Polynomial stability of wind turbine tower models

Mohamed Fkirine, Lassi Paunonen · 2025

Read Polynomial stability of wind turbine tower models by Mohamed Fkirine, Lassi Paunonen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22432.txt.

Introduction

Mohamed Fkirine and Lassi Paunonen prove slow, steady calming for wind turbine tower models. Their paper from 2025 studies the fore aft sway of monopile towers, the single post form used at sea. Two control routes are shown to give the same decay rate, where sway energy falls off as one over time.

One route feeds back the speed and turn speed of the top unit in a fixed output rule. The other fits a tuned mass damper in the top unit, a passive block that soaks up sway, and needs no active control. For side to side sway, a model with fluid power transfer is used. Feedback from top turn speed and generator load also calms that plane at the same rate.

Catalog record

CREATORMohamed Fkirine, Lassi Paunonen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22432

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Polynomial stability of wind turbine tower models Thanks: This work was supported by the Research Council of Finland Grant number 349002. Mohamed Fkirine, Lassi Paunonen Abstract . We investigate the stabilization of mathematical models describing the structural dynamics of monopile wind turbine towers. In the fore-aft plane, we show that the system becomes polynomially stable with an energy decay rate of t − 1 t^{-1} under static output feedback that relies on the velocity and/or angular velocity of the nacelle. Additionally, we prove that a tuned mass damper (TMD) in the nacelle ensures polynomial stability with the same energy decay rate, offering a viable alternative to active control. For the side-to-side plane, we analyze a model incorporating a hydraulic power transmission system and prove that feedback from the nacelle’s angular velocity and the generator load torque leads to polynomial stability of the system. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 35B35, 35B40, 93C20, 93D15, 47D06 (47A10) 1. Introduction Consider a wind turbine tower anchored to the ocean floor, bearing at its peak the nacelle, which can weigh several hundred tons. Because of its mass, the nacelle interacts with the flexible tower structure, creating complex dynamic behavior that requires a detailed model for accurate analysis. Wind turbines are subject to various types of vibrations due to environmental forces such as wind and waves. Among these, fore-aft vibrations (oscillations along the wind direction) and side-side vibrations (oscillations perpendicular to the wind direction) are particularly critical in evaluating the structural dynamics of the tower. These vibrations influence the turbine’s stability, performance, and lifespan. In this paper we investigate selected linear models that describe the dynamic behavior of wind turbine towers. In particular, we prove the strong asymptotic stability of the strongly continuous semigroup associated with each model, and derive an explicit decay rate for the energy of the classical solutions as t\to\infty . Our results are based on derivation of resolvent estimates for the generators of the strongly continuous semigroups associated with the wind turbine tower models. This analysis can be used as a basis for control design for reducing vibrations in the mathematical models. Zhao and Weiss [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] used the NASA Spacecraft Control Laboratory Experiment (SCOLE) system as an analog to model the monopile wind turbine tower dynamics in both the fore-aft and side-to-side planes. In the side-to-side plane, the SCOLE system incorporates an ordinary differential equation (ODE) to represent the dynamics of the drivetrain, which transmits mechanical power from the rotor to the generator. Originally designed to model large-scale space structures, the SCOLE system consists of a long elastic beam that is either clamped at one end and connected to a movable rigid body at the other or fully clamped at both ends, as detailed in [ 15 , 16 ] . This analogy provides a valuable tool for simplifying the analysis of wind turbine tower dynamics. Stability of the model can be enhanced through force and torque controls. Force control can be implemented by adjusting the pitch angle to regulate aerodynamic torque and rotational speed, whereas torque control utilizes an electrically driven mass within the nacelle