Towards More Accessible Scientific PDFs for People with Visual Impairments: Step-by-Step PDF Remediation to Improve Tag Accuracy
Felix M. Schmitt-Koopmann ID, Elaine M. Huang ID, Hans-Peter Hutter ID, Alireza Darvishy ID · 2025
Read Towards More Accessible Scientific PDFs for People with Visual Impairments: Step-by-Step PDF Remediation to Improve Tag Accuracy by Felix M. Schmitt-Koopmann ID, Elaine M. Huang ID, Hans-Peter Hutter ID, Alireza Darvishy ID (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22216.txt.
Introduction
Felix Schmitt-Koopmann, Elaine Huang, Hans-Peter Hutter, and Alireza Darvishy present a step-by-step way to make science PDFs readable by screen readers in a 2025 paper. Blind and low-vision readers lean on tags inside a PDF to move through it. Most science PDFs lack sound tags, which locks those readers out of the text and its math.
Their tool, PAVE 2.0, walks users through the fix and even drafts alt text for math with no expert help. In a test with 19 users, scores for tag quality near doubled against the standard pro tool. Fresh users rose from 39.2 to 75.2 percent. Most said they would pick the new tool.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Felix M. Schmitt-Koopmann ID, Elaine M. Huang ID, Hans-Peter Hutter ID, Alireza Darvishy ID |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22216
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards More Accessible Scientific PDFs for People with Visual Impairments: Step-by-Step PDF Remediation to Improve Tag Accuracy Felix M. Schmitt-Koopmann ID, Elaine M. Huang ID, Hans-Peter Hutter ID, Alireza Darvishy ID Abstract PDF inaccessibility is an ongoing challenge that hinders individuals with visual impairments from reading and navigating PDFs using screen readers. This paper presents a step-by-step process for both novice and experienced users to create accessible PDF documents, including an approach for creating alternative text for mathematical formulas without expert knowledge. In a study involving nineteen participants, we evaluated our prototype PAVE 2.0 by comparing it against Adobe Acrobat Pro, the existing standard for remediating PDFs. Our study shows that experienced users improved their tagging scores from 42.0% to 80.1%, and novice users from 39.2% to 75.2% with PAVE 2.0. Overall, fifteen participants stated that they would prefer to use PAVE 2.0 in the future, and all participants would recommend it for novice users. Our work demonstrates PAVE 2.0’s potential for increasing PDF accessibility for people with visual impairments and highlights remaining challenges. [email protected] Preprint, compiled August 24, 2026 K eywords Accessibility, PDF, Tagged PDF, PDF/UA, AI, User Study, Screen Readers 1 Introduction Many people with visual impairments rely on screen readers to access and read PDFs. Unfortunately, research has shown that only a tiny percentage of the trillions of PDF documents available are accessible for individuals who use screen readers and meet the PDF Universal Access (UA) standard [ 46 ] . This means that people with visual impairments cannot properly read most PDFs with screen readers, posing a significant problem — especially in STEM fields, where PDF is the dominant format [ 6 ] . Consequently, 2.4% of the US population is not able to easily read most scientific PDFs [ 27 ] . This presents an extra barrier for people with visual impairment wishing to pursue studies or careers in STEM fields [ 14 ] which contributes to the underrepresentation of people with disabilities in research [ 17 ] . The importance of this issue is underscored by several laws and resolutions created to ensure access to public documents for everybody. The oldest of these is the US Rehabilitation Act Section 508 of 1998 [ 45 ] . It requires US federal departments and agencies to make electronic and information technology accessible to people with disabilities. Moreover, the 2008 United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities [ 44 ] and the European Accessibility Act [ 12 ] of 2019 require that critical products and services be usable by people with disabilities. The discrepancy between these legal regulations and the continued lack of accessibility of PDFs documents can be attributed in large part to the lack of awareness regarding PDF accessibility and the challenge of making PDF documents accessible. The CHI conferences have made significant efforts to promote accessibility in CHI papers by providing templates, guidelines, and services [ 6 ] . However, the current processes for making PDFs accessible are still time-consuming and error-prone, and require expert knowledge [ 18 ] , challenges that many authors have likely experienced. As a result, our analysis reveals that conference papers often include tags, but the accuracy of the tags need to be improved. Hence, there is a need for methods and tools that allow people to remediate PDFs with a high degree of accessibility [ 6 , 18 , 34 ] . Such tools should not require that individuals have substantial specialized knowledge or invest large amounts of time to use them successfully. We developed a novel PDF remediation process with eight distinct steps to prevent users from becoming overwhelmed by the complexities of PDF accessibility details. One of our goals was to understand how our method affects the PDF remediation process from the user perspective, as well as how it affects the accessibility of the PDFs themselves. To evaluate our process, we conducted a user study involving nineteen participants with varying levels of experience in PDF remediation. Participants remediated a PDF once with our prototype and once with the industry standard tool, Adobe Acrobat Pro. It showed that our process allows novice as well as experienced users to increase the tag accuracy of their PDFs by around 90% and fifteen of nineteen participants stated that they would like to use our tool in the future. In this work, we present the following major contributions: 1) A user study to evaluate our step-by-step PDF remediation process, 2) a novel AI-based method to automatically create alternative texts for mathematical formulas, and 3) a novel accessibility score with thirteen criteria to reliably evaluate the tag accuracy of a PDF. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 explores the related work. Section 3 presents the developed process and our prototype, PAVE 2.0. Section 4 presents the design of the user test. The results of the user test are presented in Section 5 and we discuss the results in Section 6 . Lastly, Section 8 contains concluding remarks. 2 Related Work An accessible PDF can be created in two ways. The first method involves exporting an accessible PDF directly from the document editing software, provided that the software has an accessible PDF export option. However, not all document editors have this feature, and the author has to follow specific guidelines when creating the document to ensure that it is exported correctly as an accessible PDF. The second option is PDF remediation in which the author modifies an existing PDF to make it accessible. We focus on the PDF remediation method in this work because it is applicable regardless of the process used to create the PDF originally. This process is therefore valuable for making new PDFs accessible at time of their creation, but also for potentially making the vast quantity of inaccessible PDFs already in existence accessible to individuals who use screen readers as well. However, the complexity of the PDF remediation process has contributed directly to the current situation in which hardly any scientific PDFs are accessible, as the following research shows. Wang et al . [ 46 ] automatically assessed over 11,000 scientific PDFs, published between 2010 and 2019, and found that only 2.4% of the PDFs satisfied all their accessibility criteria. Nganji et al . [ 29 ] manually analyzed 200 articles from four journals between 2014 and 2018. They found that only 15.5% of the documents contained tags. Darvishy et al . [ 9 ] investigated 2,500 papers in repositories of five German-speaking universities in Switzerland from 2018 to 2022 in a semi-automatic way and found that only 11.5% of the papers contained tags. Pierrès et al . [ 33 ] examined 8,000 papers from four large scientific repositories mainly from 2023 and 2024 and found that papers that contained at least one tag and were marked as tagged comprised only 0.9% of the papers for Wiley and 16.2% for Elsevier. Even though the accessibility of scientific literature has improved in recent years, the vast majority of research literature is still not accessible to everyone. This lack of document accessibility is not only a problem in regard to scientific literature. Drye et al . [ 11 ] conducted a study to