Automated Analysis of Pricings in SaaS-based Information Systems

Alejandro García-Fernández, José Antonio Parejo, Pablo Trinidad, Antonio Ruiz-Cortés · 2025

Read Automated Analysis of Pricings in SaaS-based Information Systems by Alejandro García-Fernández, José Antonio Parejo, Pablo Trinidad, Antonio Ruiz-Cortés (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21444.txt.

Introduction

Alejandro García-Fernández, José Antonio Parejo, Pablo Trinidad, and Antonio Ruiz-Cortés present a 2025 paper on automated checks for the pricing plans of cloud software services. A plan once meant a few tiers; now it can mean thousands of feature, limit, and add on mixes. Hand checking such plans is slow and error prone.

A newer work style treats pricing as code that tools can manage. The authors define seven analysis tasks that support that style. Some tasks turn human written plans into machine readable form. Others find the cheapest plan that meets a user's needs. The paper frames these tasks as a base for pricing aware operations tools.

Catalog record

CREATORAlejandro García-Fernández, José Antonio Parejo, Pablo Trinidad, Antonio Ruiz-Cortés
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21444

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Automated Analysis of Pricings in SaaS-based Information Systems Alejandro García-Fernández, José Antonio Parejo, Pablo Trinidad, Antonio Ruiz-Cortés Abstract Software as a Service (SaaS) pricing models, encompassing features, usage limits, plans, and add-ons, have grown exponentially in complexity, evolving from offering tens to thousands of configuration options. This rapid expansion poses significant challenges for the development and operation of SaaS-based Information Systems (IS), as manual management of such configurations becomes time-consuming, error-prone, and ultimately unsustainable. The emerging paradigm of Pricing-driven DevOps aims to address these issues by automating pricing management tasks, such as transforming human-oriented pricings into machine-oriented (iPricing) or finding the optimal subscription that matches the requirements of a certain user, ultimately reducing human intervention. This paper advances the field by proposing seven analysis operations that partially or fully support these pricing management tasks, thus serving as a foundation for defining new, more specialized operations. To achieve this, we mapped iPricings into Constraint Satisfaction Optimization Problems (CSOP), an approach successfully used in similar domains, enabling us to implement and apply these operations to uncover latent, yet non-trivial insights from complex pricing models. The proposed approach has been implemented in a reference framework using MiniZinc, and tested with over 150 pricing models, identifying errors in 35 pricings of the benchmark. Results demonstrate its effectiveness in identifying errors and its potential to streamline Pricing-driven DevOps. 1 Introduction and Motivation Software as a Service (SaaS) has rapidly gained popularity in recent years [ 10 ] , driven by its flexibility to adapt to diverse user needs through subscription-based models. However, this adaptability has led to an exponential increase in configuration complexity, with modern pricing models evolving from offering a few options to thousands of potential configurations [ 6 ] . For example, Salesforce’s November 2019 pricing offered up to 10 different configurations, while its July 2024 version allowed for over 12,000, as can be seen here . This rapid expansion presents significant challenges for the development and operation of SaaS-based Information Systems (IS), as manual management of these configurations becomes a demanding task —being time-consuming and error-prone— especially when adapting to frequent pricing changes. Addressing these challenges requires a shift towards automated, scalable solutions. The paradigm of Pricing-driven Development and Operation has emerged to tackle this issue, aiming to automate tasks related to the management of pricing models 1 1 1 For brevity, the term “pricing models” and “pricings” will be used interchangeably. in SaaS-based Information Systems [ 6 ] . These may include, for example, designing pricing models, converting human-oriented representations of pricings into machine-oriented (iPricings), or finding the optimal subscription that meets particular user requirements. A foundational step toward this vision was presented in CAISE Forum, where a metamodel for representing pricings was proposed [ 7 ] , and has laid the groundwork for the idea of machine-oriented pricings (iPricings) [ 3 ] . Building on this foundation, subsequent efforts have focused on leveraging iPricings to develop solutions that automate tasks within the scope of Pricing-driven DevOps. For instance, [ 8 ] proposed a reference architecture for automating the variability management in client-server architectures leveraging feature toggling [ 4 ] , and AI4Pricing introduced initial advancements towards automating the transformation between human-oriented pricings and iPricings [ 3 ] . Although these contributions represent early steps, they highlight the progress being made toward realizing the vision of Pricing-driven DevOps. However, a crucial pillar remains unexplored: the automated analysis (AA) of iPricings, i.e. the process of uncovering latent, yet non-trivial, information from machine-oriented pricings. For instance, this approach has the potential to enable real-time validation of pricing structures, strengthen data-driven pricing decision-making, or assist customers in identifying the most cost-effective subscription that meets their specific requirements. In light of this, the paper introduces the following original contributions, inspired by solutions previously applied in the automated analysis for feature models in CAISE 2005 [ 1 ] and service level agreements [ 13 ] : 1. An unprecedented formalization of iPricings as Constraint Satisfaction Optimization Problems (CSOPs), enabling their automated analysis through constraint programming techniques. 2. A set of seven fundamental analysis operations, built on the CSOP-based formalization, to support pricing structural validation, configuration space cardinality computation, and optimal subscription selection based on user requirements. 3. A tool to apply these operations, built with the MiniZinc solver [ 14 ] and integrated within a real platform (see Fig. 1 ). 4. Two curated datasets: • A novel synthetic dataset comprising 20 pricing models with seeded consistency errors. Although our solution successfully detected most of them, it missed 6 instances, making this dataset a valuable resource for future work aimed at improving automated inconsistency detection. • An updated version of the benchmark introduced in [ 6 ] , incorporating fixes for the 35 structural issues identified by our approach, providing a more reliable baseline for future research. Figure 1: A sample final product integrating the proposed set of analysis operations. Public access available here , along with other examples The remainder of this paper is structured as follows: Section 2 frames the contribution within the existing literature and presents the core concepts, challenges, and research advancements in SaaS pricing. Section 3 presents an automated approach for iPricings analysis using CSOP-based operations. Next, Section 4 presents a reference implementation of the approach and tests it using benchmark and synthetic datasets. Finally, Section 5 showcases the conclusions. 2 Background & Related Work 2.1 User-oriented SaaS Pricings A pricing is a part of a SaaS customer agreement [ 5 ] . It structures the features of a service —defined as the distinctive characteristics whose presence/absence may guide a user’s decision towards a particular subscription [ 7 ] — into plans and add-ons to control users’ access to such features. While users can only subscribe to one of the available plans, they can subscribe to as many add-ons as they want, as long as they are available for the contracted plan. As can be noted, in this domain, a feature encompasses both functional features , which constitute the core software product, and extra-functional features , which, while external to the product itself, enhance its perceived value (e.g., support, SLA guarantees, etc). By including both types of features, pricings capture a more comprehensive view of what influences customer value, aligning the service offering with the overall customer agreement. Figure 2: Excerpt of Zoom’s pricing with 13 features, three plans, and three add-ons, with a configuration space size of 20 In order to illustrate the upcoming concepts, we will use a real-world running example: Zoom . This is a cloud-based video conferencing service that enables users to virtually meet with others and optionally record the sessions to watch them later. An excerpt of its pricing, consisting of 13 features, is presented in Fig. 2 . 2 2 2 Pricing entries that impose or extend limits on meetings are considered usage limits rather than individual features—the overarching feature in this case is “meetings”. In this example, nine features are managed through plans, one feature is associated with an add-on (“translated captions”), and one is governed by both (“phone dialing”). The pricing also enforces usage limits on the “meetings” feature (e.g., maximum assistants per meeting and maximum meeting duration) meaning that although the feature

Read the complete text