On the effects of parameters on galaxy properties in CAMELS and the predictability of Ω m \Omega_{\rm m}

Gabriella Contardo, Roberto Trotta, Serafina Di Gioia, David W. Hogg, Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro · 2025

Read On the effects of parameters on galaxy properties in CAMELS and the predictability of Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} by Gabriella Contardo, Roberto Trotta, Serafina Di Gioia, David W. Hogg, Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22654.txt.

Introduction

Gabriella Contardo and co-authors ask, in a 2025 study, whether the traits of one galaxy can reveal how much matter the universe holds. They work with CAMELS, a large set of simulated universes, and focus on two suites named IllustrisTNG and ASTRID. Past work found that machine learning could infer the matter share from a single galaxy. The team tests why that odd feat works.

They find that the matter share shifts the whole spread of galaxy traits in a strong, clear way. Most other settings barely move that spread. One stellar feedback setting does cause some overlap, but the right traits can break the tie. The two suites still differ from each other, so the authors warn that real sky data will be far harder than the simulations suggest.

Catalog record

CREATORGabriella Contardo, Roberto Trotta, Serafina Di Gioia, David W. Hogg, Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22654

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the effects of parameters on galaxy properties in CAMELS and the predictability of Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} Gabriella Contardo, Roberto Trotta, Serafina Di Gioia, David W. Hogg, Francisco Villaescusa-Navarro Abstract Recent analyses of cosmological hydrodynamic simulations from CAMELS have shown that machine learning models can predict the parameter describing the total matter content of the universe, Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} , from the features of a single galaxy. We investigate the statistical properties of two of these simulation suites, IllustrisTNG and ASTRID , confirming that Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} induces a strong displacement on the distribution of galaxy features. We also observe that most other parameters have little to no effect on the distribution, except for the stellar-feedback parameter A S ​ N ​ 1 A_{SN1} , which introduces some near-degeneracies that can be broken with specific features. These two properties explain the predictability of Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} . We use Optimal Transport to further measure the effect of parameters on the distribution of galaxy properties, which is found to be consistent with physical expectations. However, we observe discrepancies between the two simulation suites, both in the effect of Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} on the galaxy properties and in the distributions themselves at identical parameter values. Thus, although Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} ’s signature can be easily detected within a given simulation suite using just a single galaxy, applying this result to real observational data may prove significantly more challenging. I Introduction A series of recent works ( Villaescusa-Navarro et al. 2022 ; Echeverri-Rojas et al. 2023 ; Wang & Pisani 2024 ; Chawak et al. 2024 ) have investigated the possibility of predicting cosmological and astrophysical parameters from the astronomical features of a single (or few) galaxies, using machine learning (ML) and the CAMELS simulations, which vary a set of cosmological parameters (e.g. \Omega_{\rm m} , \sigma_{8} ) and sets of astrophysical parameters controlling e.g. the galactic winds speed and energy or black hole feedback. From these simulations, one can extract catalogs of galaxies with their astronomical properties such as gas mass, stellar mass, metallicity, etc. Using these catalogs, Villaescusa-Navarro et al. 2022 ; Echeverri-Rojas et al. 2023 showed that a machine learning model could successfully learn to predict \Omega_{\rm m} from the features of an individual galaxy with a \sim 10\% precision. Thus, within the context of a given suite of simulations, it seemed that the information of a single galaxy is sufficient to characterize \Omega_{\rm m} , “marginalizing” over the other astrophysical processes modeled in CAMELS. One astrophysical parameter, A_{SN1} , also seemed predictable but to lesser precision. The ML approaches tested could not predict the other parameters in the same way. As pointed out by Villaescusa-Navarro et al. 2022 , this result indicates that the “galaxy properties live in manifolds that change with the value of \Omega_{\rm