Critical modular lattices in the Gaussian core model

Arian Joharian, Frank Vallentin, Marc Christian Zimmermann · 2025

Read Critical modular lattices in the Gaussian core model by Arian Joharian, Frank Vallentin, Marc Christian Zimmermann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22895.txt.

Introduction

Lattices that repeat with a twist, called modular lattices, include some of geometry's most famous packings. Arian Joharian and co-authors test how those lattices sit in the Gaussian core model, where soft balls repel by a bell curve, in this 2025 paper. Local optimality there means no small nudge lowers the energy.

Two stars pass the strongest test: the sixteen-dimensional Barnes-Wall lattice and the twelve-dimensional Coxeter-Todd lattice are locally best among all lattices, in the sense set by Cohn and Kumar. Other modular lattices the team checked fail, some not even sitting at an energy standstill. The split shows modular symmetry alone does not guarantee optimality. The paper maps which families earn the title.

Catalog record

CREATORArian Joharian, Frank Vallentin, Marc Christian Zimmermann
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22895

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Critical modular lattices in the Gaussian core model Arian Joharian, Frank Vallentin, Marc Christian Zimmermann Abstract . We discuss the local analysis of Gaussian potential energy of modular lattices. We present examples of 2 2 -modular lattices—such as the 16 16 -dimensional Barnes-Wall lattice—and 3 3 -modular lattices—such as the 12 12 -dimensional Coxeter-Todd lattice—that are locally universally optimal among lattices (in the sense of Cohn and Kumar). We also provide other 2 2 - and 3 3 -modular lattices that are not locally universally optimal, or not even critical in the Gaussian core model. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 11H55, 52C17 1. Introduction 1.1. The Gaussian core model Let L\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{n} be an n -dimensional lattice, i.e. a discrete subgroup of \mathbb{R}^{n} of full rank. The Gaussian potential energy of L is defined by \mathcal{E}(\alpha,L)=\sum_{x\in L\setminus\{0\}}e^{-\alpha\|x\|^{2}}, for \alpha>0 . Point configurations which interact via Gaussian potential functions r\mapsto e^{-\alpha r^{2}} are referred to as the Gaussian core model . They are natural physical systems (see Stillinger [ 33 ] ) and they are mathematically quite general. This embeds into the larger context of universal optimality: Following Cohn and Kumar [ 4 ] , a point configuration is called universally optimal if it minimizes potential energy among all configurations of the same point density for every completely monotonic function of squared distance. It is an important observation that after fixing a point density, a point configuration is universally optimal if and only if it minimizes Gaussian potential energy for all \alpha>0 . This is a consequence of a theorem of Bernstein (see Widder [ 38 , Theorem 12b, page 161] ). See Cohn, Kumar, Miller, Radchenko and Viazovska [ 6 ] for further discussion. In the seminal paper [ 6 ] the authors proved that the E_{8} root lattice in dimension 8 and the Leech lattice \Lambda_{24} in dimension 24 are universally optimal point configurations in their respective dimensions. Further, the authors proved that these lattices are the unique minimizers among all periodic point configurations. In this follow-up paper to [ 16 ] we are interested in the local analysis of the function L\mapsto\mathcal{E}(\alpha,L) when L varies in the manifold of rank n lattices having point density 1 , which means that the number of lattice points per unit volume equals 1 . Even if considering local universal optimality restricted to lattice configurations, only few examples are known. Explicitly, these are, the one dimensional standard lattice \mathbb{Z} , the hexagonal lattice A_{2} (see Montgomery [ 23 ] ), the root lattice D_{4} , E_{8} and \Lambda_{24} (see Sarnak and Strömbergsson [ 30 ] ), where \mathbb{Z} , E_{8} , and \Lambda_{24} of course are now known to be universally optimal among all point configurations. The hexagonal lattice is universally optimal among lattices and conjectured to be universally optimal among all point configurations. While D_{4} is only proven to be locally universally optimal among lattices, it is conjectured (based on numerical simulations by Torquato and Stillinger [ 34 ] and Cohn, Kumar, and Schürmann [ 5 ] ) that D_{4} is actually universally optimal among all point configurations. In [ 16 ] the case of even unimodular lattices was considered. Recall that a lattice L is called unimodular if it coincides with its dual lattice L^{\#}=\{y\in\mathbb{R}^{n}:x\cdot y\in\mathbb{Z}\text{ for all }x\in L\}, where x\cdot y denotes the standard inner product of x,y\in\mathbb{R}^{n} . The lattice L is called even if for every lattice vector x\in L the inner product x\cdot x is an even integer. It is well-known (see for instance Serre [ 32 ] ) that in a given dimension the number of non-isometric even unimodular lattices is finite and that they exist only in dimensions which are divisible by 8 . One of the main goals of [ 16 ] , motivated by Regev and Stephens-Davidowitz [ 29 ] , was to find a concrete example of an even unimodular lattice that is a local maximum for some energy parameter \alpha and the associated Gaussian potential. The first such example in this class of lattices can be found dimension 32 , every extremal even unimodular lattice in dimension 32 is a local maximum for certain values of \alpha , a rigorous proof of this statement was worked out specifically for \alpha=\pi . It was proved that E_{8}\perp E_{8} in dimension 16 and every Niemeier lattice in dimension 24 with a decomposable root system are saddle points if \alpha is large enough. While all even unimodular lattices in dimensions up to 24 turned out to be critical points in the Gaussian core model, there are non-critical even unimodular lattices in dimension 32 . The aim of this paper is to extend the local analysis to a larger class of lattices, including dimensions in which no even unimodular lattice can exist. For this we consider the class of (extremal) modular lattices. This is in part motivated by an easy observation, which was already mentioned in Sarnak and Strömbergsson [ 30 ] : A lattice (of point density 1 ) cannot be universally optimal if the theta series of L and L^{\#} are different. It seems noteworthy to mention that A_{2} and D_{4} , which are locally universally optimal among lattices, are actually 2 -modular lattices, that is A_{2}\cong\sqrt{2}A_{2}^{\#} and D_{4}\cong\sqrt{2}D_{4}^{\#} . From the general definition of an \ell -modular lattice below, it becomes clear that \ell -modular lattices satisfy this necessary condition and therefore seem good candidates to investigate if one is interested in universal optimality. 1.2. Modular lattices in the Gaussian core model Modular lattices generalize unimodular lattices. This generalization is closely related to the theta series of a lattice L , which is a function of a variable \tau in the complex upper half plane given by \Theta_{L}(\tau)=\sum_{v\in L}e^{\pi i\tau\|v\|^{2}}. If L is an even lattice, \Theta_{L} can be rewritten in terms of the cardinalities a_{m}=|L(2m)| of the shells L(2m)=\left\{v\in L:\|v\|^{2}=2m\right\} for m\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0} and the modulus q=e^{2\pi i\tau} as a Fourier-series \Theta_{L}(q)=\sum_{m\geq 0}a_{m}q^{m}. It is well known that if L is even unimodular, then \Theta_{L} is a modular form for the full modular group \operatorname{SL}_{2}(\mathbb{Z}) . We now move to a larger class of lattices, for which \Theta_{L} has similar desirable properties. Let \ell>0 . A similarity \sigma:\mathbb{R}^{n}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{n} of norm \ell is a linear map satisfying \sigma(v)\cdot\sigma(w)=\ell v\cdot w for all v,w\in\mathbb{R}^{n} . Definition 1.1 . A lattice is called \ell -modular if there exists a similarity of norm (or similarity factor ) \ell such that L=\sigma(L^{\#}), or, equivalently, L\cong\sqrt{\ell}L^{\#}. As first observed by Quebbemann in [ 27 ] (and extended in [ 28 ] ) the theta series of an even \ell -modular lattice of dimension n=2k is a modular form of weight k for the Fricke group \Gamma_{*}(\ell) and a suitably chosen character. This connection to modular forms implies an upper bound on the minimal norm of a nonzero lattice vector. Modular lattices for which the minimum norm attains this bound are called extremal . For a definition of \Gamma_{*}(\ell) and details on the character and extremality we refer forward to Section 2.2 . We will investigate the local behavior of Gaussian potential energy of modular lattices in terms of the theta series of L using the relation \mathcal{E}(\alpha,L)=\sum_{x\in

Read the complete text