20 Years of Light Pentaquark Searches Submitted to Acta Physica Polonica B special volume dedicated to Dmitry Diakonov, Victor Petrov and Maxim Polyakov.
Moskov Amaryan · 2025
Read 20 Years of Light Pentaquark Searches Submitted to Acta Physica Polonica B special volume dedicated to Dmitry Diakonov, Victor Petrov and Maxim Polyakov. by Moskov Amaryan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21545.txt.
Introduction
Moskov Amaryan reviews twenty years of searches for a light pentaquark in a 2025 tribute paper dedicated to three theorist colleagues. A pentaquark is a particle built from five quarks, beyond the usual families. One candidate reported in the early two thousands drew intense effort and debate. Amaryan traces the hunt from its start to the present state of the evidence, surveying experiments that claimed signals and those that failed to confirm them. The piece serves as both a memorial and a compact history of a long running question.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Moskov Amaryan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21545
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
20 Years of Light Pentaquark Searches Submitted to Acta Physica Polonica B special volume dedicated to Dmitry Diakonov, Victor Petrov and Maxim Polyakov. Moskov Amaryan Abstract In this paper, I pay tribute to my exceptional colleagues and friends Dmitri Diakonov, Victor Petrov, and Maxim Polyakov by examining the experimental progress and current status of the searches of the Θ + \Theta^{+} pentaquark from its inception to the present. 1 Introduction As this is my contribution to the memorial volume, I would like to begin by sharing some personal reflections. My collaboration with Maxim Polyakov began during DIS99 Conference in Zeuthen, Germany in 1999 where I was presenting experimental data from the HERMES experiment at DESY, Hamburg, Germany. It was during this time that we established a friendly relationship, and I invited Maxim to give a seminar at DESY, which he graciously accepted. From that point onward, our collaboration began. In year 2000 I obtained first results of the single beam-spin asymmetry in electroproduction of a single photon via interference of Deeply Virtual Compton scattering with a similar final state of Bethe-Heitler process. It was first published as a conference proceedings [ 2 ] of the talk presented in 2000 at Spin2000 conference in Osaka, Japan, then in 2001 published in Physical Review Letters [ 3 ] . Now it is dubbed as DVCS and is well known to the community of DESY, CERN, JLab, and constitutes one of the major parts of the physics program of newly proposed Electron Ion Collider under construction at Brookhaven National Laboratory, USA. Later Maxim made significant contributions to observe the D -term for the General Parton Distributions and measurement of the pressure inside the proton. All this is well known and I would not like to further bother the reader with the details of these avenues. In 2002, an international workshop was held in Santorini, Greece. Along with Maxim, Mitya Diakonov and Vitya Petrov participated in it. This is where I met them for the first time and later we collaborated closely. In this meeting there was no word mentioned to me about their seminal work on pentaquarks [ 1 ] . In 2003 I was invited to the DIS2003 in Sankt-Petersburg, where for the first time I heard about the \Theta^{+} exotic baryon made of uudd\bar{s} quarks. I promised Diakonov, Petrov and Polyakov to look at pK_{S} decay channel of the \Theta^{+} . And apparently we observed a peak in the invariant mass of pK_{\rm S} from the HERMES data and after a long review and discussions it was finally published [ 4 ] . The results obtained by the HERMES collaboration initiated also other HERA experiments to look for \Theta^{+} . ZEUS Collaboration reported the observation of the \Theta^{+} in their data [ 5 ] , while H1 and HERAB didn’t. These outcomes created heated debates in the DESY community, there was an extraordinary seminar organized, with all four experiments at HERA, where I gave an opening experimental talk and Maxim gave a theory presentation. Things were not conclusive as none of the HERA experiments was really designed for the hadron spectroscopy. In 2003 the SPRING-8 published their first observation of the \Theta^{+} in a photoproduction on a carbon target [ 6 ] and independently in the same year there was a paper by the DIANA experiment on a bubble chamber with observation of the \Theta^{+} in the K+n\to K^{0}p reaction on the Xe target [ 7 ] . Consequently, in the same year the CLAS Collaboration at Jefferson Laboratory (JLab) claimed observation of the \Theta^{+} in photoproduction experiments on a deuteron as well as on a hydrogen targets. In the two following years there were hundreds of papers published by theorists on the topic of exotic baryons. I may have not listed all experiments, for the detailed review I refer to [ 9 ] and [ 10 ] reviews. All this created high excitement in the community until the CLAS Collaboration remeasured their previous channels with high statistics and didn’t confirm their reported claims of observation of \Theta^{+} . This was announced on the first day of the APS meeting in Tampa, FL, in 2005 where I was invited to give a talk on pentaquarks two days later. One can imagine the level of skepticism created by the CLAS announcement. Anyway, I want just to remind the reader that, as Carl Sagan once said: ”Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence”. I said something similar in my talk, however, as English proverb says: ”too many cooks spoil the broth”. Coming back to Norfolk, where I was already hired as a professor of physics at Old Dominion University and doing research in CLAS at JLab, I decided to look at the Quantum Mechanical interference between the \phi and \Theta^{+} produced with the same final state, i.e. \gamma+p\to p\phi\to pK_{\rm S}K_{\rm L} , which in more detail is described in Sect. 2 . In a meantime I was thinking how to create two body reaction to answer the question of existence or non-existence of the \Theta^{+} and came to the idea of creating secondary beam of neutral kaons and submitted a letter of intent to the JLab Program Advisory Committee (PAC) in 2015, which is discussed in Sect. 3 . Unfortunately all my theory colleagues, Dmitri Diakonov, Victor Petrov and Maxim Polyakov by now passed away and will not see the future results. 2 Theory and Experiment In his paper, classifying all existing baryons into octet and decuplet of SU(3) symmetry Gell-Mann predicted existence of multiquark states different from the regular 3-quark states for baryons, i.e 5-quarks in particular [ 8 ] . However, multiple attempts over the decades didn’t prove the existence of such configurations. The breakthrough happened after the publication of the Diakonov, Petrov and Polyakov [ 1 ] , in which authors predicted the existence of the particle in the apex of anti-decuplet, so-called Z -baryon, later dubbed as \Theta^{+} with the mass of 1530 MeV and relative narrow width on the order of 15 MeV decaying either to K^{+}n or K^{0}p . Other members of anti-decuplet were also predicted with exotics on the corners of the diagram, see Fig. 1 . Figure 1: The suggested anti-decuplet of baryons [ 1 ] . The corners of this ( T_{3} , Y ) diagram are exotic. The original name of the pentaquark lying at the apex of \overline{10} was Z^{+} , then following Diakonov’s suggestion, it was called \Theta^{+} . There was a period of a long silence until Spring-8 [ 6 ] and Diana experiment [ 7 ] announced observation of the \Theta^{+} . Then many experimental facilities tried to observe it, see a review papers in [ 9 ] and [ 10 ] . Without going into the details of the Quark Soliton Model, I should mention that hundreds of papers were published in a short period of time until 2005 APS meeting in Tampa, Florida. There I was invited to give a talk on pentaquarks, but on the first day of that meeting the CLAS Collaboration announced non-observation of \Theta^{+} in a new set of high statistics experiments and obviously my talk looked like a ”shot in