Stability of Zipf’s law for cities and occult spatial dependence effects: A study on the OECD countries

Rolf Bergs, Uwe Neumann · 2025

Read Stability of Zipf’s law for cities and occult spatial dependence effects: A study on the OECD countries by Rolf Bergs, Uwe Neumann (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22463.txt.

Introduction

Rolf Bergs and Uwe Neumann test a famed city size law for hidden spatial pull in a 2025 paper. The law says city ranks and sizes follow a clean power curve, but nearby cities may tug each other's growth and bend the curve.

The authors add a spatial weight grid to the standard tail model and run spatial regressions across rich country data. Results come out mixed. Local clustering stats traced along the rank ladder hunt where the pull sits. Belgium serves as the worked example of the method. The study warns that plain fits can hide neighbor effects.

Catalog record

CREATORRolf Bergs, Uwe Neumann
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22463

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stability of Zipf’s law for cities and occult spatial dependence effects: A study on the OECD countries Rolf Bergs, Uwe Neumann Abstract We investigate spatial dependence in Zipf’s law for cities among the OECD countries. The aim is to identify an upper tail of the distribution that follows a power law (Pareto) but is perturbed by spatial autocorrelation, as indicated by a coefficient with a significant minor or major deviation from a distribution corresponding to a (non-spatial) Zipf law. For that purpose, we augment the usual Pareto model with a spatial weight matrix and apply SEM/SAR regressions. The results for the OECD countries are mixed. In particular, we investigate the rank-size distribution of cities by estimating local Moran-I coefficients (LISA) along the city ranks to locate the causes of spatial dependence. As an example, we demonstrate the approach for Belgium, a medium-sized OECD country. 1 Introduction This is a report on preliminary results of an extended investigation of spatial dependence in Zipf’s law for cities. We investigated a large 2024 urban dataset (World Cities Database) provided by NGIA, US Geological Survey, US Census Bureau, and NASA to explore a specific aspect of Zipf’s law for cities. The purpose of our research is to further substantiate insight of a previous article on spatial dependence in Zipf’s law that dealt with the simulation of randomly generated artificial distributions and four real world datasets covering the USA, Germany, UK, and Slovenia (Bergs 2021). That analysis could markedly prove the potential existence of major spatial dependence and thus confirms a bias of regression coefficients. However, perturbations from spatial lag or spatial error on the Pareto coefficient based on real world data at the country level have shown to be partly zero or - if at all - modest, even though partly significant at the 0.01 level, hence ”weak but not negligible”. The relevance of spatial dependence in Zipf’s law was later substantiated from the viewpoint of urban scaling (Arcaute and Ramasco 2021; Xiao and Gong 2022; Griffith 2022). A spatial dependence effect on the rank-size distribution of cities and the Zipf law suggests that this famous power law is not simply a statistical tautology, as Gan at al (2006) postulated, but in fact may indicate a major relevance for the functional interaction between urban and rural regions. While with respect to the earlier applications of Zipf’s law, which derives from linguistic studies, other interdependencies could affect statistical results (Zipf 1932), spatial effects cannot be ruled out for urban systems. Empirically, it could be shown that there is a close relationship between the overall centrality of cities (i.e. the economic role of any city in a national urban system) and the same cities with respect to their urban and rural neighborhood (e.g. Hsu 2011). This can potentially activate local spatial autocorrelation among either proximate or distant city ranks of a country. Spatial autocorrelation can thus be significantly positive or negative or - of course - just insignificant. To our knowledge, to date there have been no studies that explore distance effects on the rank-size distribution in urban systems for a broader spectrum of countries. Therefore, it was our aim to do just that and to test spatial dependence for a larger range of countries by addressing the OECD group. For long, the OECD has represented the countries of the core industrialized Western world, but it now also includes countries that thirty years ago still belonged to the developing world like for instance Colombia, Costa Rica, Chile, Mexico, Korea and Turkey. The OECD thus covers countries from major world regions including the Americas, East Asia, Oceania, and Europe. 2 Methodology Methodologically, we apply a SEM/SAR regression analysis: \centering ln(R)=\rho Wln(R)+ln(C)-\alpha ln(S)+\epsilon\@add@centering (1) ln(R)=ln(C)-\alpha ln(S)+\nu (2) \nu=\lambda W\nu+\epsilon (3) The three equations, SAR defined by (1) and SEM by (2) and (3), show augmented Pareto regressions with the usual notation of spatial econometrics, where in our model R means rank and S means population; C is a constant. The variable R is defined as ”rank-1/2” to avoid a standard error implied bias (Gabaix and Ibragimov 2011) and estimated by maximum likelihood (ML). Even though, the Gabaix-Ibragimov approach is specifically aimed to reduce the bias of an OLS estimate for small samples, we follow Le Gallo and Chasco (2006) who found more robust ML estimates with ”rank-1/2” as well. More importantly, in our study the differentiation of the distribution takes account of a vital former debate about the city rank-size distribution being either Pareto- or log-normally distributed or hybrid (Malevergne et al. 2011). The SEM/SAR procedures were carried out for (i) the entire distribution per country and (ii) specifically for an upper tail that is unequivocally characterized by a Pareto distribution. This should show whether Zipf’s law is confirmed (with a coefficient of -1 \pm -0.1) or not and how strong coefficients differ. Given the often found larger variation of Zipf’s law, the application of a relaxed definition (e.g. -1 \pm -0.3) could be considered, but in the end, any such definition of intervals remains arbitrary. As a further important intermediate step of the analysis, we explore spatial autocorrelation along the city ranks by estimating local Moran-I coefficients (LISA). This helps to immediately unveil the sections of the distribution, where spatial dependence occurs and where the mean of LISA coefficients is significantly different from zero. The aim is to identify an upper tail that is Pareto-distributed but perturbed by spatial autocorrelation, as indicated by a coefficient with a significant minor or major deviation from a distribution that corresponds to a (non-spatial) Zipf law. If the coefficient were disturbed by spatial dependence, we could conclude that a non-spatial analysis of Zipf’s law is insufficient. This is because for two countries with an identical Pareto coefficient, significant spatial dependence for only one country would imply a bias. How do we proceed? We first truncate the observations at the city rank with the cumulative 50 percent of the entire urban population. This is also highlighted by Malevergne et al. (2011) who apply an UMPU test to confirm a hybrid rank-size distribution of cities. We can thus well assume that these upper sections with 50 percent of the population belong to a Pareto shaped tail, but the remaining number of observations after truncation is often rather small. In other words, there is a notable variation in kurtosis: For Australia, already the first three out of 274 ranks of the city distribution represent 1/2 of the entire city population, while for Italy, it takes 159 out of 1,356 ranks to display 50 percent of the urban population. Furthermore, restricting the analysis on few upper observations may conceal important spatial effects from cities below the cut-off. It is possible that city ranks below the truncation point (potentially exhibiting local spatial autocorrelation) still belong to the Pareto tail. Therefore, the different ”conspicuous” sections of the rank-size distributions below the truncation point have been then tested for log-normality by moving windows. This was done by (i) visual inspection of the histograms and (ii) a Shapiro-Wilk test of the log-transformed observations of S. Furthermore, we back-up the result by generating fitted log-normal and Pareto distributions from the observed data in the different sections of the size distribution.

Read the complete text