Linguistic Loops and Geometric Invariants as a Way to Pre-Verbal Thought?

Daniele Corradetti, Alessio Marrani · 2025

Read Linguistic Loops and Geometric Invariants as a Way to Pre-Verbal Thought? by Daniele Corradetti, Alessio Marrani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23311.txt.

Introduction

Daniele Corradetti and Alessio Marrani present a 2025 paper at the seam of language theory and geometry. They define three notions: a language change step, a loop of such steps that returns to its start, and a semantic deficit that a loop can carry. With Lie group tools and higher geometry, they build invariants that capture the whole loop's structure in a few numbers.

The move opens a new research line that brings hard geometry into language studies. The authors also hint at a bolder prize: a math sketch of thought before words. If loops that change words leave a fixed trace, that trace may mirror the pre-verbal frame beneath speech. The paper is a theory sketch, offered as a seed for a field.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniele Corradetti, Alessio Marrani
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23311

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Linguistic Loops and Geometric Invariants as a Way to Pre-Verbal Thought? Daniele Corradetti, Alessio Marrani Abstract We introduce the concepts of linguistic transformation, linguistic loop and semantic deficit. By exploiting Lie group theoretical and geometric techniques, we define invariants that capture the structural properties of a whole linguistic loop. This result paves the way to a totally new line of research, employing tools from Lie theory and higher-dimensional geometry within language studies. But, even more intriguingly, our study hints to a mathematical characterization of the meta-linguistic or pre-verbal thought, namely of those cognitive structures that precede the language. 1 Introduction When Raymond Queneau published his “ Exercices de style ” in 1947, inspired by Bach’s “ Art of Fugue ”, he had the intuition to be doing something intrinsically geometric (so much, that he named the first version of his work “ Dodécaèdre ”). This intuition, far from being casual, may be regarded as the first example of what in this study we define as linguistic transformation . Similarly to a geometric transformation, which transforms an object while maintaining some of its invariant algebraic and geometric properties, a linguistic transformation is, in essence, a map (usually expressed through a proposition in the natural language) that, when applied to an element of a linguistic space, transforms it into another, while preserving in a controlled way the original semantic core, through criteria of coherence and reversibility. Therefore, linguistic transformations are transformations of propositions or text elements characterized by a limited generative content, since they mainly act on the form or signifier of the sentence, with a controlled (and generally limited) impact on its meaning. Moreover, the aforementioned requirement of coherence and reversibility of such transformations yields to the introduction of the concept of linguistic loop , associated to geometric invariants which can be explicitly (and effectively) calculated. As such, the linguistic loop displays strong similarities to the Wilson loop, introduced by the physicist K. G. Wilson in 1974 in his lattice computations in Quantum Field Theory [ 19 ] , and subsequently vastly employed in Differential Geometry, Mathematical Physics [ 14 ] , and also in lattice formulations of nonperturbative Quantum Gravity [ 11 , 1 , 6 ] . From a theoretical point of view, the use of concepts and tools from Lie theory and higher-dimensional geometry, usually employed in the formulation of (classical and quantum) theories of gravity (even beyond Einstein’s General Relativity), represents an interesting and new perspective within the study of linguistic spaces. More than this, tantalizing hints arise to an even more intriguing development, namely to provide a formal, rigorous starting point for the study of cognitive structures pertaining to the pre-verbal thought, which transcends any formulation through language. Indeed, given a loop of linguistic transformations that change completely the form of a sentence while leaving its meaning unaltered, one might ask whether it is possible to characterize the semantic core of the sentence by means of some invariant structure(s), preserved by the loop itself. While it is reasonable to state that the existence of two systems of reasoning, namely system 1 (‘fast’) and system 2 (‘slow’), is gaining a quite broad recognition within the scientific communty (see e.g. [ 7 ] ), we cannot help but observe that the same community is essentially unaware of another equally, if not more, important type of thought system, namely the meta-linguistic , or (as we prefer to name it) pre-verbal , thought . For our purposes, pre-verbal thought refers to mental representations and cognitive structures that exist before being expressed in words. A careful analysis of the mental process giving rise, for example, to the formulation of an elaborate speech, immediately yields one to realize that the speech, before being lexically structured, consists of a pre-verbal intention that only eventually is clothed in a specific language (according to the grammar and the vocabulary learnt by the speaker). In this way, a polyglot can choose whether to formulate his idea in an Italian, Portuguese, English or French without virtually altering the content and the structure of the idea he wants to convey. If rational thought takes place on the linguistic plane in a way made of logical deductions and syllogisms, meta-rational or abstract or pre-verbal thought takes place independently of any specific language. From an experimental point of view, cognitive science and developmental psychology provide clear evidence that children and even animals form rich concepts without language [ 9 , 8 , 15 , 13 , 18 ] . This phenomenon finds its confirmation in neuroscience applied to the brain-computer interfacer, when it uses semantic vector spaces as intermediaries by decoding brain activity into text. In the research conducted in [ 5 , 17 ] , for example, cerebral magnetic resonance models (non-verbal signals) are mapped into a semantic integration that is then translated by a linguistic model into sentences that describe the person’s thoughts. These ‘ proto-concepts ’, identified in neuroscience as a pattern of neural activation indicating a ‘face’ or a ‘hand’ before any language is employed, can be modeled in AI by nodes or embeddings that respond to certain abstract categories. These proto-concepts have a clear pre-verbal nature, and they an support rudimentary thought and even non-verbal communication (e.g., emotional expressions). At this point, one may wonder whether it makes sense to talk about pre-verbal thought in the context of linguistic spaces such as those of a Large Language Model (LLM). Is it possible to identify concepts or invariant structures that are meta-linguistic, and which therefore pertain to the pre-verbal thought, within a space defined in terms pure linguistic elements? In this article, we suggest that this is indeed possible, by defining suitable invariants of linguistic spaces. It should be remarked that our use of algebraic-geometric invariants in linguistic spaces is distinctly different from the one made within usual studies of differential geometry on higher-dimensional varieties originated from LLMs. Usually, these studies apply differential geometry techniques to the embedding space, and they consider some classes of geometric transformations of the vectors thereof. However, geometric transformations in the linguistic space do not necessarily correspond to well-defined linguistic transformations which preserve (or alter in a controlled way) the semantic core of the linguistic element they act upon. In other words, purely geometric transformations acting onto embedding vectors are not an efficient and purposeful tool in the identification/determination of invariants allowing to identify the pre-verbal meaning of a sentence. Instead, for a given sentence and a given sequence of re-formulations of this sentence through the application of a certain set of linguistic transformations (such as translations, paraphrases, negations, etc.), we are going to identify some invariants, which thus capture intrinsic properties, transcending the applied linguistic transformations. More concretely, it is here worth recalling that in a LLM an embedding system consists of an application from a set of linguistic elements or dictionary to a vector space [ 10 , 12 ] . Therefore, through the embedding map one can switch from a discrete space, i.e., the dictionary, to a continuous space. It is important to note that the embedding map is generally not surjective , so an element of the continuous embedding space is not always uniquely translatable into one

Read the complete text