Reynolds number effects on surface-induced secondary flows in turbulent boundary layers
T. Medjnoun, M. Nillson-Takeuchi, B. Ganapathisubramani · 2025
Read Reynolds number effects on surface-induced secondary flows in turbulent boundary layers by T. Medjnoun, M. Nillson-Takeuchi, B. Ganapathisubramani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-22029.txt.
Introduction
T Medjnoun, M Nillson-Takeuchi, and B Ganapathisubramani studied how patterned surfaces stir extra swirls in turbulent boundary layers, and how flow speed changes the picture. Their 2025 paper varies the friction Reynolds number from about three thousand to thirteen thousand. Strips of differing roughness across the span set up secondary flows, slow and fast lanes side by side.
A floating drag balance and fine hot wire probes measured drag, turbulence strength, and energy across scales. Tight strip spacing hit the near wall flow hardest, while wider spacing moved the outer layer. A spectral peak marked the secondary flows at a set length and height in every case. Large rolling motions faded in the slow lanes but returned in fast lanes at wide spacing and high speed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | T. Medjnoun, M. Nillson-Takeuchi, B. Ganapathisubramani |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-22029
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reynolds number effects on surface-induced secondary flows in turbulent boundary layers T. Medjnoun, M. Nillson-Takeuchi, B. Ganapathisubramani Abstract This study explores the effect of friction Reynolds number ( R e τ ≈ 3,000 Re_{\tau}\approx 3{,}000 – 13,000 13{,}000 ) on secondary flows in three-dimensional turbulent boundary layers induced by spanwise surface heterogeneity. Using a combination of floating-element drag balance and high-resolution hot-wire anemometry, we examine how varying spanwise spacing ( S / δ S/\delta ) influences frictional drag, turbulence intensity, spectral energy distribution, and the organisation of coherent structures. The results reveal that secondary flows modulate turbulence differently depending on S / δ S/\delta , with strong near-wall effects at S / δ < 1 S/\delta<1 and outer-layer modulation at S / δ ≳ 1 S/\delta\gtrsim 1 . A robust spectral signature of secondary flows peaking at λ x ≈ 3 δ \lambda_{x}\approx 3\delta and y ≈ 0.5 δ y\approx 0.5\delta emerges across all cases. This peak coexists with, or suppresses, very-large-scale motions (VLSMs), depending on flow region and spacing. While VLSMs are suppressed in low-momentum pathways (LMPs), they gradually recover in high-momentum pathways (HMPs) at higher S / δ S/\delta and R e τ Re_{\tau} . These findings offer new insight into the interplay between secondary motions and scale interactions in three-dimensional turbulent boundary layers, with implications for drag control, mixing, and surface design. keywords Turbulent boundary layers † † affiliation: Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, University of Southampton SO17 1BJ, United Kingdom 1 Introduction Over the past century, the study of rough-wall turbulence continues to challenge researchers, reflecting the profound complexities of this field and its critical implications across a wide range of engineering applications. Central to these investigations is the ongoing challenge of accurately characterising drag as a function of surface properties, particularly at full-scale conditions. While significant progress has been achieved through advancements in experimental and numerical capabilities, key foundational questions remain unanswered, requiring further targeted research ( Chung et al., 2021 ) . Predictive frameworks of frictional drag often assume homogeneous surface roughness. However, this assumption fails for surfaces characterised by spanwise topographical heterogeneity, a feature common in many real-world applications. Examples include environmental flows, such as fluvial sediment transport and bedform formation ( Chiu & McSparran, 1966 ; Colombini, 1993 ; McLelland et al., 1999 ; Nikora & Roy, 2012 ; Scherer et al., 2022 ) , atmospheric boundary layer flows over wind farms and heterogeneous terrains ( Markfort et al., 2012 ; Stevens et al., 2016 ; Alfredsson & Segalini, 2017 ; Bossuyt et al., 2018 ; Medjnoun et al., 2021 ) , and engineering applications like renewable energy systems and heat exchangers ( Barros & Christensen, 2014 ; Chitrakar et al., 2016 ; Pathikonda & Christensen, 2017 ; Deyn et al., 2022b ; Wang et al., 2024 ) , as well as marine transportation systems ( Monty et al., 2016 ; Murphy et al., 2018 ; Nugroho et al., 2021 ; Kaminaris et al., 2023 ; Medjnoun et al., 2023 ) . Under specific conditions –commonly defined by the relative