to indirectly influence the turbine’s speed. The mathematical model, based on the SCOLE model, for the monopile wind turbine tower \Sigma_{\text{sc}} in the fore-aft plane has the form (1a) \displaystyle\rho(x)w_{tt}(x,t)=-(EI(x)w_{xx}(x,t))_{xx},\quad(x,t)\in(0,1)\times[0,\infty), (1b) \displaystyle w(0,t)=0,\quad w_{x}(0,t)=0, (1c) \displaystyle mw_{tt}(1,t)-(EIw_{xx})_{x}(1,t)=u_{1}(t), (1d) \displaystyle Jw_{xtt}(1,t)+EI(1)w_{xx}(1,t)=u_{2}(t), where the subscripts t and x denote derivatives with respect to the time t and the position x . Equation ( 1a ) is an Euler-Bernoulli beam equation which models the dynamics of the flexible tower whose one end is clamped to the ground due to the boundary condition ( 1b ). Equations ( 1c )–( 1d ) are the Newton-Euler rigid body equations that describe how the wind turbine interacts with the nacelle. In particular, (EIw_{xx})_{x}(1,t) and -EI(1)w_{xx}(1,t) are the force and the torque exerted on the nacelle by the tower at time t . The functions u_{1} and u_{2} are the open-loop control inputs that are applied to the nacelle. For simplicity of exposition we shall take the tower’s height to be 1 . The parameters EI and \rho are the flexural rigidity function and the mass density function of the tower, while the transverse displacement of the wind tower at position x and time t is w(x,t) . We assume that \rho and EI belong to C^{4}[0,1] , and are strictly positive. The parameters m>0 and J>0 are the mass and the moment of inertia of the nacelle, respectively. Exponential stability is typically the most desirable form of stability for controlled PDE systems. In [ 22 , 12 ] , it has been shown that exponential stabilization of \Sigma_{\text{sc}} can be achieved using higher-order output feedback, such as w_{xxt}(1,t) and w_{xxxt}(1,t) . However, implementing such feedback is challenging in practical applications. Consequently, velocity w_{t}(1,t) and angular velocity w_{xt}(1,t) emerge as more feasible signals for stabilizing the model \Sigma_{\text{sc}} . Unfortunately, as demonstrated in [ 15 , 22 ] , the system \Sigma_{\text{sc}} cannot be stabilised exponentially using any feedback law of the form \displaystyle u_{i}(t)=-\delta_{{i1}}w(1,t)-\delta_{i2}w_{x}(1,t)-\nu_{i1}w_{t}(1,t)-\nu_{i2}w_{xt}(1,t), where \delta_{ij} and \nu_{ij} are constants for i,j=1,2 . Given this limitation, aiming for strong stability becomes a more practical and achievable objective. The strong stabilization of the uniform model (i.e., where EI and \rho are constant) in one specific case was studied in [ 15 ] . The non-uniform case was addressed by Zhao and Weiss [ 27 ] , who demonstrated that \Sigma_{\text{sc}} can be strongly stabilized with either torque or force control and by utilizing feedback from the velocity or the angular velocity of the nacelle. As the first main result of this paper we show that the system \Sigma_{\text{sc}} also becomes polynomially stable under either torque control, force control, or a combination of the two. More precisely, we show that the energy E_{\text{sc}}(t) of every classical state trajectory of the system \Sigma_{\text{sc}} decays to zero at the rate t^{-1} as t\to\infty . In addition, the energy of every mild state trajectory satisfies E_{\text{sc}}(t)\to 0 as t\to\infty . These results are presented in Theorems 3.1 , 3.3 , and 3.4 . As our results demonstrate, force and torque control are effective in strong and polynomial stabilization of wind turbine tower models. However, in practice they may reduce the power generation efficiency and increase the blade pitch actuator usage, which can lead to fatigue. One way to address these challenges is to use passive structural control devices, the most common being the tuned mass damper (TMD). In [ 30 , 25 ] , the authors incorporated a TMD control system into the wind turbine tower system \Sigma_{\text{sc}} and showed that the resulting closed-loop system is strongly stable. As the second main result of this paper, presented in Theorem 3.5 , we prove that the TMD stabilizes the monopile wind turbine model \Sigma_{\text{sc}} polynomially. More precisely, the energy of every classical solution of \Sigma_{\text{TMD}} decays to zero at the rate t^{-1} as t\to\infty . In the side-side plane, we must consider the effect of the vibration torque transferred from the turbine blades to the nacelle through the dynamic mechanical transmission system. We study a model which incorporates the dynamics of a hydrostatic

Read the complete text