Unstable chords and destructive resonant excitation of black hole quasinormal modes Preprint: YITP-25-44, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25
Naritaka Oshita, Emanuele Berti, Vitor Cardoso · 2025
Read Unstable chords and destructive resonant excitation of black hole quasinormal modes Preprint: YITP-25-44, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25 by Naritaka Oshita, Emanuele Berti, Vitor Cardoso (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21276.txt.
Introduction
Naritaka Oshita, Emanuele Berti, and Vitor Cardoso probe a wobble in black hole ringdown math in this 2025 paper. A black hole's ringing tones shift when the underlying potential is nudged even slightly. The team computed tone strengths from first principles to see what that wobble does to waveform fits.
Small nudges spawn fresh tone sets that can fit the early ringdown better, even catching the late tail. Near-miss tone pairs can flare up but cancel each other in the full signal. So the waveform itself stays stable, they show. The work clarifies how much trust ringdown decompositions deserve.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Naritaka Oshita, Emanuele Berti, Vitor Cardoso |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21276
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unstable chords and destructive resonant excitation of black hole quasinormal modes Preprint: YITP-25-44, RIKEN-iTHEMS-Report-25 Naritaka Oshita, Emanuele Berti, Vitor Cardoso Abstract The quasinormal mode spectrum of black holes is unstable against small modifications of the radial potential describing massless perturbations. We study how these small modifications affect the convergence of the quasinormal mode expansion and the mode excitation by computing the mode amplitudes from first principles, without relying on any fitting procedure. We show that the decomposition of the prompt ringdown waveform is not unique: small modifications in the radial potential produce new quasinormal mode “basis sets” that can improve the convergence of the quasinormal mode expansion, even capturing the late-time tail. We also study avoided crossings and exceptional points of the Kerr and Kerr-de Sitter spectrum. We show that while the mode amplitude can be resonantly excited, modes that exhibit avoided crossing destructively interfere with each other, so that the prompt ringdown waveform remains stable. Introduction. The so-called “ringdown” is the relaxation of a perturbed black hole (BH) to its final state via a superposition of characteristic damped exponentials with discrete frequencies: the BH’s quasinormal modes (QNMs) Kokkotas and Schmidt 1999 ; Berti et al. 2009 . Gravitational wave detectors can measure these frequencies by observing the ringdown radiation produced in the aftermath of a BH merger. This program is known as BH spectroscopy Dreyer et al. 2004 ; Berti et al. 2006a ; Baibhav et al. 2023 . The QNM frequency spectrum is known to be unstable under small deformations of the effective potential of the governing dynamical equation Nollert 1996 ; Nollert and Price 1999 ; Barausse et al. 2014 ; Daghigh et al. 2020 ; Jaramillo et al. 2021 ; Cheung et al. 2022 ; Cardoso et al. 2024 or under changes in the boundary conditions Cardoso et al. 2016 ; Mark et al. 2017 ; Cardoso and Pani 2019 ; Cardoso et al. 2024 . Despite this frequency-domain instability, the prompt time-domain ringdown waveform is stable, i.e., it is affected only perturbatively by changes in the potential or in the boundary conditions Barausse et al. 2014 ; Cardoso and Pani 2019 ; Berti et al. 2022 ; Cardoso et al. 2024 . Motivated by these spectral instability results, in this Letter we ask the following question: is the QNM spectrum in GR the most adequate basis set to describe the prompt time-domain ringdown? The problem we have in mind can be illustrated with a simple analogy. Consider a string instrument (for example, a guitar). Just like a black hole, the guitar is not a conservative system, since the mechanical energy in the strings is dissipated through sound waves in the air. Now, imagine playing the guitar in an echo chamber – a hard-wall venue such that the system is almost perfectly conservative. The QNMs of the guitar are very different from the modes of the new, conservative system. What does a listener perceive? Should we expand the sound waves in terms of the QNMs of the guitar, or in terms of the normal modes of the guitar in the venue? Which “basis” is more appropriate or useful? Throughout this Letter, we use geometrical units ( G=c=1 ) and we set 2M=1 , where M is the BH mass. Setup. Using the Newman-Penrose