A Main Sequence CH-star in the globular cluster M55 (NGC 6809)

G. S. Da Costa, T. Nordlander · 2025

Read A Main Sequence CH-star in the globular cluster M55 (NGC 6809) by G. S. Da Costa, T. Nordlander (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22083.txt.

Introduction

Da Costa and Nordlander report a rare carbon-rich dwarf star inside a globular cluster, in a 2025 paper. The cluster, M55, holds tens of thousands of old stars. The team took spectra of eighty-nine candidate member stars with a fiber instrument on the Anglo-Australian Telescope.

Motion data confirmed seventy-two stars as true members. One main-sequence star stood out with a much stronger carbon band than the rest. The authors judge it a dwarf carbon star that gained its carbon from a companion. The companion, once a mid-size star, shed carbon-rich gas before shrinking to a white dwarf. The cluster's loose structure likely let the pair survive where denser clusters would tear it apart. The cluster also hosts a carbon-rich giant, and similar stars in other clusters fit the same story.

Catalog record

CREATORG. S. Da Costa, T. Nordlander
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22083

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Main Sequence CH-star in the globular cluster M55 (NGC 6809) G. S. Da Costa, T. Nordlander Abstract Spectra have been obtained with multi-fibre instrument 2dF on the Anglo-Australian Telescope of 89 candidate main sequence stars in the globular cluster M55 (NGC 6809). Radial velocities and Gaia proper motions confirm 72 candidates as cluster members. Among these stars one stands out as having a substantially stronger G-band (CH) than the rest of the member sample. The star is a dwarf carbon star that most likely acquired the high carbon abundance ([C/Fe] ≈ \approx 1.2 ± \pm 0.2) via mass transfer from a ∼ \sim 1 − - 3 M ⊙ binary companion (now a white dwarf) during its AGB phase of evolution. Interestingly, M55 also contains a CH-star that lies on the cluster red giant branch – the low central concentration/low density of this cluster presumably allows the survival of binaries that would otherwise be disrupted in denser systems. The existence of carbon stars in six other globular clusters is consistent with this hypothesis, while the origin of the carbon-enhanced star in M15 (NGC 7078) is attributed to a merger process similar to that proposed for the origin of the carbon-rich R stars. keywords globular clusters: M55 – stars: abundances – stars: carbon – stars: Population II G. S. Da Costa][email protected] \alsoaffiliation Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, 751 20 Uppsala, Sweden 1 Introduction Carbon stars are stars with an overabundance of carbon 1 1 1 Usually taken as [C/Fe] > 0.7 ( Aoki2007 ) in their atmospheres, and are frequently designated as C-stars, CH-stars, or CEMP (carbon-enhanced metal-poor) stars. While the existence of such stars has a long history (e.g. Keenan42 ; Bond74 ; Dahn77 ) it is now generally accepted that most examples can be grouped into one of three broad categories. The first category are stars with masses in the range \sim 1 – 5 M ⊙ in the thermally-pulsing phase on the upper asymptotic giant branch – the TP-AGB stars (e.g. AKJL07 ; VA09 ; Cristallo09 ; Rosenfield16 ) . In TP-AGB stars, carbon is synthesized via triple- \alpha burning in the thermal pulses and is subsequently dredged-up into the surface layers. These stars also synthesize s -process elements, such as Ba, during the thermal pulses and these elements are also dredged-up into the surface layers. TP-AGB stars are seen in all stellar systems where there is a significant intermediate-age population – for example in the \sim 1–3 Gyr old star clusters in the Magellanic Clouds and in the intermediate-age field star populations of the SMC and LMC (e.g. Pasto2020 ) . The second category is the so-called CEMP-no stars. These are carbon-enhanced metal-poor stars with [Fe/H] < –1 ( BeersNC2005 ) that lack any accompanying enhancement of neutron-capture elements, hence the use of “no” in the designation. CEMP-no stars are generally quite metal-poor (e.g. [Fe/H] \leq –3) and become increasingly common as [Fe/H] decreases, dominating ultra-metal-poor star numbers