Breaching the light barrier without paradoxes
Abhishek Mehta · 2025
Read Breaching the light barrier without paradoxes by Abhishek Mehta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22704.txt.
Introduction
Particles that outrun light have haunted physics with time paradoxes: in some frames they seem to travel backward, letting effects precede causes. Abhishek Kumar Mehta proposes a fix in this 2025 paper that needs no reinterpretation trick. His regularization principle rewrites a backward-moving tachyon's impossible momentum as an endless sum of forward-moving momenta, using properties of the zeta function.
Because the particle then moves forward in time in every frame, the classic paradoxes dissolve. The paper also follows the idea outward, to the censorship of naked singularities and to faster-than-light messaging. The claim is bold: faster-than-light travel at the large scale could be consistent with causality, at least on paper. The work is a mathematical proposal, offered for scrutiny rather than as an experimental result.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abhishek Mehta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22704
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Breaching the light barrier without paradoxes Abhishek Mehta Abstract In this paper, we propose the regularization principle that resolves the temporal paradoxes associated with faster-than-light particles or tachyons at the macroscopic scale. The principle involves using the properties of the ζ \zeta -function to regularize the unphysical momenta of tachyons that moves backwards in-time as an infinite sum of physical tachyon momenta that travel forwards in-time. Since the tachyon moves forward in-time in all Lorentz frames, this ensures that the tachyon processes are paradox-free without invoking the Reinterpretation Principle (RIP). Apart from resolving these paradoxes associated with faster-than-light particles, its other notable consequences especially pertaining to the censorship of naked singularities and faster-than-light communication are also discussed. keywords Tachyons, Black holes, Cosmic Censorship, Zeta function 1 Introduction Tachyons refer to hypothetical particles that have coordinate speed exceeding the speed of light Bilaniuk and Sudarshan, 1969 . Due to the temporal inconsistencies associated with tachyons at the macroscopic scale Shoshany, 2019 , they are mostly considered unphysical and are therefore, eliminated from theories via intricate formalisms like the Higgs’ mechanism Peskin, 2018 and supersymmetry Schwarz, 2012 or by interpreting them as artifacts of an unstable or incorrect vacuum in a field theory Tong, 2009 . Despite that, several attempts are continually made to develop a consistent tachyonic mechanics Bilaniuk and Sudarshan, 1969 ; Maccarrone and Recami, 1980 ; Caldirola and Recami, 1980 ; Recami, 1984 . The tachyon mechanics that are formulated exclusively rely on a frame-dependent reinterpretation of the tachyon processes where the emission of tachyons that move backwards in-time are reinterpreted as an absorption or vice-versa Bilaniuk and Sudarshan, 1969 . However, this reinterpretation is not sufficient to rule out the temporal paradoxes completely for more complicated tachyon processes Benford et al., 1970 . It is also argued that the reinterpretation principle implies that the tachyon is more akin to a force-carrier and therefore, would only play a role as “internal lines” in particle interactions. This means that these paradoxes are no longer of any relevance as they assume the existence of free, modulated tachyon radiation to work Recami, 1984 ; Recami and Rodrigues Jr, 1985 . This understanding is also echoed in recent investigations where tachyons are incorporated in models of cosmology, dark matter and quantum gravity Schwartz, 2025 ; Mandal et al., 2025 ; Ilkhchi et al., 2025 . Therefore, the reinterpretation principle inevitably leads to tachyons being restricted to quantum regimes with no classical analogues Paczos et al., 2024 . In this paper, we present a novel departure from the existing means of preserving tachyon causality in the literature. In order to describe a macroscopic tachyon mechanics, we instead propose a ‘regularization’ principle of tachyons that move backwards in-time. We use momentum conservation to first identify emission and absorption processes involving only tachyons that move forwards in-time. This imposes a selection rule on the sign of the tachyon mass parameters depending on the process. The selection rule forces us to work with negative mass particles to ensure that the tachyon signals travel forwards in-time in the reference frames of emitters and receivers. To further avoid the RIP, we regularize the momenta of tachyons moving backwards in-time as an infinite sum of tachyon momenta that travel forward in-time which, referred to as the ‘tachyon shower’, using the properties of the \zeta -function. This ensures that tachyons travel forwards in-time in all frames of references related by Lorentz transformations either as a single particle or a shower of particles effectively resolving all temporal paradoxes. This has an interesting consequence on faster-than-light communications i.e. in certain frames information encoded in tachyon signals may be become unintelligible due to Inter-Symbol Interference (ISI). Additionally, we demonstrate that paradox-free tachyons play an essential role to censorship of naked singularities in General Relativity (GR). 