Solvability of N-level Systems under the Rotating Wave Approximation (RWA) and Dipole Selection Rules

Phoenix M. M. Paing, Daniel F. V. James · 2025

Read Solvability of N-level Systems under the Rotating Wave Approximation (RWA) and Dipole Selection Rules by Phoenix M. M. Paing, Daniel F. V. James (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21689.txt.

Introduction

Phoenix Paing and Daniel James work out when light-driven multi-level atoms can be described by equations that do not change with time, in this 2025 arXiv paper. Such atoms, used in quantum optics, are often treated with the rotating wave approximation, which drops fast-wiggling terms. When the governing equations can be rotated into a steady form, the system becomes easy to solve.

The authors check four-level and five-level setups case by case, under the rules that govern which jumps between levels light can drive. Systems with only one level of a given parity reach the steady form on their own. All others get there only when the laser's tuning meets a set condition. The result is a clear map of which light-atom systems admit the simple treatment.

Catalog record

CREATORPhoenix M. M. Paing, Daniel F. V. James
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21689

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Solvability of N-level Systems under the Rotating Wave Approximation (RWA) and Dipole Selection Rules Preprint: APS/123-QED Phoenix M. M. Paing, Daniel F. V. James Abstract We analyze the dynamics of an N-level system under the Rotating Wave Approximation and dipole selection rules. Such systems can be solved straightforwardly if the Hamiltonian can be transformed into a time-independent form. The condition under which a unitary transformation can be used to render time-dependent Hamiltonians into a time-independent form, thereby making the solution, is examined. After case-by-case analysis of different four and five-level systems, we conclude that systems having only one odd or even parity level are solvable. In contrast, the others must satisfy a condition of laser detuning for solvability. I Introduction Laser excitations and multi-level atomic systems are simple yet fundamental tools that can be applied in various fields of quantum technology. Multi-level atomic systems are used in optical atomic clocks to achieve standard timekeeping of precision up to 10^{-19}s Ludlow et al. 2015 ; Vishnyakov et al. 2025 . Rydberg atoms are a direct application of multilevel atomic systems and are very useful in quantum gate construction and quantum information processing Saffman et al. 2010 . Successful quantum gates such as the Cirac-Zoller gate Cirac and Zoller 1995 , and the Molmer-Sorensen gate Sørensen and Mølmer 2000 are examples of the utilization of multi-level atomic systems in quantum information science. STImulated Raman Adiabatic Passage(STIRAP) uses a 3-level lambda( \lambda ) system, and it demonstrates coherent population transfer from a nearly-degenerate ground state to the other Bergmann et al. 1998 ; Shore 2017 ; Coulston and Bergmann 1992 . Quantum computing techniques using qudits(quantum states with more than two qubits) have strong correlations with multi-level atomic systems Wang et al. 2020 . The validity of the RWA on multi-level atomic systems when exposed to the environment is also an active research area Baker et al. 2018 . The multi-level systems are also interesting for their applications in nonlinear optics and photonics in characterizing various non-linear processes such as four-wave mixing Levine et al. 1987 ; Nakai and Meath 1992 ; Yanes-Thomas et al. 2025 . A recent work from Keck et al. demonstrated how to use a control field to make the Hamiltonian time independent under the rotating wave approximation Keck et al. 2015 . Therefore, it is worth revisiting what we know about the solutions of general N-level systems under RWA. This research is based on a paper from Einwohner, Wong, and Garrison that studied the solvability of N-level systems using graph theory Einwohner et al. 1976 . There has also been work by Fujii et al. on the exact solutions of 3-level systems Fujii et al. 2003 ; Fujii 2006 . We ask the same question as Einwohner, Wong, and Garrison on the solvability of various N-level systems. However, we approach it from the rotating frame and a case-by-case analysis of different systems. The Hamiltonian of a general N-level system under RWA can be written as follows Allen and Eberly 1975 . \displaystyle\hat{H}=\hat{H_{0}}+\hat{\vec{d}}\cdot\vec{E}(t) (1) \displaystyle\hat{H}=\sum_{n=1}^{N}\hbar\omega_{n}\ket{n}\bra{n}+\hbar(\sum_{m,n=1}^{N}\frac{\Omega_{nm}}{2}e^{-i\omega_{nm}t}\ket{n}\bra{m}+c.c.) (2) H_{0} represents the Hamiltonian of an isolated N-level system with no interaction between the levels. The field of interest is a multi-mode electric field with the assumption that only one field mode