below [Fe/H] = –4 (e.g. Placco14 ) . The carbon enhancements in these stars are often very large with [C/Fe] values exceeding 2.5 common (e.g. Table 7 of FN2015 ; MSB2015 ; TN2019 ) . CEMP-no stars are thought to be predominantly “second generation” stars; stars that formed from the enrichment products of zero-metallicity (Population III) supernovae. Specifically, the abundances reflect the products of low-luminosity mixing-and-fallback Pop III supernovae (e.g. NKT2013 ) , where the majority of the supernovae nucleosynthetic products remain in the remnant and only elements from the outer layers, such as C and O, pollute the surrounding interstellar medium (e.g. TN2019 ; GH2020 ) . The third category is where the carbon enhancement results from mass transfer in a binary system. With the appropriate separation the (original) primary can, during its TP-AGB phase, transfer mass to the (original) secondary subsequently evolving to become a white dwarf and leaving the companion carbon-enhanced. C-stars in this category occur in all stellar populations including the Galactic halo (e.g. Lin2024 , and the references therein) and the Galaxy’s dwarf spheroidal companions (e.g. Kirby2015 ; Lardo2016 ; Salgardo2016 ) . The classification of metal-poor examples (i.e., CEMP stars ) is discussed in BeersNC2005 , where the sub-classes CEMP-s, CEMP-r/s, and CEMP-r are defined. These sub-classes depend on which neutron capture elements are enhanced in the star’s atmosphere. For example, CEMP-s stars, which make up the largest number of CEMP stars ( Aoki2007 ) are defined by [Ba/Fe] > 1.0 and [Ba/Eu] > +0.5 dex. The binary nature of at least the large majority of these carbon-enhanced stars has long been established (e.g. McClure1984 ; McClure1997a ; Lucatello2005 ; Starkenburg2014 ; Foster2024 ) . It is also worth noting that while carbon stars in the first category are by definition giants, carbon stars in the other two categories can, and do, occur as either dwarfs or giants. As regards carbon stars in globular clusters, an extensive spectroscopic survey is that of \omega Cen (NGC 5139) by vanLoon2007 . This study obtained spectra of over 1500 \omega Cen members selected to uniformly sample a ( B,B-V ) colour-magnitude diagram to B magnitudes approximately 3 magnitudes below the red giant branch (RGB) tip. This survey revealed seven carbon stars, four of which were previously known (see references in vanLoon2007 ) and three of which were new. The spectra (see Fig. 25 of vanLoon2007 ) all show C 2 absorption as well as CN- and CH-bands. No measurements of [C/Fe] are presented but it is likely that all are significantly enhanced in carbon. Similarly, the complex nature of the spectra precluded estimates of the barium abundances for these stars but vanLoon2007 suggested that the carbon enhancements were most likely the result of mass-transfer processes. The faintest carbon star (LEID 53109) lies near the faint limit of the vanLoon2007 sample, slightly more than 3 magnitudes below the RGB tip. Small numbers of CH-stars on the upper part of the RGB have also been identified in six additional clusters. GFV2021 have identified 2, and perhaps as many as 5, CH star candidates in M53 (NGC 5024) from spectroscopy of 94 cluster RGB stars. Similarly, there are at least 3 CH stars in M22 (NGC 6656) ( McJEN1977 ; HesserH79 ) , 2 in M2 (NGC 7089) ( SmithMateo1990 ; Yong2014 ) and 1 in each of M55 (NGC 6809) ( GHSJEN1982 ; Briley1993 ) , NGC 6402 ( Cote1997 ) and NGC 6426 ( Sharina2012 ) . Kirby2015 has also noted the presence of a CH star with [C/Fe] = 0.9 \pm 0.1 in a sample of \sim 160 RGB and AGB stars in M15 (NGC 7078). Overall these numbers are relatively small in the context of the many 100s of globular cluster RGB-star spectra obtained over the past two decades or more (e.g. CarrettaVII ; CarrettaVIII ) . An RGB CH-star, which possesses large over-abundances of s -process elements, has also been found in the 300S stellar stream ( Usman2024 ) , whose progenitor was a globular cluster. Usman2024 conclude that the over-abundances in the CH-star result from mass-transfer in a binary system. In this paper we present the results of a search for dwarf carbon (dC) stars on the main sequence of

Read the complete text