United States Early Career Researchers in Collider Physics input to the European Strategy for Particle Physics Update

Summary prepared by Oz Amram, Grace Cummings · 2025

Read United States Early Career Researchers in Collider Physics input to the European Strategy for Particle Physics Update by Summary prepared by Oz Amram, Grace Cummings (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22834.txt.

Introduction

Young American particle physicists got a vote on Europe's collider future, and Oz Amram and Grace Cummings report the tally in a 2025 document. The paper is the United States early-career community's formal input to the European Strategy update for 2025-2026. Early career meant students, postdocs, untenured faculty, and research scientists under forty.

A survey run in early 2025 drew 105 responses. The questions gauged enthusiasm for the rival future collider options and for research priorities, framed around the recommendations of the United States' own P5 planning report. The authors set out the community's preferences option by option, so European planners can see where the next generation of American collider physicists hopes the field will build. The document stands as a snapshot of a workforce staking its future on machines not yet approved.

Catalog record

CREATORSummary prepared by Oz Amram, Grace Cummings
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22834

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

United States Early Career Researchers in Collider Physics input to the European Strategy for Particle Physics Update Summary prepared by Oz Amram, Grace Cummings Abstract This document represents a contribution of the United States early career collider physics community to the 2025–2026 update to the European Strategy for Particle Physics. Preferences with regard to different future collider options and R&D priorities were assessed via a survey. The early career community was defined as anyone who is a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, untenured faculty member, or research scientist under 40 years of age. In total, 105 participants responded to the survey between February and March 10th, 2025. Questions were formulated primarily to gauge the enthusiasm and preferences for different collider options in line with the recommendations of the United States’ P5 report, relevant to the European Strategy Update. 1 Introduction A key outcome of the current update to the European Strategy is a recommendation for the next energy frontier collider project hosted at CERN. Given the grand scale and long timeline of any proposed future collider, the decision will shape the entire field of particle physics for the next several decades. The careers of particle physicists in the United States will undoubtedly be greatly affected by the outcome of this process. Early career collider physicists in particular have a lot at stake, as the majority of our career will occur after the conclusion of High Luminosity LHC, and thus will be determined by whatever project is built next. Historically, the United States has had significant involvement in the physics program at CERN, and given this history, it is fair to anticipate this opportunity again. The US particle physics community has recently come together in the Snowmass--P5 process to decide on a vision and prioritization for the next decade of research, culminating in the widely accepted P5 report 1 1 1 https://www.usparticlephysics.org/2023-p5-report/ . In relation to future collider physics programs, a key area of the current European Strategy Update, the P5 report made several statements. The report recommended US participation in an off-shore Higgs Factory, and research and development toward a parton-center-of-mass collider of 10 TeV. Within this guidance, the P5 report could support several different collider options at CERN. While the Snowmass–P5 process received input from early career scientists, the final report synthesizes views from the entire community, and does not specifically highlight the opinions of the early career community. Given the long term impact of the current update to the European Strategy, and the generality of the P5 report, we felt it was a useful exercise to directly assess the enthusiasm of the US early career community for different collider options consistent with the recommendations of the P5 report. A survey was designed to assess different proposed colliders. Respondents were also asked to consider R&D priorities and communicate preferences for different long-term options beyond the next immediate collider. The survey did not explicitly ask about the perception of technical and financial feasibility of the different projects, but these factors likely played a role in the project preferences. The survey was distributed to various experimental collaborations (ATLAS, CMS, Belle-II, LHCb, ALICE) through dedicated early career mailing lists when possible, the US LHC Users Association, and among theorists. Responses were solicited February 10th to March 10th, 2025. Any early career researcher associated with the United States was encouraged to submit input. For the purposes of this survey, early career was defined as anyone who is a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, untenured faculty member, or research scientist under 40 years of age. A total of 105 responses were collected. The survey was anonymous, but participants could optionally enter their emails if they wished to provide feedback on the summary document. 2 Survey Results In this section we summarize the survey responses. The exact distributions for each question are given in Appendix A . The anonymized survey responses have been made public for transparency 2 2 2 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oeMfGNbFBOYMDkJyZsCHbP48nKHzt1BbtG9XqZelfRY . Given the statistical power of the 105 respondents, the uncertainty on the mean value of the questions asking for a 1 through 5 rating is {\sim}0.1 . The uncertainty on the outcome yes/no poll questions asked is {\sim}5\% . Many questions had significant heterogeneity in the responses. Given the limited range of the rating scale we do not report the standard deviation of the rating scores but instead assess the homogeneity of responses based on the fraction of responses in the 1-2 range vs. 4-5 range. 2.1 Respondent Demographics Of the 105 survey respondents, the largest career stage represented was postdocs (43%), followed by graduate students (32%), untenured faculty (17%) and research scientists (8%). The majority of survey respondents were members of a current LHC collaboration, with 47% and 35% of respondents part of the CMS and ATLAS Experiments, respectively. Theorists made up 8% of respondents, and the remaining 10% came from various other particle physics experiments (ALICE, LHCb, Belle-II, and others). Figure 1 summarizes the career stage and experimental affiliation of the respondents of this survey. Primary work location was also surveyed, with 54% of the respondents based at a US University, 25% at a US national laboratory, 20% at CERN, and the remaining 1% at other European institutes. Additional demographic figures can be found in Appendix A.1 . Figure 1: Left: Summary of the self-reported career stages of the respondents of this survey. Right: Experimental affiliation or field of study of respondents of this survey. 2.2 Project Enthusiasm The first section of the survey assessed excitement for the physics opportunities at various collider options, asking participants to rate their enthusiasm for each project on a scale of 1 (not excited at all) to 5 (extremely excited). The collider options offered for consideration were the FCC-ee, a linear electron-positron Higgs factory (such as CLIC or the ILC), an immediate FCC-hh at energy of {\sim}85 TeV, beginning operation in {\sim}2050 , a 3 TeV muon collider, and a 10 TeV muon collider. Respondents were encouraged to write-in collider scenarios not covered. The enthusiasm of the different physics cases can be summarized as follows: • The FCC-ee was given an average score of 3.2. There was large heterogeneity between responses, with 30% giving a 1 or 2, and 42% giving a 4 or 5. • A linear electron-positron Higgs factory received a similar average rating of 3.2, with similar heterogeneity. • The proposal for an 85 TeV FCC-hh starting in \sim 2050 had a slightly higher average rating of 3.7. There was moderate heterogeneity in responses, with 18% giving a 1 or 2 and 66% giving a 4 or 5. • The two muon collider options presented, 3 TeV and 10 TeV, received higher average scores of 4.1 and 4.6 respectively. There was minimal heterogeneity in responses, with 4% giving a 1 or 2 and 87% giving a 4 or 5. Common write-in options were the HE-LHC and LEP3, as well as as plasma-wakefield colliders such as HALHF were mentioned. Collider programs with similar physics program, like the CEPC, were also mentioned. Figure 2 provides a visual summary of the relative enthusiam-levels for the different physics cases. Appendix A.2 contains the full distributions for each collider scenario. Figure 2: Summary of excitement-level for the physics cases

Read the complete text