topography/roughness height/strength and spanwise characteristic length scale –such heterogeneous surfaces can promote flow channelling ( Mejia-Alvarez & Christensen, 2013 ) , resulting in high- and low-momentum pathways (HMPs and LMPs, respectively). These features are associated with large-scale secondary flows, known as Prandtl’s secondary flows of the second kind, which are critical to understanding the interplay between surface topology and turbulent flow dynamics ( Hinze, 1973 ; Anderson et al., 2015 ; Kevin et al., 2017 ; Hwang & Lee, 2018 ; Stroh et al., 2020 ) . Despite significant advances, critical gaps remain in understanding drag over spanwise heterogeneous surfaces, particularly at high Reynolds numbers. Current research predominantly focuses on low to moderate Reynolds numbers ( Medjnoun et al., 2018 ; Nikora et al., 2019 ; Nugroho et al., 2021 ; Guo et al., 2022 ; Deyn et al., 2022a ; Frohnapfel et al., 2024 ) , often overlooking turbulence dynamics at higher Reynolds numbers where the scale separation between near-wall and outer-layer motions becomes more pronounced ( Smits et al., 2011b ) . Addressing these gaps requires experimental investigations that bridge fundamental understanding and practical relevance at high Reynolds numbers. Such data are essential for developing predictive frameworks to manage drag in engineering systems, such as biofouled ship hulls, and to improve sediment transport models in environmental applications. Furthermore, secondary flows have the potential to play a significant role in influencing the naturally occurring coherent structures characteristic of wall-bounded turbulence. These structures, spanning scales from near-wall motions to large-scale outer-layer motions, are well described by the attached eddy hypothesis ( Townsend, 1976 ; Perry & Li, 1990 ) , which posits a self-similar hierarchy of eddies scaling with their distance from the wall. The near-wall cycle –a self-sustaining process involving the generation of streamwise streaks and energy production that sustains larger flow structures –forms the foundational energy-generating mechanism in wall-bounded turbulence ( Jiménez & Pinelli, 1999 ) . Marusic & Monty (2019) highlight the hierarchical organisation of attached eddies in wall-bounded turbulence and their role as energy and momentum carriers across scales. At high Reynolds numbers, interactions between inner- and outer-layer motions become increasingly significant as large outer-layer eddies penetrate the near-wall region, modulating local structures and amplifying turbulence intensity within the boundary layer ( Hutchins & Marusic, 2007a ; Hutchins & Marusic, 2007b ) . These dynamics ultimately coalesce into VLSMs, sometimes also referred to as “superstructures”, which act as conveyors of energy and momentum across the boundary layer ( Marusic et al., 2010 ; Smits et al., 2011b ) . The streamwise coherence and scale of VLSMs, which can exceed an order of magnitude of the boundary layer thickness, highlight their critical role in maintaining energy transfer and turbulence dynamics ( Guala et al., 2006 ) . The exact nature of VLSMs remains debated, particularly regarding their independence and interaction with other scales. Traditionally, VLSMs are considered to form through the alignment or aggregation of smaller Large-Scale Motions (LSMs). In this view, VLSMs are not entirely independent but arise from the spatial organisation of these smaller eddies into large-scale coherent motions ( Kim & Adrian, 1999 ; Adrian et al., 2000 ; Deshpande et al., 2023 ) . Alternatively, some studies suggest that VLSMs may behave as independent, self-sustaining structures with distinct dynamical properties, particularly at high Reynolds numbers where scale separation is more pronounced ( Guala et al., 2006 ; Jiménez, 2012 ; Zampiron et al., 2024 ) . These two interpretations have significant implications for how VLSMs interact with secondary flows. If VLSMs are independent, secondary flows may directly influence their energy and structure. Conversely, if VLSMs primarily arise from aligned LSMs, secondary flows might affect VLSMs indirectly by modulating the underlying LSMs. Understanding this distinction is critical to characterising turbulence at multiple scales and its sensitivity to external influences like surface heterogeneity. Early insights into these interactions emerged from Nugroho et al. (2013) , who introduced “herringbone” riblet-patterned surfaces to passively control turbulent boundary layers and perturb the naturally occurring large-scale coherent motions. Their study revealed substantial modifications in the energy distribution among the largest energetic structures across the boundary layer. Subsequent