Maximilian Detering
a · 2025
Read Maximilian Detering by a (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22787.txt.
Introduction
Detering and co-authors present a report, published in 2025, on why the Higgs boson may sit at the edge of stability. The Higgs gives other particles their mass, and its own mass helps decide whether the universe's energy state is truly stable. New physics at modest energies could tip that state toward decay. There is a highest Higgs mass that keeps the state just barely stable over the universe's life. The authors review the idea that our Higgs sits exactly at that bound.
If so, the new physics enforcing the bound lies within reach of planned colliders. Experiments could then find it, or rule the idea out. That makes the hypothesis unusually testable for such a deep claim. The report sums up recent work on the bound and its ties to the puzzle of the Higgs mass. It frames a target for the next generation of machines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | a |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22787
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Maximilian Detering a Abstract New physics at the TeV scale or lower may destabilise the electroweak vacuum. How low could the vacuum instability scale be? This fundamental question may be tied to a deeper understanding of the Higgs potential and its associated hierarchy problem. The scale of vacuum instability can be viewed as an upper bound on the Higgs mass—the so-called vacuum metastability bound—and criticality of the Higgs potential through some underlying mechanism then places our universe at this metastable point. In this report, we summarise recent work developing this eminently testable hypothesis. If the vacuum metastability bound plays a role in determining the properties of the Higgs boson, the new physics responsible will likely be discovered or excluded in the entire natural region of parameter space at future facilities. This makes it a tantalising and attractive target for future colliders. Higgs Criticality and the Metastability Bound: a target for future colliders 1 Motivation 1.1 The hierarchy problem as a fundamental challenge to modern particle physics In our modern understanding, quantum field theories are really Effective Field Theories (EFTs) whose Lagrangian terms are controlled by symmetries, thus leading to the expectation of “natural” values for their coefficients (see e.g. Ref. [ 1 ] for a review). The limitations of this paradigm have been revealed by two of the most consequential open problems of modern fundamental physics, the electroweak (EW) hierarchy problem and the cosmological constant problem. In the Standard Model (SM), the cosmological constant and Higgs mass are unprotected by symmetry. Quantum fluctuations therefore contribute large corrections to their bare parameter values (which are expected to be calculable in terms of more fundamental parameters in the UV theory) up to the cut-off scale of the EFT that could be as high as the Planck scale. The tiny vacuum energy and Higgs mass measured in our universe must then be the result of fine-tuned cancellations to an inconceivable number of digits between the bare parameters and unrelated quantum corrections. In the case of the Higgs mass, such a contrived situation could be avoided if new physics with additional symmetries exist close to the EW scale. The absence of such new physics at the LHC and the failure of symmetry-based solutions for addressing the cosmological constant motivate exploring alternative solutions to the hierarchy problem. Starting with the so-called relaxion mechanism [ 2 ] , the last decade has seen renewed speculations about the observed Higgs mass originating from a landscape of values with some cosmological selection mechanism. Here we summarise a different approach based on the observation that avoiding the instability and collapse of the electroweak vacuum places an upper bound on the Higgs mass. This so-called vacuum metastability bound could then explain the hierarchy problem if a dynamical mechanism for achieving criticality of the Higgs potential selects a metastable vacuum at the edge of a quantum phase transition. 1.2 Metastability bound The increasing pressure experiments put on natural symmetry-based solutions to the EW hierarchy problem calls for the exploration of possibilities beyond the paradigm of symmetry. The hierarchy problem can be viewed as understanding the scale of the EW vacuum, determined by the Higgs potential, V(H)=-\mu_{H}^{2}H^{\dagger}H+\lambda_{H}(H^{\dagger}H)^{2}, (1) where H is the Higgs doublet and the Higgs parameters receive radiative corrections. While the EW symmetry is broken spontaneously for -\mu_{H}^{2}<0 , the existence of the EW vacuum also requires \lambda_{H}>0 . The renormalisation group (RG) evolution of the Higgs quartic coupling can lead to an instability of the Higgs potential with a negative quartic coupling in the ultraviolet (UV). A non-trivial vacuum may therefore only exist below the instability scale \mu_{I} given by the renormalisation scale of vanishing quartic coupling, \lambda(\mu_{I})=0, (2) where \lambda represents the quartic coupling including relevant loop-level corrections. The observed values for the SM parameters suggest a large value for this instability scale of about {10}^{10}\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV} [ 3 , 4 ] . As illustrated in Fig. 1 , the properties of the Higgs potential in the infrared (IR) are controlled by the mass parameter. For a small mass parameter, the potential has a metastable minimum in the IR similar to the EW vacuum. For large mass parameters, in particular larger than the instability scale, this vacuum disappears. Figure 1 : Shape of the Higgs potential for different values of the mass parameter \mu_{H}^{2} . The IR vacuum only exists for small values of the mass parameter. These two regimes are separated by a critical value corresponding to the metastability bound , first introduced in Ref. [ 4 ] (see also Refs. [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] ), \mu_{H}^{2}\lesssim\mu_{\rm crit}^{2}\equiv\frac{1}{2}e^{-3/2}|\beta_{\lambda}(\mu_{I})|\mu_{I}^{2}. (3) Note that the left-hand side of the metastability bound is not the physical Higgs mass but the Lagrangian parameter. At tree-level, these are simply related by m_{h}^{2}=2\mu_{H}^{2} . This bound is generated through dimensional transmutation from the RG evolution of the Higgs self-coupling and can thus be exponentially separated from the scale of UV completion, \Lambda_{\text{UV}}\gg\mu_{I} , see Refs. [ 5 , 6 ] for more details. The EW hierarchy problem may then be understood through the metastability bound if a mechanism of vacuum selection preferentially selecting a minimum in the IR with broken EW symmetry generates a sufficiently tight bound [ 5 , 10 , 6 , 11 ] . The metastability bound is however agnostic to the nature of the vacuum selection mechanism, even if not independent of their existence. Viable realisations are briefly reviewed in the following section. In contrast to conventional natural solutions to the hierarchy problem, the scale of UV completion of the SM does not have to be a loop factor larger than the Higgs mass, m_{h}^{2}\sim\text{loop-factor}\times\Lambda_{\text{UV}}^{2} , but can be exponentially separated from the instability scale, \mu_{I}\ll\Lambda_{\text{UV}} [ 6 ] . In the SM, the large instability scale constrains the mass parameter only to be below \mathcal{O}(${10}^{10}\text{\,}\mathrm{GeV}$) , leaving the remaining hierarchy unexplained. As we discuss in Sect. 3 , well-motivated extensions of the SM can however exhibit an instability at lower scales around the TeV. 2 Mechanisms achieving Higgs metastability An important feature of the metastability bound in Eq. ( 3 ) is that it follows immediately from the structure of the Higgs potential and is sensitive only to the running of the quartic coupling. This implies in particular that whether or not the Higgs mass is controlled by this inequality can be answered independently from the question of why this is the case. This generality represents one of the strongest motivations to consider this scenario, in addition to its distinct experimental signatures. Nevertheless, and for illustration, we briefly discuss in this section three examples of fundamentally different approaches justifying a metastable vacuum from underlying physics. These encompass: i) a dynamical attractor in the early Universe; ii) statistical arguments in theories with a large number of vacua; and iii) a cosmological crunch argument. 2.1 Self-organised localisation Self-organised criticality of a scalar field undergoing quantum fluctuations during inflation can localise it near the critical point on the verge of a quantum phase transition. The stochastic dynamics of the scalar field are described by a probability distribution governed by the Fokker-Planck equation with a volume term—the Fokker-Planck Volume (FPV) equation—to account for Hubble patches with higher