Experimental and Numerical Study of Acoustic Streaming in Mid-Air Phased Arrays

Christopher Stone, Yusuke Koroyasu, Yoichi Ochiai, Akiko Kaneko, Bruce W. Drinkwater, Tatsuki Fushimi · 2025

Read Experimental and Numerical Study of Acoustic Streaming in Mid-Air Phased Arrays by Christopher Stone, Yusuke Koroyasu, Yoichi Ochiai, Akiko Kaneko, Bruce W. Drinkwater, Tatsuki Fushimi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21271.txt.

Introduction

Stone and co-authors measure air flows set off by ultrasound arrays in mid-air, in this 2025 paper. Focused sound can push air into steady motion, called acoustic streaming. That flow can alter touch sensations from sound-based haptics, shake levitated objects, or carry scents to a chosen spot.

The team filmed tracer particles to map the flow and compared the maps with computer models. Single-focus setups drove air faster than half a meter per second in places. Side lobes spawned sideways jets that models captured poorly. The findings help engineers design sound fields that account for the air they stir.

Catalog record

CREATORChristopher Stone, Yusuke Koroyasu, Yoichi Ochiai, Akiko Kaneko, Bruce W. Drinkwater, Tatsuki Fushimi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21271

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental and Numerical Study of Acoustic Streaming in Mid-Air Phased Arrays Preprint: AIP/123-QED Christopher Stone, Yusuke Koroyasu, Yoichi Ochiai, Akiko Kaneko, Bruce W. Drinkwater, Tatsuki Fushimi Abstract Mid-air acoustic streaming, where ultrasound induces steady fluid motion, could significantly affect the perception of haptic sensations, stability of levitation systems, and enable controlled transfer of odours (smells) through air by directing volatile compounds to specific locations. Despite its importance, the streaming behavior in airborne phased-array transducers remains poorly understood. Here, we use particle image velocimetry and numerical simulations to investigate streaming dynamics in single- and multi-focus acoustic fields. Experimental measurements reveal streaming velocities exceeding 0.4 ​ m/s 0.4~\text{m/s} in single-focus configurations and up to 0.3 ​ m/s 0.3~\text{m/s} in multi-focus setups, with distinct grating lobe-induced lateral jets. While multi-physics finite-element models effectively capture central streaming, they exhibit subtle differences and perform poorly in capturing flow in the side lobes. These findings provide valuable insights into the interplay between acoustic field design and streaming dynamics, offering guidance for optimizing ultrasonic technologies in haptics and levitation applications. I Introduction Acoustic streaming has been extensively investigated in liquid media and microchannels, where ultrasound-induced streaming reveals intricate fluid dynamics Muller and Bruus 2014 ; Das, Snider, and Bhethanabotla 2020 . These studies contributed significantly to understanding acoustic streaming in confined liquid geometries and its applications in particle manipulation, fluid mixing, and lab-on-chip technologies Karlsen and Bruus 2015 ; Wiklund, Green, and Ohlin 2012 ; Hou et al. 2025 . The phenomenon of mid-air acoustic streaming stems from early work by Hasegawa et al. Hasegawa et al. 2017 , and many follow-up studies have explored applications such as fog Norasikin et al. 2019 , odor displays Hasegawa, Qiu, and Shinoda 2017 and localized cooling sensations Nakajima et al. 2021 . Furthermore, acoustic streaming could affect the performance of technologies such as volumetric displays Fushimi et al. 2019 ; Hirayama et al. 2019 and digital microfluidics Koroyasu et al. 2023 . While streaming velocity measurements using mechanical Norasikin et al. 2019 and hot-wire anemometers Hasegawa et al. 2017 ; Hasegawa, Yuki, and Shinoda 2019 have been reported, these methods are prone to inaccuracies from nonlinear acoustic field interactions. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) offers a more direct and reliable method for capturing streaming velocity fields, as demonstrated in measurements of flows driven by Langevin horns and focused transducer arrays Stone et al. 2025 . Here, we apply PIV to characterize airborne streaming flows induced by flat phased array transducers (PATs), addressing a critical gap in understanding these systems. PATs can shape and steer acoustic fields to enable advanced airborne applications. This study systematically explores focal distances, beam geometries, and multi-focus configurations, comparing experimental results with numerical predictions under different attenuation assumptions. The results provide new insights into the design of high-power ultrasonic systems, particularly, the influence of focal distance on streaming fields, impact of grating lobes, and transient responses, ultimately offering a comprehensive framework for optimizing ultrasonic applications in haptics, odor displays, and levitation. II Methods II.1 Experimental setup A 16 \times 16 array of open-type air coupled transducers (MA40S4S, Murata, Japan) based on OpenMPD design was used in the experiment (see Montano-Murillo et al. Montano-Murillo, Hirayama, and Plasencia 2023 for details on the array). A MOSFET driver (MIC4127YME) was used to drive the array at a frequency of f=40 kHz. For PIV measurements, the array was positioned at the bottom of a 1\times 1\times 1.2 m enclosed chamber filled with smoke particles (KINCHO Mosquito Coil, Japan Insecticide Mfg. Co.). A 5W green laser was used to illuminate the particles, with the laser plane positioned at y=0 mm (that is in the xz- plane). A Sony \alpha 9 camera (positioned 560 mm from the plane) with a Sony 16-35 mm lens was used to capture the particle displacements at a frame rate of 240 Hz, capturing 1000 frames per case. PIVlab in MATLAB Stamhuis and Thielicke 2014 was used to process the data and calculate the streaming velocity fields. II.2 Huygens’ Principle Model for the Pressure Field The acoustic pressure field was modeled using a 3D Huygens’ principle model approach. The total pressure field p was computed by superimposing contributions from all transducers: p=\sum_{n}^{N}\frac{P_{\text{scale}}}{R_{n}}D(k,\theta_{n})e^{j(kR_{n}+\phi_{n})}, where P_{\text{scale}}=0.179V_{in} is the transducer power based on the input voltage V_{in} , R_{n} is the distance from the transducer to the field point, D(k,\theta) is the directivity function (see Supplementary Material), and k=2\pi/\lambda is the wavenumber. The phase shifts \phi_{n} were calculated to generate specific beam types. For focused beams, \phi_{n} ensured constructive interference at the focal point, while for Bessel beams, the phases were derived based on the cone angle and transducer geometry. Multi-focus fields were calculated using the iterative backpropagation (IBP) algorithm, which iteratively adjusts transducer pressures to achieve specified amplitudes at multiple focal points. The IBP method was implemented as described in Marzo & Drinkwater Marzo and Drinkwater 2019 . Detailed derivations of the phase calculations for focused, Bessel, and multi-focus fields are provided in the Supplementary Material. II.3 Acoustic Streaming Force The acoustic particle velocity was computed as: \textbf{v}_{1}=\frac{1}{j\omega\rho}\nabla p , where \omega=2\pi f , f is the frequency, and \rho is the air density. Using this velocity, the acoustic intensity vector was calculated as: \textbf{I}=\frac{1}{2}\Re(p\cdot\textbf{v}_{1}^{*}), where \textbf{v}_{1}^{*} denotes the complex conjugate of the particle velocity. The streaming force per unit volume was then given by: \frac{\textbf{F}_{s}}{dV}=\frac{2\alpha\textbf{I}}{c}, where c is the speed of sound and \alpha is the attenuation coefficient. The methods used to calculate \alpha are described below. II.4 Attenuation Coefficients Two attenuation mechanisms were incorporated into the model: thermoviscous and atmospheric. Figure 1: Comparison of experimental (a) and numerical (b–c) streaming velocity fields obtained under different attenuation models. Data were acquired using a focused beam at (0, 0, 80) mm, 5V. Experimental measurements (a) reveal pronounced grating lobe jets alongside a focused central jet. The thermoviscous model (b) significantly underestimates both the central flow and the grating lobe jets. The atmospheric model (c) shows improvement but still underestimates the grating lobe jets. The thermoviscous attenuation coefficient was calculated using the Stokes-Kirchhoff relation Hu, Wang, and Wang 2015 : \alpha_{\text{thermoviscous}}=\frac{\omega^{2}}{2\rho c^{3}}\left(\frac{4\mu}{3}+\mu_{B}+(\gamma-1)\frac{k_{\text{cond}}}{C_{p}}\right), where \mu is the dynamic viscosity, \mu_{B} is the bulk viscosity, \gamma is the ratio of specific heats, k_{\text{cond}} is the thermal conductivity, and C_{p} is the specific heat capacity at constant pressure. A detailed derivation of this equation is included in the Supplementary Material. The atmospheric attenuation coefficient was given by Bass et al. 1995 : \alpha_{\text{atmospheric}}=f^{2}\left(B_{1}\cdot\frac{f_{rN}}{f_{rN}^{2}+f^{2}}+B_{2}\cdot\frac{f_{rO}}{f_{rO}^{2}+f^{2}}+B_{3}\right), where B_{1} , B_{2} , and B_{3} are temperature- and pressure-dependent coefficients, and f_{rN} , f_{rO} are the relaxation frequencies of nitrogen and oxygen. The expressions for these coefficients and relaxation frequencies are provided in the Supplementary Material. Constants such as the relative humidity, absolute temperature, and saturation vapor pressure are listed in Supplementary Material. II.5 Numerical Implementation The 3D Huygens’ principle model and resulting acoustic streaming force were implemented in MATLAB. The forces (sliced in 2D plane) were exported as CSV files and imported into COMSOL Multiphysics 6.2 using interpolation to apply the forces as volume forces. A 2D mirror symmetry along the x=0 boundary and a laminar flow model was assumed for all models. The modeled domain had a width of 200\,~\text{mm} and a height of 400\,~\text{mm} .

Read the complete text