Using Wavelet Decomposition to Determine the Dimension of Structures from Projected Images

Svitlana Mayboroda, David N Spergel · 2025

Read Using Wavelet Decomposition to Determine the Dimension of Structures from Projected Images by Svitlana Mayboroda, David N Spergel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23202.txt.

Introduction

Svitlana Mayboroda and David Spergel present a way in 2025 to measure the fractal dimension of tangled structures from flat images. Many natural patterns are fractal, filling space in a fractional way between a line and a plane. When such a pattern is seen only in projection, like through a telescope, the true dimension is hard to recover.

Their method uses wavelets, small wave packets that sort a picture by scale. Under a fair-view assumption, the wavelet spectrum of the shadow follows a clean power law set by the true dimension, whatever the viewing angle. They applied it to a nearby exploded star. Its layers ranged from dimension near one point seven for cool gas to two point five for hot X-ray gas.

Catalog record

CREATORSvitlana Mayboroda, David N Spergel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23202

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Using Wavelet Decomposition to Determine the Dimension of Structures from Projected Images Svitlana Mayboroda, David N Spergel Abstract Mesoscale structures can often be described as fractional dimensional across a wide range of scales. We consider a γ \gamma dimensional measure embedded in an N N dimensional space and discuss how to determine its dimension, both in N N dimensions and projected into D D dimensions. It is a highly non-trivial problem to decode the original geometry from lower dimensional projection of a high-dimensional measure. The projections are space-feeling, the popular box-counting techniques do not apply, and the Fourier methods are contaminated by aliasing effects. In the present paper we demonstrate that under the "Copernican hypothesis” that we are not observing objects from a special direction, projection in a wavelet basis is remarkably simple: the wavelet power spectrum of a projected γ \gamma dimensional measure is P j ∝ 2 − j ​ γ P_{j}\propto 2^{-j\gamma} . This holds regardless of the embedded dimension, N N , and the projected dimension, D D . This approach could have potentially broad applications in data sciences where a typically sparse matrix encodes lower dimensional information embedded in an extremely high dimensional field and often measured in projection to a low dimensional space. Here, we apply this method to JWST and Chandra observations of the nearby supernova Cas A. We find that the emissions can be represented by projections of mesoscale substructures with fractal dimensions varying from γ = 1.7 \gamma=1.7 for the warm CO layer observed by JWST, up to γ = 2.5 \gamma=2.5 for the hot X-ray emitting gas layer in the supernova remnant. The resulting power law indicates that the emission is coming from a fractal dimensional mesoscale structure likely produced by magneto-hydrodynamical instabilities in the expanding supernova shell. I 1. Introduction Observations of nebulae, molecular clouds, and other astronomical objects reveal intricate structures. While astronomers display these images in beautiful multi-color images, they rarely extract the full information contained in the data. In this paper, we discuss how to infer the fractal dimension of a structure in three-dimensional space from projected images. While this work has been motivated by examples from astronomy, our methods are applicable to a broad range of fields. Many objects show scaling behavior over many orders of magnitude, often generated by hydrodynamical or magneto-hydrodynamical turbulence. If we could accurately measure the dimension of these structures in 3D, then we could obtain new insights into the underlying physics. The dimension of a level set of a passive scalar in a turbulent flow appears to depend on the Damkohler number Chatakonda et al. 2020 : flames develop a 7/3 fractal if the chemical reaction time (or equivalently the cooling time) is short compared to the Eddy turnover time of the smallest eddies and 8/3 if the Eddy turnover time scale is comparable to the chemical reaction time. Simulations Fielding et al. 2020 suggest that the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability generates a thermal emission layer with dimension 5/2 while simulations Beattie et al. 2019 of molecular clouds show an index that varies with Alfvenic Mach number. If we could infer the dimension of a structure in three dimensions, we would have important insights into the physics that determines the observed mesoscale structures. When astronomers observe the surface brightness of an image at frequency, \nu , \Sigma_{\nu}(x,y), they are measuring the projection of the emissivity, \epsilon_{\nu} : \Sigma_{\nu}(x,y)=\int dz\ \epsilon_{\nu}(x,y,z), (1) where we assume that the emission at frequency \nu is optically thin. If the emission at frequency \nu is coming from a thin layer corresponding to a peak in the cooling function, then our underlying physical model is that we are observing emission from a surface that can be described as a \gamma -dimensional surface on its mesoscale, r_{min}<r<r_{max} . Here, r_{min} is the thickness of the emission layer and r_{max} is the outer scale of the instability that creates the mesoscale phenomenon. Note that equation (1) implies that we are interesting in measures and their projections, not sets. Indeed, when \gamma>2 , the projection of a set would be typically space-filling, that is, two-dimensional, as well, rending no information about the initial structure. In this paper, we will generalize from the projection from 3 to 2 dimensions to N to D dimensions. What is the most effective way of describing the fractal dimension of a measure on the mesoscale? Even with the access to the full structure, not just its projection, this is a very intricate question, and the traditional toolbox is surprisingly misleading. The fundamental problem is that numerical methods developed for “classical" fractals do not accurately capture the mesoscale phenomena in highly disconnected sets under consideration. While the box counting methods are widely used to describe sets in fields ranging from engineering Wu et al. 2020 to plant science Bouda et al. 2016 to opthalmology Liebovitch and Toth 1989 , we argue that this approach fails even for the famous problem of determining the properties of a coastline. This method counts the number of boxes, K , in {\mathbb{R}}^{N} that contain \mu as a function of scale, L and then defines the box-counting dimension as d\log K/d\log L . This definition is problematic Falconer 1990 , particularly if \mu is not a continuous surface. An important caveat is that in many applications \mu is fragmented into bubbles. While it may be tempting to introduce a “filling factor" to count the boxes containing \mu , this is an ill-defined concept: in the limit, the points in \mu are a set of measure zero in {\mathbb{R}}^{N} and the filling factor, the volume of the box filled by \mu , is zero. One could say that a bubble is not a point, but when viewed on the mesoscale, a bubble or tidal pool appears as "dust" and box counting breaks down in the presence of "dust". As an illustration of its failure, consider the rational numbers {\mathbb{Q}}\subset{\mathbb{R}} : box counting yields a dimension 1 for {\mathbb{Q}} and dimension N for {\mathbb{Q}}^{N} . The rational numbers are a set of measure zero. If you are a marine biologist who wants to determine the surface area of the tidal zone, you do not want to exclude tidal pools. Similarly, isolated bubbles are not properly counted in analyses of molecular clouds or measurements of the area of a flame front in studies of combustion. In §2, we show that wavelets are a sparse and effective description of a measure that provides a more robust approach than box counting on sets. An even bigger problem, central to the present paper, is that in astronomy one often only has access to projected images. If one is projecting to {\mathbb{R}}^{d} a set of dimension larger than 2, the result is typically two-dimensional, space-filling, and box counting fails for much more trivial reasons than above: it blindly yields projected dimension 2. The Fourier methods, if attempted, would be contaminated by aliasing. Moreover, we only observe one projection at a time, as opposed to the view from all angles. Thus, the methods of reconstructing the data from projections at all angles used, e.g., in CT, do not apply. This problem is the focus of §3, where the main contributions

Read the complete text