Bayesian and Monte Carlo approaches to estimating uncertainty for the measurement of the bound-state β − \beta^{-} decay of 205 Tl 81+

G. Leckenby, M. Trassinelli, R. J. Chen, R. S. Sidhu, J. Glorius, M. S. Sanjari, Yu. A. Litvinov, M. Bai, F. Bosch, C. Brandau, T. Dickel, I. Dillmann, D. Dmytriiev, T. Faestermann, O. Forstner, B. Franczak, H. Geissel, R. Gernhäuser, B. S. Gao, C. J. Griffin, A. Gumberidze, E. Haettner, R. Heß, P.- · 2025

Read Bayesian and Monte Carlo approaches to estimating uncertainty for the measurement of the bound-state β − \beta^{-} decay of 205 Tl 81+ by G. Leckenby, M. Trassinelli, R. J. Chen, R. S. Sidhu, J. Glorius, M. S. Sanjari, Yu. A. Litvinov, M. Bai, F. Bosch, C. Brandau, T. Dickel, I. Dillmann, D. Dmytriiev, T. Faestermann, O. Forstner, B. Franczak, H. Geissel, R. Gernhäuser, B. S. Gao, C. J. Griffin, A. Gumberidze, E. Haettner, R. Heß, P.- (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22822.txt.

Introduction

A rare kind of decay, where the electron stays bound to its atom, can serve as a clock for the young solar system and a meter for the Sun's ghost bits. The authors, a team of some sixty writing in 2025, measured that decay in a storage ring and here weigh how sure the count is. (The catalog author list is cut off mid-name; the head carries the full team.) The beam of thallium ions came with a lead twin that could not be fully kept out.

How much twin rode along swings the end count, so the team priced that swing two ways. A Bayesian build and a dice-roll build landed near each other, each with its own strengths. They urge both habits on future runs where hidden swings rule the error.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Leckenby, M. Trassinelli, R. J. Chen, R. S. Sidhu, J. Glorius, M. S. Sanjari, Yu. A. Litvinov, M. Bai, F. Bosch, C. Brandau, T. Dickel, I. Dillmann, D. Dmytriiev, T. Faestermann, O. Forstner, B. Franczak, H. Geissel, R. Gernhäuser, B. S. Gao, C. J. Griffin, A. Gumberidze, E. Haettner, R. Heß, P.-
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22822