2 Two-way Tachyonic antitelephone The two-way tachyonic antitelephone Benford et al., 1970 is the most significant thought-experiment that makes tachyons physically nonviable. To see this, consider two inertial observers A and B initially at point (0,0) with A having a worldline (t,vt) in B ’s frame where v<1 . At t=T , B decides to communicate with A via a Tachyonic signal that has the worldline (T+\lambda,u\lambda) in B ’s frame where u>1 . In B ’s frame, the signal must reach A at \lambda_{0} given by \displaystyle(T+\lambda_{0},u\lambda_{0})=(t_{0},vt_{0}) (2.1) \displaystyle\implies t_{0}=\frac{Tu}{u-v}\quad\lambda_{0}=\frac{Tv}{u-v} (2.2) Now in A ’s frame, the worldline for the Tachyonic signal is given by a Lorentz transformation i.e. \displaystyle\gamma(T+(1-uv)\lambda,-vT+(u-v)\lambda)\quad\gamma=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^{2}}} (2.3) where one can have (1-uv)<0 for a sufficiently high u . This means that in the range (0,\lambda_{0}) , A will experience the signal going backwards in-time. This is a violation of causality and therefore, is a well-known paradox, called the Tolmann paradox, in tachyonic communication. 2.1 Constraints from momentum conservation In order to resolve the paradox, any tachyon process must involve only tachyons that move forwards in-time. Therefore, we must consider only those processes that emit or absorb tachyons that move forward in-time in the frame of the emitter or receiver, i.e. a particle that absorbs tachyon, respectively. We parametrize the four-momenta of a tachyonic beam in (-,+,+,+) signature as \displaystyle p^{\mu}=\begin{cases}&\left(\frac{m}{\sqrt{u^{2}-1}},\frac{m\vec{u}}{\sqrt{u^{2}-1}}\right)\equiv m(\Gamma,\vec{u}\Gamma)\quad\text{Forwards in-time}\\ &\left(-\frac{m}{\sqrt{u^{2}-1}},\frac{m\vec{u}}{\sqrt{u^{2}-1}}\right)\equiv m(-\Gamma,\vec{u}\Gamma)\penalty\ \text{Backwards in-time}\end{cases}\quad u>1 \displaystyle\implies p^{2}=m^{2} (2.4) where we call m the mass parameter of the tachyon. In the above, we have utilized the Feynman-Stuckelberg interpretation to identify the tachyon four-momenta with negative energy as the one travelling backwards in-time Thomson, 2013 . According to the Feynmann-Stuckelberg interpretation, particles that travel backwards in-time appear to us with their energies and charges having their signs flipped. That is why negative energy electrons, when traveling backwards in-time, appear to us as positrons with positive energy. In the same manner, positive energy tachyons traveling backwards in-time will appear to us as negative energy tachyons. Hence, the above parametrization. Consider now a process that involves tachyon absorption. The tachyon receiver is made up of rest mass M . Due to conservation of momentum, we have \displaystyle P^{\mu}+p^{\mu}=\bar{P}^{\mu} (2.5) where P^{\mu},\bar{P}^{\mu} are the initial and the final four-momenta of the Tachyon receiver and p^{\mu} is the four-momenta of the Tachyon. We choose the following ansatz for P^{\mu},\bar{P}^{\mu} \displaystyle P^{\mu}=(M,0,0,0)\quad\bar{P}^{\mu}=M(\gamma,\vec{w}\gamma)\quad\gamma=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-w^{2}}} (2.6) which leads to the following equations for the different kinds of Tachyonic signals \displaystyle M(\gamma-1)-m\Gamma=0\quad m\vec{u}\Gamma=M\vec{w}\gamma\quad\text{Forwards in-time} \displaystyle M(\gamma-1)+m\Gamma=0\quad m\vec{u}\Gamma=M\vec{w}\gamma\quad\text{Backwards in-time} (2.7) Notice that the momentum conservation do not hold simultaneously for tachyonic signals moving forwards and backwards in-time. Therefore, for tachyons moving forward in-time, we must have m>0 . But for tachyonic signals of m>0 moving backwards in-time, momentum conservation doesn’t hold unless the receiver is made of negative mass i.e. M<0 . This implies that, in general, we must have the following selection-rule \displaystyle\operatorname{sgn}(M/m)=1 (2.8) to ensure that only the tachyonic signals that move forward in-time are absorbed in the frame of the receiver in an absorption process. Let us now discuss tachyonic emission. Consider a Tachyon emitter made of ordinary matter of rest mass M emitting a tachyon. From momentum conservation, we then have \displaystyle P^{\mu}=p^{\mu}+\bar{P}^{\mu} (2.9) which leads to the following equations for the different kinds of Tachyonic signals \displaystyle M(\gamma-1)+m\Gamma=0\quad m\vec{u}\Gamma+M\vec{w}\gamma=0\quad\text{Forwards in time} \displaystyle M(\gamma-1)-m\Gamma=0\quad m\vec{u}\Gamma+M\vec{w}\gamma=0\quad\text{Backwards in time} (2.10) Again the momentum conservation do not hold simultaneously for tachyonic signals moving