Uncertainty-aware waveform modeling for high signal-to-noise ratio gravitational-wave inference

Simone Mezzasoma, Carl-Johan Haster, Caroline B. Owen, Neil J. Cornish, Nicolás Yunes · 2025

Read Uncertainty-aware waveform modeling for high signal-to-noise ratio gravitational-wave inference by Simone Mezzasoma, Carl-Johan Haster, Caroline B. Owen, Neil J. Cornish, Nicolás Yunes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23304.txt.

Introduction

Simone Mezzasoma and co-authors add uncertainty handling to gravitational wave modeling in a 2025 paper. Semi analytic waveform models for black hole pairs must be tuned against full numerical relativity simulations, which capture the late inspiral and merger where formulas fail. Standard practice then freezes the tuned knobs during inference from real detector data.

Frozen values ignore both fit quality and the noise inside the simulation data itself. Using a standard waveform model, the authors instead sample the fitting knobs from a prior built so the model stays compatible with a training set of surrogate waveforms. Marginalizing over those knobs then carries the uncertainty into parameter inference, a path to cut bias in loud events.

Catalog record

CREATORSimone Mezzasoma, Carl-Johan Haster, Caroline B. Owen, Neil J. Cornish, Nicolás Yunes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23304

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Uncertainty-aware waveform modeling for high signal-to-noise ratio gravitational-wave inference Simone Mezzasoma, Carl-Johan Haster, Caroline B. Owen, Neil J. Cornish, Nicolás Yunes Abstract Semi-analytical waveform models for black hole binaries require calibration against numerical relativity waveforms to accurately represent the late inspiral and merger, where analytical approximations fail. After the fitting coefficients contained in the model are optimized, they are typically held fixed when the model is used to infer astrophysical parameters from real gravitational-wave data. Though point estimates for the fitting parameters are adequate for most applications, they provide an incomplete description of the fit, as they do not account for either the quality of the fit or the intrinsic uncertainties in the numerical relativity data. Using the IMRPhenomD model, we illustrate how to propagate these uncertainties into the inference by sampling the fitting coefficients from a prior distribution and marginalizing over them. The prior distribution is constructed by ensuring that the model is compatible with a training set of numerical relativity surrogates, within a predefined mismatch threshold. This approach demonstrates a pathway to mitigate systematic bias in high signal-to-noise events, particularly when envisioned for the next generation of semi-analytical models. I Introduction Fully analytical waveform models for gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black holes (BBHs) remain out of reach due to the complexity of solving the Einstein equations exactly. The most accurate waveforms we currently have to describe the late inspiral and merger of BBHs are obtained by evolving Einstein’s equations numerically [ 1 , 2 ] . These numerical-relativity (NR) waveforms are computationally costly to produce [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] , and the limited NR data available renders them impractical for extensive data analysis. To address this limitation, faster semi-analytical waveform models have been constructed, primarily categorized into two families: phenomenological models [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] and effective-one-body (EOB) models [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] . Additional effort to improve NR efficiency has led to NR surrogates [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] , which interpolate between known NR waveforms to generate high-quality waveforms in regions without NR simulations. However, NR surrogates are limited by the few NR GW cycles available, as generating the inspiral phase with NR methods is prohibitively expensive. Unless hybridized to post-Newtonian (PN) inspirals, NR surrogates are less suitable for parameter estimation of signals where the inspiral contributes significantly to the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), as with low-mass BBHs and binary neutron stars. We here focus on phenomenological models because they are particularly efficient for data analysis by computing closed-form expressions for GW polarizations directly in the frequency domain. The model amplitude and phase smoothly transition from the low-frequency inspiral regime through the merger to the high-frequency ringdown. Each segment uses a different analytical expression, tailored to the theoretical approximation that most reliably describes the dynamics in each regime. Despite recent advances in PN theory (see, e.g., [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] ), analytical methods alone are insufficient in the region leading up to (and including) the merger, requiring the use of higher-order corrections containing coefficients fit to NR data. The values of these coefficients are then traditionally held fixed during subsequent GW data inference with the model. Using point estimates for the fitting coefficients in phenomenological waveform models is sufficient if (1) the model accurately represents the NR data, i.e., the model is able to replicate the NR data throughout the parameter space with sufficient accuracy, and (2) the biases in the inferred astrophysical parameters produced by the uncertainties in NR waveforms are undetectable. To address cases where condition (1) is not satisfied, model complexity can be increased. This includes strategies like adding more fitting coefficients (e.g. in refining IMRPhenomD into IMRPhenomXAS [ 8 ] ), using a mixture model to capture any residual unfitted data, or selecting the optimal parametrization through transdimensional sampling [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] (e.g. via Reversible Jump Markov Chain Monte Carlo [ 29 ] ). However, for GW detector data with sufficiently high SNRs, we become sensitive to the resolution of the NR waveforms [ 30 ] , and assumption (2) no longer holds. At such SNRs, a model that can accurately reproduce NR waveforms should, in principle, be able to account for the inherent uncertainty in the NR waveforms as well. In this paper, we seek to propagate this uncertainty into the waveform, by allowing the model phenomenological fitting coefficients to vary within a prior volume, where the model faithfully reproduces NR data. We illustrate this approach using the phase of IMRPhenomD during inspiral, though this method can be applied to more recent models and can be generalized to also include merger and ringdown. Our strategy builds on a series of efforts aimed at improving waveform models to make them more reliable for high-SNR GW parameter estimation. Recent studies have focused on quantifying waveform inaccuracies and incorporating them into GW inference through marginalization, similar to what is done in detector calibration [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] . Notably, 4-PN-order truncation errors have been shown to introduce biases in inferred parameters at the sensitivities of current detector networks but can be marginalized away at the cost of increased statistical uncertainty [ 36 ] . Probabilistic waveform models have also emerged as a means to incorporate uncertainty directly into waveform generation. These models employ Gaussian process regression (GPR) [ 37 , 38 , 39 ] to capture uncertainties in NR training waveforms, dynamically adjusting model precision based on the density and resolution of the training data [ 40 ] . While completing this project, we became aware of independent studies that employed GPR to represent NR uncertainty in both phenomenological [ 41 ] and EOB [ 34 ] waveform flavors. Additionally, EOB waveform uncertainty has been modeled with a mixture density network and marginalized over during inference [ 42 ] . Though similar in scope to probabilistic phenomenological models, our approach is more simple and direct, sampling the fitting coefficients from a probability distribution. We explicitly parametrize uncertainty at the level of the phase, following the approach of [ 33 , 36 ] , by introducing frequency-dependent corrections. We can thus incrementally activate individual coefficients and regulate the transition from uninformative priors (i.e. likelihood-dominated constraint on the coefficients, as done in the training) to informative priors (i.e. prior-dominated constraint on the coefficients, as done in the GW inference). The training also reveals the underlying correlations among the coefficients, thus providing insight into the effectiveness of the parametrization: the most degenerate coefficients do not contribute to the waveform structure and could be reduced with a change of variable for a more efficient representation. The computational cost of sampling and marginalizing over the fitting coefficients remains comparable to that of the underlying waveform model, in this case, IMRPhenomD . We organize the paper as follows. Section II reviews the IMRPhenomD inspiral-phase calibration and the uncertainties from fitting to NR waveforms. Section III details the construction of a probability distribution for fitting coefficients, ensuring consistency with NR surrogates. Section IV applies this uncertainty-aware model in Bayesian inference,

Read the complete text