formalism, gravitational perturbations in the background of a spinning BH of mass M and dimensionless angular momentum j=a/M=J/M^{2} can be reduced to the study of a single master wavefunction Teukolsky 1973 . The wavefunction can be factorized into an angular part that satisfies the spin-weighted spheroidal wave equation Berti et al. 2006b and a radial part. We will consider a variant of the radial wavefunction (the Sasaki-Nakamura wavefunction X_{\ell m\omega} Sasaki and Nakamura 1982 ; Hughes 2000 ) which, in Fourier space, satisfies the equation \frac{d^{2}X_{\ell m\omega}}{dr_{\ast}^{2}}+\left(\frac{1}{2}\frac{d{\cal F}_{\ell m\omega}{}}{dr_{*}}-\frac{{\cal F}_{\ell m\omega}{}^{2}}{4}-{\cal U}_{\ell m\omega}\right)X_{\ell m\omega}=0, (1) where r_{*} is the tortoise coordinate defined as dr_{*}/dr=(r^{2}+a^{2})/(r^{2}-r+a^{2}) in terms of the usual Boyer-Lindquist coordinate r , \omega is the Laplace variable, (\ell,m) label the multipolar components, and the explicit form of {\cal F}_{\ell m\omega} and {\cal U}_{\ell m\omega} is given in Ref. Sasaki and Nakamura 1982 . In the j\to 0 limit, the above equation reduces to the Regge-Wheeler equation. Figure 1: Gray markers are the \ell=m=2 QNM frequencies of the Sasaki-Nakamura equation in GR for j=0.7 (circles) and 0.99 (squares). Blue circles and red squares correspond to the QNM frequencies for a Pöschl-Teller perturbation with V_{0}=10^{-4} , x_{0}=10 , and \sigma=1 in Eq. ( 3 ). The QNM frequencies are the discrete complex values of \omega=\omega_{\ell mn} such that X_{\ell m\omega} is purely ingoing at the horizon and purely outgoing at spatial infinity. Here the overtone number n=0,\,1,\,2\dots sorts the frequencies by the absolute value of their imaginary part. The QNM frequency spectrum can be destabilized by small changes to the effective potential {\cal U}_{\ell m\omega} Berti et al. 2022 ; Cardoso et al. 2024 ), or even by “soft” changes in the boundary conditions Cardoso et al. 2016 ; Mark et al. 2017 ; Cardoso and Pani 2019 . For definiteness, we choose the latter possibility and consider the following modified boundary condition: \displaystyle X_{\ell m\omega}=\begin{cases}e^{-ik_{\rm H}r_{*}}\ \ (r_{*}\to-\infty)\,,\\ e^{i\omega r_{*}}+\epsilon(\omega)e^{-i\omega(r_{*}-2x_{0})},\ \ (r_{*}\to\infty)\end{cases} (2) where k_{\rm H}\equiv\omega-m\Omega_{\rm H} , \Omega_{\rm H} is the horizon frequency, \epsilon(\omega) is the reflectivity of the reflective “bump,” and x_{0} is its radial position in terms of the tortoise coordinate. These boundary conditions are an effective description of spacetime deformations which would induce a change in the local effective potential. The reflective nature of the spacetime deformations is encoded in the parameter \epsilon (in vacuum general relativity, \epsilon=0 ). For example, a bump of magnitude \delta V can be modeled by choosing \epsilon\ll 1 for \omega^{2}\gg\delta V , and \epsilon\simeq 1 for \omega^{2}\ll\delta V . This prescription gives results identical to those obtained by explicitly incorporating a bump-like perturbation into the master equation Cheung et al. 2022 , provided that \epsilon(\omega) is appropriately chosen and the bump is far enough that it does not overlap with the peak of the potential barrier. Even when these conditions are not fully satisfied, this method remains practical for demonstrating QNM instabilities. For definiteness, we choose the function \epsilon(\omega) such that it yields the reflectivity of the Pöschl-Teller potential V_{\rm PT}=V_{0}/\cosh^{2}[(r_{*}-x_{0})/\sigma] in the limit x_{0}\to\infty : \epsilon(\omega)=\frac{\Gamma(a_{+})\Gamma(a_{-})\Gamma(c-a_{+}-a_{-})}{\Gamma(a_{+}+a_{-}-c)\Gamma(c-a_{+})\Gamma(c-a_{-})}\,, (3) with a_{\pm}\equiv\left[\sigma\pm\sqrt{\sigma^{2}-4V_{0}}-2i\omega\right] and c\equiv 1-i\omega/\sigma . Other potentials can be accommodated by changing \epsilon(\omega) . The QNM frequencies with the new boundary conditions are shown and compared with the GR spectrum in Fig. 1 . It is clear at a glance that the GR spectrum is unstable under small changes in the boundary conditions. Figure 2: Absolute value of the QNMEFs |E_{22n}| in GR and for destabilized modes with j=0.9 , x_{0}=10 , \sigma=1 and different values of V_{0} , plotted as functions of {\rm Im}(\omega_{22n}) . The QNMEF of the fundamental mode (2,2,0) is marked by an arrow. Excitation and convergence of destabilized spectra. We have seen that small disturbances produce large changes in the spectrum. However, the prompt time domain signals is robust, as we demonstrate below (see also Barausse et al. 2014 ; Berti et al. 2022 ; Cardoso et al. 2024