close to the transition frequency gets coupled Einwohner et al. 1976 . Under RWA, the Hamiltonian can be represented as in equation 2 where \Omega_{nm}=\frac{1}{\hbar}\bra{n}\hat{\vec{d}}\ket{m}\cdot\vec{E}(\vec{r}) is the Rabi frequency between the two levels and \omega_{nm} is the laser frequency of the transition between two levels. The dipole operator( \hat{\vec{d}} ) is a classical dipole \hat{\vec{d}}=e\hat{\vec{r}} which neglects the relativistic effects of the atom. Since we are interested in atomic systems concerning ultracold atoms, the approximation is valid as the cold atoms do not move at relativistic speeds. We are also ignoring the field couplings with quadrupole, octupole, etc. Dipole selection rules allow us to reduce the number of transitions. As a result, the topology of the graphs representing various systems becomes non-trivial and of interest. Therefore, we look for conditions for the solvability of different topologies governing the multi-level systems. Some applications go beyond the dipole approximation in ion-trapped quantum computing Freedhoff 1989 ; James 1998 . Such schemes using quadrupole and octupole transitions are beyond the scope of this research. The eigenstates (orbitals) of atoms are eigenstates of the parity operator. Since the position operator( \hat{\vec{r}} ) is odd, the matrix element \bra{n}\hat{\vec{d}}\ket{m} is zero unless the two levels have opposite parities. Therefore, the Hamiltonian of the system depends on how many even-parity levels the system has. This paper analyzes every 4-level system while extending the analysis to induce the conditions for the solvability of a general N-level system. II Brief Review on the Rotating Frame Transforms Solving the Schrodinger equation of Hamiltonians with explicit time dependence is a challenging task. There are a few approaches. The most simple approach of all is transforming the time-dependent Hamiltonian into a time-independent form using a unitary matrix and its conjugate as follows. \hat{H^{\prime}}=\hat{U}^{\dagger}\hat{H}\hat{U}-i\hbar\hat{U}^{\dagger}\frac{\partial\hat{U}}{\partial t} (3) If the transformed Hamiltonian is time-independent, it can be diagonalized for exact solutions. However, in this paper, we are only interested in the question of which systems are solvable instead of what the solutions are. The unitary matrix used for the rotation is a diagonal unitary(equation 4 ). U=\sum_{n=1}^{N}e^{-i\bar{\omega}_{n}t}\ket{n}\bra{n} (4) The chosen unitary matrix has a few advantages. Since the phases cancel when multiplied with the conjugate, the second term of equation 3 has no time-dependence, and we only have to worry about \hat{U}^{\dagger}\hat{H}\hat{U} . However, a diagonal unitary has four degrees of freedom, and we will see that the degrees of freedom vs. the number of transitions determines the solvability of a system. Having introduced the rotating picture and the general method of the analysis, we are ready to answer the question of which systems are solvable. III Unconditionally Solvable Systems III.1 3+1 systems 3+1 systems are systems where three levels are even and one is odd, or three are odd and one is even. There are four different 3+1 systems, as shown in figure 1 . (a) M system (b) Y system (c) \lambda system (d) W system Figure 1 : All possible diagrams of a 3+1 four-level systems. The names were chosen by the author according to symbol resemblance. Although the Hamiltonians of the four 3+1 systems are different, they follow a pattern after transformation. We will only show the step-by-step approach to solving the \lambda system, and the others can be solved using the same method. The Hamiltonian of the \lambda system in matrix form is as follows. \hat{H}_{\lambda}=\hbar\begin{pmatrix}\omega_{1}&0&\frac{\Omega_{13}}{2}e^{-i\omega_{13}t}&0\\ 0&\omega_{2}&\frac{\Omega_{23}}{2}e^{-i\omega_{23}t}&0\\ \frac{\Omega_{13}^{*}}{2}e^{i\omega_{13}t}&\frac{\Omega_{23}^{*}}{2}e^{i\omega_{23}t}&\omega_{3}&\frac{\Omega_{34}}{2}e^{-i\omega_{34}t}\\ 0&0&\frac{\Omega_{34}^{*}}{2}e^{i\omega_{34}t}&\omega_{4}\end{pmatrix} Acting on the diagonal unitary and setting the time-evolving phases to zero, we get a system of equations to solve as follows. \displaystyle\bar{\omega}_{1}+\omega_{13}-\bar{\omega}_{3}=0 \displaystyle\bar{\omega}_{2}+\omega_{23}-\bar{\omega}_{3}=0 \displaystyle\bar{\omega}_{3}+\omega_{34}-\bar{\omega}_{4}=0 Since \bar{\omega}_{n} are the degrees of freedom of the unitary, there exists one more \bar{\omega}_{n} than the transition frequencies( \omega_{mn} ). Following the same analysis on M, Y, and W systems, one sees that there also exists one more degree of freedom than the transition frequency in each 3+1 system. With the freedom to choose an extra constraint for the unitary, we conclude that every 3+1 system is unconditionally solvable. III.2 (N-1)+1 level systems 4+1 systems

Read the complete text