Pool Value Replication (CPM) and Impermanent Loss Hedging

Agustín Muñoz González, Juan I. Sequeira, Ariel Dembling · 2025

Read Pool Value Replication (CPM) and Impermanent Loss Hedging by Agustín Muñoz González, Juan I. Sequeira, Ariel Dembling (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21967.txt.

Introduction

Agustin Munoz Gonzalez, Juan Ignacio Sequeira, and Ariel Dembling wrote this finance paper, published in two thousand twenty-five, on a hidden cost in crypto markets. People who add coins to automated trading pools can lose value when prices move, a loss known as impermanent loss.

The authors work out the math of that loss for constant-product pools, the kind used by Uniswap and Balancer. They show that a pool's value can be copied exactly with a fixed mix of standard call and put options. Within a set price range, that mix fully covers the loss. A worked example uses real option prices from Deribit, a large crypto options market, to show a strangle strategy in action. The paper gives pool providers a concrete way to hedge a risk many only meet after the fact.

Catalog record

CREATORAgustín Muñoz González, Juan I. Sequeira, Ariel Dembling
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21967

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pool Value Replication (CPM) and Impermanent Loss Hedging Agustín Muñoz González, Juan I. Sequeira, Ariel Dembling Abstract This paper analytically characterizes impermanent loss for automated market makers (AMMs) in decentralized markets such as Uniswap or Balancer (CPMM). We derive a static replication formula for the pool’s value using a combination of European calls and puts. Furthermore, we establish a result guaranteeing hedging coverage for all final prices within a predefined interval. These theoretical results motivate a numerical example where we illustrate the strangle strategy using real cryptocurrency options data from Deribit, one of the most liquid markets available. Keywords— Impermanent Loss, Static Hedging, Constant Product Market Maker, Decentralized Finance Introduction A decentralized exchange (DEX) is a platform that enables cryptocurrency trading similarly to traditional exchanges, but unlike them, a DEX operates without the need for intermediaries. Such exchanges function via smart contracts, making them autonomous tools that anyone, anywhere in the world, can use without requiring permissions or authorizations from any central authority responsible for this service. Historically, many different decentralized exchanges (DEXs) have been proposed using a variety of market-making or price discovery mechanisms, ranging from classical order book methods [ 12 ] to more complex approaches involving specialized bonding curves [ 8 ] . However, a simple yet surprisingly effective automated market maker seems to be the constant product market maker (CPMM), popularized by Uniswap [ 15 ] and Balancer. While order books are the dominant medium of electronic asset exchange in traditional finance [ 14 ] , they are difficult to implement within a smart contract environment. The state size required by an order book to represent the set of pending orders is large and extremely costly within the smart contract setting, where users must pay for the storage and computational power utilized [ 13 ] . Furthermore, order matching logic is usually complex, as it often needs to support multiple different order types (such as iceberg, good-till-cancel, and stop-limit orders [ 14 ] ). To avoid significant on-chain execution costs (paid to the miners/validators of the smart contract by the agents executing trades), a variety of decentralized exchange designs use the underlying blockchain only for settlement, executing operations off-chain instead [ 12 ] . On the other hand, automated market makers (AMMs) have been extensively studied in algorithmic game theory, starting with Hanson’s logarithmic market scoring rule (LMSR) [ 7 ] , which is often used in practice as an AMM for prediction markets. Such AMMs are typically constructed by liquidity providers first depositing assets in a fixed ratio to specify an initial belief distribution about possible outcomes. Then, the AMM provides a scoring rule specifying the cost of changing the belief distribution from its current state to a new desired state. This scoring rule incentivizes traders to truthfully reveal their belief that the expected value of adjusting the distribution is positive. Since the exchange state depends solely on the total deposited quantities, corresponding storage requirements are substantially lower than