macroscopic description of cell invasion, which represents the phenotype of the cell as a continuous variable and is much more amenable to simulation and analysis than its individual-based counterpart when considering a large number of phenotypes. We showcase the utility of the generalised framework in three biological scenarios: range expansion; cell invasion into the extracellular matrix; and T cell exhaustion. The results highlight how phenotypic structuring impacts the spatial and temporal dynamics of cell populations, demonstrating that different environmental pressures and phenotypic transition mechanisms significantly influence migration patterns, a phenomenon that would be computationally very expensive to explore using an individual-based model alone. This framework provides a versatile and robust tool for understanding the role of phenotypic heterogeneity in collective cell migration, with potential applications in optimising therapeutic strategies for diseases involving cell migration. 2025 keywords phenotypic structuring, collective cell migration, coarse-graining, T cells, go-or-grow, range expansion 1 Introduction Mathematical models are essential tools for helping us to understand the key features and mechanisms underpinning biological processes, such as collective cell migration. Various modelling techniques exist to analyse cell behaviour during migration, ranging from microscopic, individual cell-based models to macroscopic-level, continuum-based models. Stochastic individual-based models track the dynamics of single cells, describing migration through rules that dictate cell interactions with one another and their environment ( Anderson and Rejniak, 2007 ; Cornell et al, 2019 ; Van Liedekerke et al, 2015 ; Wang et al, 2015 ; West et al, 2023 ) . Deterministic continuum models, on the other hand, usually focus on the collective migration of cells into external tissue, stroma, or the local environment, containing, for example, chemo-attractants, adhesive substances or other cell populations that impact cell migration ( Merino-Casallo et al, 2022 ; Trepat et al, 2012 ) . They utilise a variety of different mathematical approaches, such as partial differential equations (PDEs), that describe the evolution of cell densities and are amenable to both computational and analytical exploration. While some PDE models are adaptations of classical invasion models from other contexts, many are derived from first principles as the deterministic, continuum limit of stochastic, discrete models, such as individual-based models. This process of formally deriving the deterministic model ensures that the continuum equation provides a mean-field representation of the underlying dynamics of the individual cells and their environment, which is valid in specific parameter regimes ( Macfarlane et al, 2022b ) . Mathematical models for cell invasion often assume that the cell population is phenotypically homogeneous, meaning every cell behaves identically in terms of division, movement and interactions with the local environment. However, such homogeneity is rarely present in biological systems. During collective cell migration, it is common to observe different cell types working together to facilitate invasion. The observable differences in physical or biochemical characteristics present within most cell populations are known as phenotypic heterogeneity. Over recent years, the role of phenotypic heterogeneity in cell populations has garnered significant attention. Models have been developed to account for distinctly different cell behaviours, using a discrete number of phenotypes ( Carrillo et al, 2024 ; Chauviere et al, 2010 ; Crossley et al, 2024b ; Falcó et al, 2024 ; Stepien et al, 2018 ) , as well as for a continuous spectrum of phenotypes, whereby population members exhibit a variety of behaviours to different degrees ( Bouin et al, 2012 ; Macfarlane et al, 2022a ) . Variability in cell phenotypes can be incorporated into mathematical models of cell dynamics involving differential equations by introducing a variable to describe the phenotypic state of the cells. When there is a discrete set of known cell phenotypes with distinct behaviors, it may be most appropriate to model the phenotypic state as a discrete variable, typically using integer values. However, when there are numerous (or potentially infinite) phenotypes with incremental differences or smoothly transitioning behaviours between them, then a continuously structured phenotype model might be more pertinent. In this case, the resulting evolution equation for the cell population density often takes the form of a non-local reaction-diffusion equation ( Arnold et al, 2012 ; Berestycki et al, 2015 ; Lorenzi and Painter, 2022 ) , or a non-local advection-reaction-diffusion equation ( Celora et al, 2021 ; Celora et al, 2023 ; Lorenzi et al, 2022 ) . Understanding the role of different cell phenotypes during collective migration can guide experimental design, enhance understanding of cell behaviors, and aid the development of treatments for diseases where collective cell migration is crucial, such as during wound healing. However, a critical question arises when these continuum models are constructed phenomenologically, without derivation from an underlying individual-based model. In such cases, we may not fully understand the biological significance of the terms within the model, especially in realising their connection to the behaviours of the individual cells and their interactions with the local environment, leaving the meaning of various terms in the model ambiguous. Moreover, we may unknowingly be making intrinsic assumptions about cell behaviour that could be invalid. This research, therefore, focuses on constructing a general continuum model that is explicitly derived from the individual-based behaviours of the cells and their interactions with surrounding environmental features. This approach ensures that each term in the resulting continuum model has a well-defined interpretation in relation to the underlying cell dynamics, providing clarity and a deeper understanding of the biological processes being modelled. We are not, however, concerned with a detailed quantitative comparison between individual- and population-level models as this is already well explored in the literature ( Ardaševa et al, 2020 ; Byrne and Drasdo, 2009 ; Lorenzi and Painter, 2022 ; Lorenzi et al, 2020 ; Macfarlane et al, 2022b ; Murray et al, 2009 ; Murray et al, 2011 ; Schaller and Meyer-Hermann, 2006 ) . Therefore, in this article, we present a methodology for deriving a continuously structured PDE model for general cell migration into the local environment that is robustly derived from an underlying individual-based model that takes into account the individual interactions between the cells and their local environment. Using this approach, we demonstrate the model’s applicability to various biological scenarios, highlighting the flexibility of this general framework and the consistent, coherent connections between the microscale behaviours captured in the individual-based model and the macroscale descriptions in the resulting PDE model. For the purposes of the derivation of the continuum model, we have chosen cell invasion into the local environment in general, but due to its generality, the local environment could be replaced with a variety of substances, such as neighbouring

Read the complete text