Higher-Order Asset Pricing Factors via Forward Selection Fama-MacBeth Regression
Nicola Borri, Denis Chetverikov, Yukun Liu, Aleh Tsyvinski · 2025
Read Higher-Order Asset Pricing Factors via Forward Selection Fama-MacBeth Regression by Nicola Borri, Denis Chetverikov, Yukun Liu, Aleh Tsyvinski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23501.txt.
Introduction
Nicola Borri, Denis Chetverikov, Yukun Liu, and Aleh Tsyvinski study what drives stock returns in a 2025 paper. Standard models explain returns with a few common factors, such as market and size effects. The authors ask whether squared terms and cross terms of those same factors carry extra pricing power that linear models miss.
Using a step-by-step selection method built on a classic test, they pick a small set of such higher terms. A model with only those terms beat standard rivals both in the data used to build it and in fresh data. It also shrank the unexplained returns of many other proposed factors. That suggests much of the factor zoo's power comes from exposure to these higher terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicola Borri, Denis Chetverikov, Yukun Liu, Aleh Tsyvinski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 154 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23501
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Higher-Order Asset Pricing Factors via Forward Selection Fama-MacBeth Regression Thanks: We are grateful for the comments by Gavin Feng, Stefano Giglio, Narayana Kocherlakota, Whitney Newey, Robert Novy-Marx, Allan Timmermann, and Dacheng Xiu. Nicola Borri, Denis Chetverikov, Yukun Liu, Aleh Tsyvinski Abstract We show that the higher-order terms and interactions of the common sparse linear factors are significantly priced in the cross-section of equity returns. A higher-order model with only a small number of selected higher-order terms from six widely used factors outperforms traditional benchmarks both in-sample and out-of-sample. It also substantially reduces the alphas of the extensive factor zoo, suggesting that the pricing power of many zoo factors is attributable to their exposure to higher-order terms of common linear factors. We identify and rank the most relevant higher-order terms by developing a forward selection Fama-MacBeth procedure. Keywords: high-dimensional factor models, risk premium, stochastic discount factor, forward selection Fama-MacBeth regression procedure, factor zoo 1 Introduction The asset pricing literature has proposed hundreds of candidate factors to explain the cross-section of asset returns. Cochrane (2011) , in his presidential address, refers to this proliferation of candidate factors as the “factor zoo.” This proliferation is itself symptomatic of the fact that sparse linear factor models, such as those introduced by Fama and French (2015) and Carhart (1997) , struggle to fully price the cross-section and hence may not fully span the stochastic discount factor (SDF). In this paper, we show that the interactions of the higher-order terms of the common sparse linear factors are significantly priced in the cross-section of equity returns and capture a significant fraction of the factor zoo. We do so by determining the important interactions via a new factor-selection procedure, which we call the forward selection Fama-MacBeth regression procedure (FS-FMB). The prevalent focus in the literature on sparse linear factor models is primarily driven by considerations of parsimony and is motivated by the first-order Taylor expansion of the SDF. This observation naturally raises the question of whether higher-order terms and interactions of common sparse linear factors, motivated by a higher-order Taylor expansion, also play an important role in pricing the cross-section of expected returns. In this paper, we show that a small and interpretable subset does, by selecting and ranking the higher-order terms. A main challenge in studying such relevant terms is dimensionality. Consider, for example, the standard 6-factor model that includes the Fama-French 5 factors ( Fama and French , 2015 ) and the momentum factor ( Carhart , 1997 ). The higher-order interactions up to degree 3 (4) already have 63 (114) factors. Therefore, we develop a forward selection procedure to choose factors that explain the stochastic discount factor that is suitable for the case when the number of potentially important factors is large. The method adds factors one by one into the set of selected factors, each time maximizing the R^{2} of the cross-sectional regression (second step) of the Fama-MacBeth procedure, thus naturally ranking the importance of the selected factors. After the set of factors is selected, we estimate the SDF loadings by running the cross-sectional regression of sample average returns on sample covariances between returns and selected factors. We derive the rate of convergence of the proposed estimator and also propose a method to debias it, leading to simple inference procedures. We show that the performance of the common factors is substantially improved with their higher-order interactions. We start with 6 of the most common factors in the asset pricing literature. These are the Fama-French 5 factors of Fama and French (2015) and the momentum factor of Jegadeesh and Titman (1993) , and we refer to this model as the FF5M. We consider higher-orders as well as interactions of these 6 factors up to degree 3, leading to 57 candidate higher-order factors. For the test assets, we use a large cross-section of equities including 484 characteristic-managed portfolios from Kozak et al. (2020) . We apply our FS-FMB to select the higher-order factors that are most important in pricing the cross-section of these 484 asset returns. The procedure selects 7 higher-order factors, including 2 second degree higher-orders and 5 interactions. 1 1 1 The FS-FMB procedure requires the choice of a stopping threshold for the second-stage R^{2} improvement. In our baseline, we set it to be 1%. In the Appendix, we show that we can use a cross-validation method to choose the optimal stopping threshold, which generates qualitatively and quantitatively similar results. The inclusion of the 5 interaction terms shows the importance of co-dependence of common asset pricing factors in pricing the cross-section of equity returns. We show that the inclusion of the higher-order factors leads to substantial improvement in pricing the cross-section of asset returns – the adjusted cross-sectional R^{2} increases from 31.2% for the baseline FF5M model to 59% for the selected higher-order factor model. Moreover, the intercept alpha of the higher-order factor model is not statistically significant at the 5% level. We then examine the SDF loadings of the higher-order factors selected by the FS-FMB using both the non-debiased estimates based on the standard Fama-MacBeth (FMB) two-pass regression and the debiased estimates. Estimates from the standard FMB two-pass procedure are likely biased because of the omitted variable bias (see, e.g., Chernozhukov et al. (2018) and Giglio and Xiu (2021) ). The directions of the point estimates are the same and the magnitudes are similar across the two procedures. The estimates based on the non-debiased procedure are all significant at the 5% level, while the estimates based on the debiased procedure are all significant at the 10% level with 5 of the 7 SDF loading estimates being significant at the 5% level. Overall, the results show that the higher-order factors are important for empirically capturing the SDF and significantly price assets in the cross-section. In our baseline analysis, we demonstrate that higher-order factors are important components of the SDF and price cross-sectional asset returns in-sample. We further provide evidence of the out-of-sample performance of the selected higher-order factor model, where we conduct two types of out-of-sample tests. Firstly, we present an out-of-sample test in the asset space. We select higher-order factors and estimate SDF loadings from the training assets and then evaluate the out-of-sample performance using the remaining assets. Our results show that the selected higher-order factors and the performance of the higher-order factor model are stable in this out-of-sample exercise. Secondly, we conduct an out-of-sample test in the time series, where we split the sample into two equal subsamples based on the time series. We use the first half of the sample as the training sample and the second half of the sample as the test sample. Then, we estimate the model in the training sample and evaluate the out-of-sample performance in the test sample. Compared with the benchmark factor models including the CAPM, the FF3 factor model, the FF5 factor model, and the FF5M factor model, the out-of-sample R^{2} of the higher-order factor model is significantly larger. Next, we examine whether the selected higher-order factor model can reduce the pricing power of the factors in the factor zoo. We employ two empirical procedures. First, we perform standard FMB regressions to test the significance of the SDF loading of each factor in the