those of traditional exchanges. Additionally, pricing a trade requires only a single function evaluation, in contrast to more complicated matching algorithms like those used in order books. A constant product market (CPM) is a mechanism to trade pairs of assets. A typical CPM is a pool containing certain amounts of both assets, along with a rule specifying how much of one asset will be exchanged for the other. Arbitrage with external spot markets ensures that the ratio of assets in the pool remains close to the prevailing exchange rate. Liquidity providers supply the asset pair and can withdraw their liquidity at any time, receiving a proportion according to the new asset ratio, as well as a share of transaction fees. It can be shown that the payoff to liquidity providers is proportional to the square root of the price ratio between the two assets [ 1 ] . This payoff can be precisely replicated using a static combination of futures and options [ 5 ] . Liquidity providers are exposed to impermanent loss, which is only realized when liquidity is withdrawn from the pool. This loss is typically computed as the difference between the value of the tokens provided in the liquidity pool and the value of simply holding the tokens statically upon entering the pool. Since traders always exchange less valuable tokens for more valuable ones, liquidity providers consistently suffer impermanent losses (IL) that can be significant. In this paper, we propose a static hedging strategy for liquidity providers using standard European options to eliminate the impact of impermanent loss. Firstly, we demonstrate that liquidity providers have an exposure equivalent to holding both long and short positions in various call and put options. We then derive a result ensuring impermanent loss protection within a given price interval [P_{i},P_{s}] , provided certain inequalities relating to the quantities and costs of purchased puts and calls, total invested capital, and returns obtained from the pool are satisfied, considering the classic Long Strangle strategy. In the results section, we illustrate this strategy through an application example of a hedging strategy, considering the duration we decide to remain in the pool, the initial capital, and the available options at the moment of implementing this project, utilizing real Ethereum option data from the Deribit options market. 1 Value of Constant Product Markets Constant Product Market A constant product market (CPM) is a market for exchanging tokens X for tokens Y (and vice versa). This market has reserves x>0 and y>0 , a constant product k=xy , and a percentage fee (1-\gamma) . A transaction in this market, exchanging \Delta_{y}>0 tokens Y for \Delta_{x}>0 tokens X , must satisfy: (x-\Delta_{x})(y+\gamma\Delta_{y})=k. (1) The reserves are updated as follows: y\to y+\Delta_{y} , x\to x-\Delta_{x} , and k\to(x-\Delta_{x})(y+\Delta_{y}) . The term “constant product market” arises from the fact that when the fee is zero (i.e., \gamma=1 ), any exchange \Delta_{y}\leftrightarrow\Delta_{x} must alter the reserves such that the product xy remains constant and equal to k . Spot Market A spot market is a mechanism that exchanges \Delta_{x} units of X for m_{p}^{t}\Delta_{y} units of Y at time t . An infinitely elastic spot market is one where m_{p}^{t} does not depend on \Delta_{y} . The Value of a Constant Product Market Let x^{t} , y^{t} , and m_{p}^{t}\in\mathbb{R}_{+} be the reserves of token X , token Y , and the relative market price of token X in terms of token Y , respectively, at each time t=0,\dots,T . On one hand, under the no-arbitrage hypothesis, the spot market price ( m_{p}^{t} ) coincides with the price implied by the constant product market ( y^{t}/x^{t} ), that is, m_{p}^{t}=y^{t}/x^{t} . On the other hand, if fees are not considered, the definition of a constant product market implies x^{t}y^{t}\equiv k for all t . Combining these two statements yields: y^{t}=\sqrt{km_{p}^{t}}. (2) We can use this expression to compute the relative return between time t-1 and t : \delta^{t}=\frac{m_{p}^{t}x^{t}+y^{t}}{m_{p}^{t-1}x^{t-1}+y^{t-1}}=\frac{y^{t}}{y^{t-1}}=\sqrt{\frac{m_{p}^{t}}{m_{p}^{t-1}}}. Thus, the total relative gain is given by: \delta=\prod_{t=1}^{T}\delta^{t}=\sqrt{\frac{m_{p}^{T}}{m_{p}^{0}}}, and the total portfolio value is: P_{V}^{T}=(m_{p}^{0}x^{0}+y^{0})\delta=2\sqrt{km_{p}^{T}}. (3) 2 Static Replication of a Payoff using Options and Bonds In the following section, we use [ 4 ] , which reviews the static replication theory using options originally developed by Ross

Read the complete text