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bayesian and Monte Carlo approaches to estimating uncertainty for the measurement of the bound-state β − \beta^{-} decay of 205 Tl 81+ G. Leckenby, M. Trassinelli, R. J. Chen, R. S. Sidhu, J. Glorius, M. S. Sanjari, Yu. A. Litvinov, M. Bai, F. Bosch, C. Brandau, T. Dickel, I. Dillmann, D. Dmytriiev, T. Faestermann, O. Forstner, B. Franczak, H. Geissel, R. Gernhäuser, B. S. Gao, C. J. Griffin, A. Gumberidze, E. Haettner, R. Heß, P.-M. Hillenbrand, P. Kienle, W. Korten, Ch. Kozhuharov, N. Kuzminchuk, S. Litvinov, E. B. Menz, T. Morgenroth, C. Nociforo, F. Nolden, N. Petridis, U. Popp, S. Purushothaman, R. Reifarth, C. Scheidenberger, U. Spillmann, M. Steck, Th. Stöhlker, Y. K. Tanaka, S. Trotsenko, L. Varga, M. Wang, H. Weick, P. J. Woods, T. Yamaguchi, Y. H. Zhang, J. W. Zhao Abstract The measurement of the bound-state β \beta decay of 205 Tl at the Experimental Storage Ring (ESR) at GSI, Darmstadt, has recently been reported with substantial impact on the use of 205 Pb as an early Solar System chronometer and the low-energy measurement of the solar neutrino spectrum via the LOREX project. Due to the technical challenges in producing a high-purity 205 Tl 81+ secondary beam, a robust statistical method needed to be developed to estimate the variation in the contaminant 205 Pb 81+ produced in the fragmentation reaction, which was subsequently transmitted and stored in the ESR. Here we show that Bayesian and Monte Carlo methods produced comparable estimates for the contaminant variation, each with unique advantages and challenges given the complex statistical problems for this experiment. We recommend the adoption of such methods in future experiments that exhibit unknown statistical fluctuations. Keywords : bound-state β \beta decay, heavy-ion storage rings, uncertainty estimation, Bayesian methods, Monte Carlo methods I Introduction Bound-state \beta^{-} decay ( \beta_{b} decay) has proven to be a rare but consequential decay mode in astrophysical events because it has the potential to vastly alter the decay properties of certain nuclei [ 1 , 2 ] . In this decay mode, the \beta electron is created in a bound-state of the daughter nucleus, which can significantly enhance the Q value of the decay for very high charge states. Takahashi et al. [ 3 ] were the first to catalogue key isotopes where bound-state \beta decay had a large impact on the decay rate, and this was soon backed up by the first measurements at the Experimental Storage Ring (ESR) at GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung in Darmstadt, Germany [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . The technical challenges involved in storing millions of fully-stripped ions for several hours mean that, presently, the ESR is the only facility capable of directly measuring bound-state \beta decay [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Recently, we reported on the first measurement of the \beta_{b} decay of 205 Tl 81+ [ 11 , 12 ] . This measurement was crucial in establishing the weak decay rates of 205 Tl and 205 Pb in the core of Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) stars, the nucleosynthetic site for the cosmochronometer 205 Pb that is valuable in early Solar System studies. Additionally, the \beta_{b} -decay rate of 205 Tl 81+ was required for the Lorandite Experiment (LOREX), which aims to use the Tl-bearing mineral lorandite to achieve the lowest-threshold measurement of the solar neutrino spectrum, sensitive to E_{\nu_{e}}\geq 53~$\mathrm{k}\mathrm{e}\mathrm{V}$ [ 13 ] . An accurate estimation of uncertainties on experimental measurements are paramount in nuclear astrophysics, especially when trying to determine whether discrepancies originate from nuclear data or astrophysical modelling. For the \beta_{b} decay of 205 Tl 81+ , our experimental half-life is 4.7 times longer than the values presently used in the astrophysical community [ 14 ] , although agrees with modern shell-model calculations [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] , so an accurate uncertainty was crucial in order to assess the impact of the experiment. The analysis we presented in Refs. [ 11 , 12 ] , with further details in the theses [ 18 , 19 ] , was quite complex involving four corrections and a fit with experimentally measured parameters. This analysis demanded careful handling of the correlations between data points and a fit to a model with uncertain parameters, which required methods more sophisticated than the traditional \chi^{2} minimisation. Furthermore, we identified in Refs. [ 11 , 12 ] that the measured uncertainties on the corrections, which we refer to as the “raw uncertainties,” do not sufficiently describe the scatter of the data. To address both these issues, we developed a Monte Carlo error propagation that included a method for self-consistently estimating the “missing uncertainty” and including it in the determination of the model parameters, namely the decay-rate of 205 Tl 81+ . This Monte Carlo method extends a Frequentist framework to deal with experimentally determined parameters and missing uncertainty, however, Bayesian methods also naturally handle these issues in a self-consistent way. In this work we compare the two approaches for the decay-rate estimation. Additionally, we explore how the Bayesian approach can efficiently handle outlier data points, which we had to exclude manually in our original analysis. To further investigate the origin of the missing uncertainty, we also present a new, dedicated analysis of the statistical uncertainties. Due to the presence of beam losses, this analysis is not trivial and it has been further developed here to take into account the Poisson nature of the recorded signals. In Sec. II , we briefly introduce the experimental method. Since the experimental method and analysis corrections have been described elsewhere, we refer the interested reader to the provided references for further details. The Monte Carlo uncertainty estimation method is then presented in Sec. III , with Poisson counting statistics described in Sec. IV . The alternative Bayesian analysis in then presented Sec. V , with a discussion on the comparison of the methods in Sec. VI and a conclusion in Sec. VII . II Experimental Method In our experimental analysis, the sources of uncertainty for each datum depend on the method for producing and detecting the ions. To measure the \beta_{b} decay of 205 Tl, ions need to be stored in the storage ring in the fully-stripped charge state as only \beta_{b} decay to the K shell of the daughter nucleus is energetically allowed. To do so, a secondary 205 Tl 81+ beam was created via projectile fragmentation of a primary 206 Pb 67+ beam using the entire accelerator chain at GSI. The main contaminant of concern was 205 Pb 81+ , as it has only a 31.1(5) keV mass difference compared to 205 Tl 81+ and is also the \beta_{b} -decay daughter product, which directly confounds the decay signal. To minimise this contamination, the Fragment Separator (FRS) was used, where an aluminium energy degrader produced a spatial separation at the exit of the FRS via the B\rho – \Delta E – B\rho method [ 20 ] . With this setting, 205 Pb 81+ contamination was reduced to \sim 0.1\% . Roughly 10^{6} 205 Tl 81+ ions were accumulated in the ESR from over 100 injections from the FRS. These ions were then stored in the ring for various periods up to 10 hours

Read the complete text