Yang model revisited

S. Mignemi · 2025

Read Yang model revisited by S. Mignemi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-23155.txt.

Introduction

Mignemi, writing alone, revisits Yang's model of curved noncommutative spacetime in a 2025 paper. Long ago, Yang stretched Snyder's noncommutative space onto a curved background. The algebra behind it contains both the Snyder and de Sitter versions as special cases.

That nesting makes the model a bridge between the very small and the very large. The review gathers recent progress on generalizations of the model. It also recasts the setup in Hopf algebra language, a modern frame for such symmetries. Phenomenological hooks, places the math might touch observation, are reported as well. The paper serves readers entering this corner of quantum gravity.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Mignemi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-23155

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Yang model revisited S. Mignemi Abstract A long time ago C.N. Yang proposed a generalization of the Snyder model to the case of a curved background spacetime, based on an algebra isomorphic to s ​ o ​ ( 1 , 5 ) so(1,5) , which includes as subalgebras both the Snyder and the de Sitter algebras. His proposal can therefore be interpreted as a model of noncommutative curved spacetime, and could be useful for relating physics at very small and very large scales. We review this model and some recent progress concerning its generalizations and its interpretation in the framework of Hopf algebras. We also report some possibilities to relate it to more phenomenological aspects. 1 Quantum gravity and noncommutative geometry At present, no complete theory of quantum gravity is available. However, it is known that the predictions of quantum mechanics and general relativity imply the existence of a minimal measurable length of the size of the Planck length L_{P}=\sqrt{\hbar G\over c^{3}}=10^{-33} cm [ 1 ] . Hence it is natural to believe that the properties of spacetime at this scale must be rather different from those we observe in everyday experience. Among the proposals for a model of spacetime at Planck scale, noncommutative geometry plays a relevant role [ 2 ] . Noncommutative geometry is based on the assumption that the components of the position operator do not commute, leading to the impossibility of localizing a particle exactly. Among various approaches to this field, a relevant one is the Hopf algebra formalism [ 3 ] , which is suitable for the description of the symmetries of the geometry. Noncommutative geometries are usually defined on flat spacetime, but their extension to curved spacetime has earned some interest recently because of possible implications for astrophysical observations, like time delay of photons from distant sources [ 4 ] . However, also the formal aspects of this extension are noticeable, in particular the relations between the curvature of spacetime and of momentum space. Moreover, these models relate the properties of spacetime at microscopic and macroscopic scales. The first model of this kind was proposed by C.N. Yang already in 1947 [ 5 ] . In the present paper, we review this framework and discuss some recent progresses and generalizations. 2 The Snyder algebra We start by summarizing the main features of the Snyder model, from which Yang took inspiration. In 1947 Snyder proposed the first model of noncommutative geometry [ 6 ] . His aim was to construct a theory that included a fundamental length without breaking the Lorentz invariance. This purpose was realized by deforming the commutation relations of the Heisenberg algebra. In fact, the model was defined through an algebra that, besides the deformed Heisenbeg algebra generated by positions \hat{x}_{\mu} and momenta \hat{p}_{\mu} , contained the Lorentz algebra with generators J_{\mu\nu} , [\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{x}_{\nu}]=i\beta J_{\mu\nu},\quad[\hat{p}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\nu}]=0,\quad[\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\mu}]=i(\eta_{\mu\nu}+\beta\hat{p}_{\mu}\hat{p}_{\nu}), [J_{\mu\nu},J_{\rho\sigma}]=i\big(\eta_{\mu\rho}J_{\nu\sigma}-\eta_{\mu\sigma}J_{\nu\rho}+\eta_{\nu\rho}J_{\mu\sigma}-\eta_{\nu\sigma}J_{\mu\rho}\big), [J_{\mu\nu},\hat{p}_{\lambda}]=i\left(\eta_{\mu\lambda}\hat{p}_{\nu}-\eta_{\lambda\nu}\hat{p}_{\mu}\right),\quad[J_{\mu\nu},\hat{x}_{\lambda}]=i\left(\eta_{\mu\lambda}\hat{x}_{\nu}-\eta_{\nu\lambda}\hat{x}_{\mu}\right). (1) In particular, the components of the position operator \hat{x}_{\mu} do not commute among themselves. The coupling constant \beta has dimension of inverse mass square and may be identified with 1/M_{P}^{2}=L_{P}^{2} , M_{P} being the Planck mass. Note that \beta can take both signs. If it is positive, the bound p^{2}<1/\beta must hold, and hence a maximal mass 1/\beta is predicted. Snyder also showed that his algebra can be realized on canonical phase space of coordinates x and p , with Lorentz generators defined as J_{\mu\nu}=x_{\mu}p_{\nu}-x_{\nu}p_{\mu} . In contrast with most common models of noncommutative geometry, the commutators are not linear in the phase space variables: this allows them to be compatible with a linear action of the Lorentz symmetry, so that the Poincaré algebra is not deformed. However, translations (generated by the \hat{p}_{\mu} ) act in a nonlinear way on position variables. The Snyder model can be interpreted as describing flat spacetime with a curved momentum space. In fact, the subalgebra generated by J_{\mu\nu} and \hat{x}_{\mu} is isomorphic to the de Sitter algebra so(1,4) , and hence the Snyder momentum space has the same geometry as de Sitter spacetime. 