Effect of irradiation model on 2D hydrodynamic simulations of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs
Caitriona S. Leedham, Richard A. Booth, Cathie. J. Clarke · 2025
Read Effect of irradiation model on 2D hydrodynamic simulations of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs by Caitriona S. Leedham, Richard A. Booth, Cathie. J. Clarke (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22667.txt.
Introduction
Young discs of gas around newborn stars can grow heavy enough that their gravity stirs them into spirals, moving matter inward and building planets. Starlight heating should calm that unrest, especially in the outer disc. Caitriona Leedham, Richard Booth, and Cathie Clarke ask how much the answer depends on the way heating is put into the model, comparing two recipes in two-dimensional simulations.
When heating was spread by mass, the unrest died out once starlight became the heat source, as expected. When heating was spread evenly by area, the unrest survived under strong starlight and high stability readings, matching theory. Discs could still break into fragments in that regime, though the cooling had to be faster as the heating rose. The team caps the viscosity in that state at roughly 0.03 to 0.09. Their point is practical: the recipe chosen for starlight can flip what a simulation predicts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Caitriona S. Leedham, Richard A. Booth, Cathie. J. Clarke |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22667
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effect of irradiation model on 2D hydrodynamic simulations of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs Caitriona S. Leedham, Richard A. Booth, Cathie. J. Clarke Abstract Young protoplanetary discs are expected to be gravitationally unstable, which can drive angular momentum transport as well as be a potential mechanism for planet formation. Gravitational instability is most prevalent in the outer disc where cooling timescales are short. At large radii, stellar irradiation makes a significant contribution to disc heating and is expected to suppress instability. In this study, we compare two models of implementing irradiation in 2D hydrodynamic simulations of self-gravitating discs: supplying a constant heating rate per unit mass and per unit area of the disc. In the former case, instability is quenched once the stellar irradiation becomes the dominant heating source. In the latter case, we find instability persists under high levels of irradiation, despite large values of the Toomre Q parameter, in agreement with analytic predictions. Fragmentation was able to occur in this regime with the critical cooling timescale required decreasing as irradiation is increased, corresponding to a maximum threshold for the viscosity parameter: α ∼ 0.03 − 0.09 \alpha\sim 0.03-0.09 . 2024 Effect of irradiation model on 2D hydrodynamic simulations of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs – A 1 Introduction Protoplanetary discs form around young stars as infalling material is flattened into a disc due to angular momentum conservation. Young discs are dominated by their gas component and can be massive enough to be self-gravitating. The destabilising force of gravity can overcome support from pressure and centrifugal forces, causing regions of gas to clump together. The potential for gravitational instability (GI) has considerable implications for the evolution of the disc and planet formation. The formation of bound objects via the runaway collapse of overdensities (fragmentation) has been proposed to explain the high occurrence rate of binary stars ( Clarke, 2009 ) and to account for the formation of giant planets at large orbital radii ( Boss, 1997 ) . Additionally, non-axisymmetric structures induced by GI, such as spiral arms ( Lynden-Bell & Kalnajs, 1972 ) , facilitate angular momentum transport – a critical process in accretion disc theory that enables material to flow inward. Previous studies have emphasised that an important role for GI, both in terms of planet formation and driving significant angular momentum transfer, relates to the ratio of the cooling time to the dynamical time. Consequently, the regions where GI is potentially important are limited to the outer parts of the disc ( r\gtrsim 40AU , Rafikov (2005) ; Matzner & Levin (2005) ; Stamatellos & Whitworth (2008) ; Clarke (2009) ; Forgan & Rice (2011) ). However, these regions are precisely where it can be expected that external heating of the disc by stellar irradiation is significant ( D’Alessio et al., 1999 ; Kratter & Lodato, 2016 ) . The regime of short cooling time and strong irradiation is therefore an important one to understand but previous studies are unclear about the behaviour of the disc in this region. In this paper we focus on simulations that explore this regime in detail. The linear theory described by Toomre (1964) applies perturbations to a 2D self-gravitating axisymmetric rotating disc. The onset of instability is characterised by the Toomre parameter: Q=\frac{c_{s}\Omega}{\pi G\Sigma}, (1) which represents the balance of self-gravity against pressure and centrifugal forces. Low and less stable values of Q are found at large radii where the disc is cooler. Classically, Q<1 is required for instability, however, realistic discs will undergo heating and cooling processes that allow them to thermally saturate at higher values of Q . As regions of the disc collapse, Q decreases and the increased heating rate due to shock dissipation will stabilise overdensities. As they expand, the heating rate decreases and the disc begins to cool again. This self-regulated state ( Paczynski, 1978 ) is known as gravitoturbulence and numerical simulations show discs saturate with Q\approx 1-2 ( Lodato & Rice, 2004 ; Rice et al., 2011 ) . Gravitoturbulence is sensitive to the thermodynamics of the disc. Heating due to shocks acts to increase Q , whereas radiative cooling will decrease Q towards instability. The more efficient the cooling, the higher the rate of heating required to balance it. Cooling is often implemented using the \beta –prescription ( Gammie, 2001 ) , where \beta=\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\Omega is the ratio of the cooling timescale of the disc material to the orbital timescale. \beta is a decreasing function of radius such that larger radii have shorter cooling times ( Rafikov, 2005 ; Clarke, 2009 ) . The effective viscosity can be modelled by the Shakura & Sunyaev (1973) prescription, \nu=\alpha c_{s}H , where \alpha is a dimensionless parameter measuring the efficiency of angular momentum transport due to turbulence. Assuming thermal equilibrium in the saturated state leads to an inverse relationship between \alpha and \beta : \alpha=\frac{4}{9\gamma(\gamma-1)\beta} , derived by Gammie (2001) and similarly by Mamatsashvili & Rice (2009) using the total energy equation. This relation assumes the energy associated with angular momentum transport is dissipated locally, which has been tested numerically using global simulations and shown to be a good approximation ( Lodato & Rice, 2004 ; Lodato & Rice, 2005 ; Cossins et al., 2009 ) . A further source of heating is irradiation from the central star. While incident flux decreases with orbital radius, it does so less steeply than internal heating in the disc ( Kratter & Lodato, 2016 ) . At large radii, it becomes a significant contribution to the overall heating. High levels of irradiation are expected to stabilise the disc by raising the value of Q . However, the outer disc is also where the cooling timescale becomes short, making the disc more susceptible to fragmentation. Thus it is import to understand the role of irradiation in these outer regions and whether they do, or do not, satisfy conditions required for planet formation by GI. How irradiation is incorporated in realistic disc simulations is complicated by optical depth effects and the computational cost of radiative transfer models. A common simplification used in 2D local disc models is to include a constant added rate of energy determined by the stellar luminosity and radial location in the disc ( Rice et al., 2011 ; Baehr & Klahr, 2015 ) to the energy equation. Irradiation creates an effective heat bath and imposes a background sound speed. It is expected that once this sound speed implies Q>1 , a gravitoturbulent state cannot be maintained. This additional term has been treated in various ways in previous studies with a clear difference being whether or not the heating rate per unit area depends on surface density. Linear analysis studies show distinctly different behaviours depending on the choice made ( Lin & Kratter, 2016 ) . Density dependence provides an extra stabilising term such that at large levels of irradiation implying Q\gtrsim 1-2 , there are no unstable solutions. Alternatively, without it, unstable solutions remain for arbitrarily high irradiation. This has been seen in numerical simulations, such as Rice et al. (2011) , who simulate the first case and find no evidence of instability for highly irradiated discs. However, using the latter case, Löhnert et al. (2020) find active GI for