Learnable cut flow for high energy physics
Jing Li, and Hao Sun · 2025
Read Learnable cut flow for high energy physics by Jing Li, and Hao Sun (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22498.txt.
Introduction
Particle physicists sort signal from background by cutting events on measured quantities, a method called cut flow. It reads easily but is slow to tune by hand, while neural networks tune themselves yet hide their logic. Jing Li and Hao Sun merge the two in the Learnable Cut Flow, a network that turns cut selection into a trainable process. It learns boundaries in two styles, treating each observable alone or letting early cuts shape later ones, and it adds a learned importance score per feature.
A softened loss replaces hard cuts with masks so training flows through the network. On six mock datasets and one realistic diboson-versus-QCD task, the method learned boundaries and rated discriminating features highest. It first trailed tree and network baselines on the full feature set. The authors present it as a bridge that keeps the method's clarity with modern learning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jing Li, and Hao Sun |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22498
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Learnable cut flow for high energy physics Jing Li, and Hao Sun Abstract Neural networks have emerged as a powerful paradigm for tasks in high energy physics, yet their opaque training process renders them as a black box. In contrast, the traditional cut flow method offers simplicity and interpretability but requires extensive manual tuning to identify optimal cut boundaries. To merge the strengths of both approaches, we propose the Learnable Cut Flow (LCF), a neural network that transforms the traditional cut selection into a fully differentiable, data-driven process. LCF implements two cut strategies—parallel, where observable distributions are treated independently, and sequential, where prior cuts shape subsequent ones—to flexibly determine optimal boundaries. Building on this strategy, we introduce the Learnable Importance , a metric that quantifies feature importance and adjusts their contributions to the loss accordingly, offering model-driven insights unlike ad-hoc metrics. To ensure differentiability, a modified loss function replaces hard cuts with mask operations, preserving data shape throughout the training process. LCF is tested on six varied mock datasets and a realistic diboson vs. QCD dataset. Results demonstrate that LCF (1) accurately learns cut boundaries across typical feature distributions in both parallel and sequential strategies, (2) assigns higher importance to discriminative features with minimal overlap, (3) handles redundant or correlated features robustly, and (4) performs effectively in real-world scenarios. In the diboson dataset, LCF initially underperforms boosted decision trees and multilayer perceptrons when using all observables. LCF bridges the gap between traditional cut flow method and modern black-box neural networks, delivering actionable insights into the training process and feature importance. Source code and experimental data are available at https://github.com/Star9daisy/learnable-cut-flow . arXiv: 2503.22498 1 Introduction At the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), vast data from high-energy collisions are collected, allowing physicists to search for signals of Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics against overwhelming background noise. As a common tool, the cut flow (cut-based) method applies a series of manually defined cuts in sequence to filter rare signal events. While straightforward in eliminating background and preserving signals, it struggles with rigidity as the complexity and number of observables grow. In contrast to the cut flow method, machine learning is increasingly adopted across the field, proving effective in diverse applications: tagging jets with deep networks and jet charge [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , speeding up shower simulations with generative models [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , enhancing unfolding for full-event reconstruction [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] , anomaly detection in complex LHC data [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] , and suppressing pileup with attention-based methods [ 24 , 25 ] . While machine learning excels in high-energy physics, its opacity makes the reinterpretation of the results far more involved, if not impossible in some cases, driving efforts to align such techniques with physical intuition and traditional methods. One approach embeds symmetry principles into neural networks, yielding architectures like Lorentz-equivariant autoencoders [ 26 ] , PELICAN networks [ 27 ] , energy flow networks [ 28 , 29 ] , particle cloud jet tagging [ 30 ] , and others [ 31 , 32 , 33 ] . Another approach bridges neural networks with high-level observables, with ref. [ 34 ] leveraging ML to quantify jet information and saturate feature space, ref. [ 35 ] deriving novel jet observables, and ref. [ 36 ] automating observable construction. Additionally, researchers map low-level features to high-level observables [ 37 ] and craft interpretable anomaly detectors for jet substructure [ 38 ] , extracting discriminative insights in a human-readable form. For a comprehensive overview, see ref. [ 39 ] . To overcome the opacity of neural networks while retaining the clarity of traditional cut-based analyses, we introduce the Learnable Cut Flow (LCF). It is a neural network that fully emulates human cut-searching operations, ensuring what it learns is entirely transparent and understandable. Recent efforts have also explored making cuts differentiable for optimization. In ref. [ 40 ] , cuts are represented as bias parameters in a neural network, with losses that are customized for targeted efficiencies and smoothness. While both approaches share similarities in neural network structure, we adopt a different approach for deriving cut expression and calculating losses, emphasizing parallel and sequential strategies via mask operations, as well as a learnable importance mechanism for feature prioritization. At bottom, we transform cuts into differentiable operations, such that training a neuron is equivalent to searching for an optimal cut. This match reflects LCF’s transparency and interpretability. For scenarios where signals lie in the middle or at both edges of an observable distribution, we employ mask operations to split observable distribution into two parts around a specified center. With such learnable cuts, boundaries are automatically identified after training. Since observables vary in their separation power, contributing unevenly to classification, we introduce Learnable Importance . It is a set of softmax-normalized trainable weights that favors stronger observables while suppressing weaker ones. Unlike other ad-hoc metrics, it not only reflects the contribution fraction but also provides a robust way for selecting key observables to build the final cut flow. At inference, we select results based on importance—retaining cuts from high-importance observables and discarding the rest. We train the LCF model by rethinking human cut-searching strategies: a parallel approach searches each raw observable distribution independently, while a sequential approach searches the distribution altered by prior cuts. In the parallel strategy, we sum the loss across all cuts. For the sequential strategy, we modify the loss function to incorporate prior cuts. Here, mask operations apply binary weights to filter out contributions from already-cut events. This ensures training aligns with LCF’s transparent design. We demonstrate LCF’s effectiveness on dedicated mock datasets and a realistic diboson vs. QCD dataset. Results show it accurately learns cut boundaries in both strategies, prioritizes discriminative features with minimal overlap, handles redundant or correlated features robustly, and performs well in real-world cases. The paper is structured as follows: section 2 explores the methodological foundations, section 3 details the experimental setups, section 4 presents results and analysis, and section 5 concludes the study. 2 Methodology 2.1 Learnable cuts In high-energy physics, the traditional cut flow involves a series of manual steps. First, physicists select relevant observables. Next, each observable is visualized as a one-dimensional distribution. Then, boundaries are chosen by inspecting these distributions to separate signal from background events. To formalize cuts, consider a dataset with N events ( i indexes events) and F observables ( j indexes observables). A traditional cut on x_{ij} is \hat{y}_{i}=\Theta\left(x_{ij}-c_{j}\right), (1) \hat{y}_{i}=1\rightarrow x_{ij}>c_{j}. (2) Here, \Theta is the Heaviside step function, c_{j} the cut’s boundary, and \hat{y}_{i} the result. \hat{y}_{i}=1 means the event passes the cut x_{ij}>c_{j} , which is taken as a signal. We use the strictly greater than sign for clarity. This is a fundamental case where signal lies right of c_{j} as a lower limit. For the left case, with signal below the cut, the operation becomes \hat{y}_{i}=\Theta\left(c_{j}-x_{ij}\right), (3) \hat{y}_{i}=1\rightarrow x_{ij}<c_{j}. (4) Here, \hat{y}_{i}=1 means the event passes the cut x_{ij}<c_{j} , taken as signal. To make cuts learnable and auto-updated,