3 The Yang algebra Soon after the publication of Snyder’s paper, Yang proposed a generalization where also the momentum variables do not commute, like in de Sitter spacetime [ 5 ] . The algebra is isomorphic to so(1,5) , with 15 generators, [\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{x}_{\nu}]=i\beta J_{\mu\nu},\quad[\hat{p}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\nu}]=i\alpha J_{\mu\nu},\quad[\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\nu}]=i\eta_{\mu\nu}K, [J_{\mu\nu},J_{\rho\sigma}]=i\big(\eta_{\mu\rho}J_{\nu\sigma}-\eta_{\mu\sigma}J_{\nu\rho}+\eta_{\nu\rho}J_{\mu\sigma}-\eta_{\nu\sigma}J_{\mu\rho}\big), [J_{\mu\nu},\hat{p}_{\lambda}]=i\left(\eta_{\mu\lambda}\hat{p}_{\nu}-\eta_{\lambda\nu}\hat{p}_{\mu}\right),\quad[J_{\mu\nu},\hat{x}_{\lambda}]=i\left(\eta_{\mu\lambda}\hat{x}_{\nu}-\eta_{\nu\lambda}\hat{x}_{\mu}\right), [K,\hat{x}_{\mu}]=i\beta\hat{p}_{\mu},\quad[K,\hat{p}_{\mu}]=-i\alpha\hat{x}_{\mu},\quad[J_{\mu\nu},K]=0. (2) The deformation parameter \alpha has dimension of inverse length square and may be identified with the cosmological constant, while {\beta} is the same as in the Snyder model. Notice that both \alpha and \beta can take positive or negative values, giving rise to models with very different physical properties [ 7 ] . For example, positive \alpha enforces the bound \hat{x}^{2}<1/\alpha^{2} and analogously, for positive \beta , \hat{p}^{2}<1/\beta^{2} . The Yang algebra contains as subalgebras both the de Sitter and the Snyder algebras, and therefore describes a noncommutative model in a spacetime of constant curvature. In order to close the algebra, Yang had to introduce a new generator K which rotates positions into momenta, but whose physical interpretation is not evident. The previous algebra is invariant under a generalized Born duality [ 8 , 9 ] , \alpha\leftrightarrow\beta,\quad\hat{x}_{\mu}\to-\hat{p}_{\mu},\quad\hat{p}_{\mu}\to\hat{x}_{\mu},\quad J_{\mu\nu}\leftrightarrow J_{\mu\nu},\quad K\leftrightarrow K. (3) The isomorphism with the so(1,5) algebra can be obtained by identifying M_{\mu\nu}=J_{\mu\nu},\qquad M_{\mu 4}=\hat{x}_{\mu},\qquad M_{\mu 5}=\hat{p}_{\mu},\qquad M_{45}=K, (4) where M_{AB} ( A,B=0,\dots,5 ) are the generators of so(1,5) . There also exists a different generalization of the Snyder algebra on curved space, known as triply special relativity (TSR), that does not include K , but is nonlinear [ 10 ] . In particular, in that case the deformed Heisenberg subalgebra takes the form [\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{x}_{\nu}]=i\beta J_{\mu\nu},\quad[\hat{p}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\nu}]=i\alpha J_{\mu\nu}, [\hat{x}_{\mu},\hat{p}_{\nu}]=i\Big(\eta_{\mu\nu}+\alpha\hat{x}_{\mu}\hat{x}_{\nu}+\beta\hat{p}_{\mu}\hat{p}_{\nu}+\sqrt{\alpha\beta}(\hat{x}_{\mu}\hat{p}_{\nu}+\hat{p}_{\mu}\hat{x}_{\nu}-J_{\mu\nu})\Big), (5) and one can interpret the phase space as a coset space SO(1,5)/SO(1,3)\times O(2) . Triply special relativity theory has been described as a deformation of the Galilei group in [ 11 ] and its Hamiltonian formulation has been investigated in [ 12 ] . A framework unifying it with the Yang model has been proposed in [ 13 ] . Two interpretations of the Yang algebra are possible: Take the algebra as it is, with its 15 generators [ 14 , 15 ] . This allows one to construct the Hopf algebra structure, with the related star product, twist, etc. exploiting the results known for generic orthogonal algebras [ 16 ] However, in this case one has to consider an extended phase space with scalar and tensorial degrees of freedom, whose interpretation is not obvious. Take a nonlinear realization on canonical phase space spanned by x_{\mu} and p_{\mu} , with J_{\mu\nu}=x_{\mu}p_{\nu}-x_{\nu}p_{\nu} and K=K(x,p) [ 17 ] , in analogy with the representation given by Snyder for his model [ 6 ] . In this case the interpretation is easier and one can include the Yang model in the same family of nonlinear realizations of so(1,5) as TSR, identifying the phase space with a coset space. However, one can no longer define a Hopf algebra, star products etc. 4 Realizations of the Yang-Poisson model We start following the second route, and discussing the classical limit of the Yang model, in which commutators are replaced by Poisson brackets. This makes the investigation much easier because of the absence of ordering problems. We call this limit Yang-Poisson model.

Read the complete text