m} ” –or that at least a subset of the galaxy’s properties are significantly impacted by \Omega_{\rm m} . Chawak et al. 2024 extended this line of work to a slightly larger number of galaxies (up to 10), and Hahn et al. 2023 applied these ideas to real data using galaxy photometry observations for cosmological parameters inference but using a much larger set of galaxies ( \sim 14,000 ). However, Echeverri-Rojas et al. 2023 and Chawak et al. 2024 showed that the performance can degrade when transferring between different suites, i.e. training on one and testing on another. For instance, in Echeverri-Rojas et al. 2023 (see Figure 4), a model trained on SIMBA performed significantly worse on both IllustrisTNG and ASTRID ; ASTRID seemed to provide the best results (or the least degradation) when used as a training set, but still exhibited a bias in prediction on IllustrisTNG (consistently over-predicting). Training on IllustrisTNG seemed to lead to performances that are not as biased but with larger errors and scatter. More important degradations were observed in Chawak et al. 2024 using more than one galaxy (specifically 10): in this work, while the prediction precision within a suite was significantly improved by using more than one galaxy, the performance when transferring to different suites was even more degraded than in the single galaxy case. These results indicate some distributional differences between suites in terms of galaxy population properties, which is expected since those suites were run using different codes that have different astrophysics implementations. For instance, while IllustrisTNG and SIMBA use a fixed blackhole seed mass (respectively 8\times{10}^{5}h^{-1}M_{\odot} and 1\times{10}^{4}h^{-1}M_{\odot} ), in ASTRID the blackhole seed mass is drawn from a power-law sampling masses in the range ( 3\times{10}^{4}h^{-1}M_{\odot} , 3\times{10}^{5}h^{-1}M_{\odot} ). The stellar mass threshold adopted in SIMBA for the BH seeding is also significantly bigger than the one adopted in IllustrisTNG ( Bird et al. 2022 ) . Another possibly important aspect is that SIMBA and IllustrisTNG have been calibrated using observational summary statistics and scaling relation at z=0 ( Pillepich et al. 2018a ) , while ASTRID simulations have been calibrated only against the observed UV galaxy luminosity function at z=4 ( Bird et al. 2022 ) . These discrepancies might impact inference results: Busillo et al. 2023 showed that the constraints obtained for \Omega_{\rm m} , using the SPARC sample with the structural properties and dark matter content of star-forming galaxies, differed widely between suites. Some of these derived constraints were inconsistent with current constraints from other observables: IllustrisTNG gives \Omega_{\rm m} =0.27 , ASTRID gives \Omega_{\rm m} =0.44 , and SIMBA \Omega_{\rm m} =0.14 . Their work also showed that the fiducial runs based on SIMBA and ASTRID suites predict that, at fixed stellar mass, masses of the central dark matter haloes are larger than those observed. This implies that for a given stellar mass, galaxies in ASTRID will reside in more massive haloes compared to IllustrisTNG . Since we expect galaxies at a similar mass to reside in more massive haloes when \Omega_{\rm m} increases ( Lue et al. 2025 ) , this is a factor, among others, that will impact a potential inference on \Omega_{\rm m} . Understanding and quantifying these differences are thus crucial to improving our fundamental comprehension of how numerical implementations and modelling choices impact galaxy formation and evolution and to identifying potential systematic biases that could impact subsequent methods. In this spirit, Lue et al. 2025 recently presented a follow-up analysis of Villaescusa-Navarro et al. 2022 results, using Information-Ordered Bottleneck auto-encoding to investigate the effects of parameters on the reconstruction, putting in perspective scatter from the cosmic variance at a fiducial setting and the variance or effects induced by parametrization change. Some of the concerns about the results of Villaescusa-Navarro et al. 2022 and follow-up works can be summarized with the following key points: first, galaxy formation is far from being completely resolved, and the assumptions made in the hydro-simulations are known to be approximated at most; additionally, incomplete or incorrect sub-grid physics, as well as the limitations of simulations’ volumes, could impact our conclusions regarding the real universe, as seen in e.g. Busillo et al. 2023 . Second, the impact of the priors used when building the simulations (e.g. choice of astrophysical parameters, their ranges, etc) could be the main driver of the observed results –this aspect

Read the complete text