Shape instabilities driven by topological defects in nematic polymer networks
Silvia Paparini †, Giulio G. Giusteri, L. Angela Mihai · 2025
Read Shape instabilities driven by topological defects in nematic polymer networks by Silvia Paparini †, Giulio G. Giusteri, L. Angela Mihai (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21941.txt.
Introduction
Silvia Paparini, Giulio Giusteri, and Angela Mihai model how sheets of a smart material bend around built-in defects, in a 2025 paper. The material is a liquid crystal network, a rubber threaded with rod-like units that line up in one direction. Points where that alignment swirls or breaks are called topological defects. Earlier work had not fully coupled those defects to the bending of the sheet itself.
The authors build a math framework for a flat sheet with one central defect. Energy terms cover both the cost of twisting the alignment and the elastic cost of bending out of plane. The model predicts which shapes the sheet takes for each defect type. Such materials are candidates for soft robots and lenses that change shape on cue.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Silvia Paparini †, Giulio G. Giusteri, L. Angela Mihai |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21941
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Shape instabilities driven by topological defects in nematic polymer networks Silvia Paparini †, Giulio G. Giusteri, L. Angela Mihai Abstract Liquid crystalline networks (LCNs) are stimuli-responsive materials formed from polymeric chains cross-linked with rod-like mesogenic segments, which, in the nematic phase, align along a non-polar director. A key characteristic of these nematic systems is the existence of singularities in the director field, known as topological defects or disclinations, and classified by their topological charge. In this study, we address the open question of modeling theoretically the coupling between mesogens disclination and polymeric network by providing a mathematical framework describing the out-of-plane shape changes of initially flat LCN sheets containing a central topological defect. Adopting a variational approach, we define an energy associated with the deformations consisting of two contributions: an elastic energy term accounting for spatial director variations, and a strain-energy function describing the elastic response of the polymer network. The interplay between nematic elasticity, which seeks to minimize distortions in the director field, variations in the degree of order, with the consequent tendency of monomers in the polymer chains to distribute anisotropically in response to an external stimulus, and mechanical stiffness, which resists deformation, determines the resulting morphology. We analyze the transition to instability of the ground-state flat configuration and characterize the corresponding buckling modes. Key words: nematic solids, liquid crystals, topological defects, shape change, first and second variations, mathematical modeling. Mathematics subject classification: 74B20, 76A15, 74F99. 1 Introduction Nematic liquid crystal networks (LCNs) are anisotropic materials combining the properties of polymeric chains and nematic liquid crystals (LCs) [ 24 , 25 , 39 , 43 , 45 , 46 , 47 ] . Similarly to classical LCs, in LCNs, the mesogenic segments in the nematic phase possess orientational order but lack positional ordering of their centers of mass. Moreover, different from liquid crystal elastomers (LCEs), in LCNs, cross-linking is tight and mobility of the nematic director is limited with respect to the polymer network, hence the coupling between nematic order and polymer is strong enough to constrain the director field to follow material deformation [ 41 ] . A significant factor in the mechanical behavior of LCNs is the presence of topological defects or disclinations [ 36 ] . These are singularities in the nematic orientation, which emerge when LC molecules encounter sudden geometrical changes, such as sharp edges or corners, and can be classified by their topological charge [ 23 ] . Many biological systems of cells and cytoskeletal elements can also form a nematic phase where elongated constituents align parallel to each other, inducing partial orientational order similar to that observed in nematic LCs [ 2 , 18 , 20 , 29 , 34 ] . For these systems, topological defects in the nematic order can act as organizing centers enabling organisms to grow protrusions or deplete material to relieve stress [ 8 , 17 , 18 , 22 , 34 ] . In Hydra’s ectoderm, for example, topological defects align with morphological features: a defect of charge +1 is localized at the tentacle’s tip, and two -1/2 defects reside at its base [ 22 ] . While LC disclinations and textures are ubiquitous in natural and synthetic soft matter, their coupling with the polymeric network in LCNs is a difficult task to model analytically, especially for topological charges different from +1 [ 13 , 14 , 26 ] . Defects of charge +1 have been primarily studied, for example, in [ 15 , 28 , 27 ] . Emergent shapes with Gaussian curvature localized at point defects are discussed in [ 28 , 43 ] , while numerical approaches such as shell theory simulations [ 10 ] and finite element methods with regularization [ 3 ] have been employed to capture richer physical phenomena in LCNs, including origami-like structures and deformations due to defects with varying topological charges. In this work, we develop a mathematical framework for the study of LCN defects by building on results from the LC theory [ 21 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 38 ] . The key characteristic of our approach, which also distinguishes our model from, for example [ 28 , 10 , 3 ] , in the treatment of defects with different topological charges, is that we consider a regime in which the nematic phase around the defect is well established, and shape deformations arise to relieve the mechanical stress originating from the imprinted, distorted director field with topological disclinations, as well as from variations in the degree of order and mechanical stiffness. Accordingly, an elastic energy that penalizes spatial distortions in the director field, measured by its gradient, is employed, along with a strain-energy function that describes the elastic response of the nematic polymer network to deformations, depending on the degrees of orientation and the director fields before and after the application of an external stimulus. This framework is inspired by biological shape formation and morphogenesis, as well as by the shape morphing of LCN sheets studied in [ 23 ] . Within this formalism, we adopt a variational approach that enables an almost entirely analytical solution to the out-of-plane buckling problem in nematic polymer networks. In the following sections, we first define topological defects in planar LCN sheets (Section 2 ). We then describe mathematically the formation of topological defects caused by physical changes when external stimuli are applied (Section 3 ). To demonstrate our theoretical framework, we present computed examples showing out-of-plane shape deformations in initially flat LCN samples similar to those seen in physical experiments (Section 4 ). In this context, the thickness of the flat LCN sheet is assumed to be sufficiently small to ensure that the imprinted director field has no significant component or variation in the thickness direction, and can therefore be extended uniformly across the cross-section. Our energy will scale linearly with the thickness and account for stretching. The resulting model will be therefore a membrane model [ 5 , 30 , 7 ] . Another popular scaling of the free energy with the thickness is cubic, leading to a plate model governed by bending effects. Examples include models derived via formal asymptotics [ 30 ] and a von Kármán plate model obtained in [ 26 ] using asymptotic analysis. In the concluding section, we highlight key challenges in deriving our results and provide an outlook on further investigations. More substantial detailed calculations are deferred to appendices. 2 Topological defects in the plane Nematic order in LCNs is described by a non-polar unit vector \bm{n}\in\mathbb{S}^{2} , called the director , and a scalar order parameter s\in[0,1] . The former describes the local average orientation of the LC molecules at the macroscopic scale, and has a bearing on the spatial organization of polymer strands. The constitutive molecules of nematic liquid crystals do not possess a permanent dipole moment and exhibit head-tail symmetry, meaning that the director field \bm{n} is physically equivalent to -\bm{n} . The latter represents the average orientation of the nematogenic constituents at the microscopic scale, with s=1 when LC molecules are perfectly aligned with each other, and s=0 when the material becomes isotropic. According to Ericksen’s theory [ 11 ] , whose formalism will be employed