Expressive Timing in Hindustani Vocal Music

Yash Bhake and Preeti Rao · 2025

Read Expressive Timing in Hindustani Vocal Music by Yash Bhake and Preeti Rao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-21142.txt.

Introduction

Yash Bhake and Preeti Rao measure how singers bend the beat in Hindustani vocal music in this 2025 paper. Masters of the style often sing off the steady tabla beat on purpose, and the drift carries expression. The team built a computational method to quantify those timing gaps across whole performances.

They applied it to two renditions of a popular song frame in raga Yaman. The measures separated the fixed pull of the style from each singer's personal signature. Small timing choices, invisible to a casual ear, showed up as clear patterns. The authors frame the work as a step toward computer analysis and generation of Indian classical performance, where timing is part of the art.

Catalog record

CREATORYash Bhake and Preeti Rao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-21142

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Expressive Timing in Hindustani Vocal Music Yash Bhake and Preeti Rao Abstract Temporal dynamics are among the cues to expressiveness in music performance in different cultures. In the case of Hindustani music, it is well known that expert vocalists often take liberties with the beat, intentionally not aligning their singing precisely with the relatively steady beat provided by the accompanying tabla. This becomes evident when comparing performances of the same composition such as a bandish . We present a methodology for the quantitative study of differences across performed pieces using computational techniques. This is applied to small study of two performances of a popular bandish in raga Yaman , to demonstrate how we can effectively capture the nuances of timing variations that bring out stylistic constraints along with the individual signature of a performer. This work articulates an important step towards the broader goals of music analysis and generative modelling for Indian classical music performance. I Introduction Bandish are notated lyrical compositions in the Hindustani music genre that serve as a reference for the associated raga in terms of the overall pitch movement and characteristic phrases. A bandish comprises two verses, typically with 2-4 lines each. Vocal concerts include the singing of a bandish in the chosen raga . Performers bring in different variations in the rendition of a given bandish and we also see variations in the same bandish lines across repetitions within the performance. The variations are evident to listeners, who are usually familiar with the prototypical form of the bandish . The associated auditory experience is greatly appreciated especially when executed by expert musicians. In a work that addresses ‘musical expressiveness’ across cultures, Fabian et al. [ 1 ] refer to the effects caused by the variation of auditory parameters such as loudness, intensity, phrasing and tempo away from a prototypical performance but strictly within stylistic constraints. They make it clear that expressiveness does not refer to any features of the composition itself or the emotion that is expressed. The vocal rendition of a bandish in a Hindustani music concert can therefore be considered suitable for the investigation of the kind of variation that constitutes musical expressiveness. We refer to the widely regarded book of V. N. Bhatkhande [ 2 ] who collected and notated a large number of traditional compositions from across the country in the early 20^{th} century. The Bhatkhande notated compositions serve as a convenient reference for a discussion of the measured variations of a given bandish line across performers. With schematic notation that depicts the melodic outline using the syllables of the lyrics, it is possible to relate the sung performance to the canonical version via the corresponding lyrics syllables. In this work, we use computational techniques to compare the performances of a given bandish by different artists. We present our methodology that includes automatic techniques for some of the audio feature extraction. We focus solely on timing expressiveness, leaving the study of pitch inflections and other dynamics that can also define expressiveness, to future work. In particular, we are interested in developing computational methods that capture the similarities and differences between different performances of the same bandish . We illustrate our approach with a small study of audio recordings by two expert vocalists of a well-known bandish in raga Yaman to draw insights about individual differences as well as the adherance to any genre-specific contraints. The motivation for our work is to model the variations in acoustic parameters that can lead to the deeper understanding of music performance and the strategies used by accomplished musicians. This can potentially contribute to quantitative models for music generation from notation that are consistent with the intricacies of the specific genre and style. II Dataset and Preparation Table I describes our dataset comprising audio and metadata for several performances of bandish in raga Yaman , a popular raga which is taught early in music training and widely performed on the concert stage. In terms of choice of bandish , we restrict ourselves to madhyalay and drut (medium and fast tempo) due to the relatively high complexity and freedom in vilambit (slow tempo) bandish . We select bandish where we have the canonical notation from Kramik Pustak Malika [ 2 ] . Next, for each bandish , we look for good quality audios recordings ranging from maestro concerts to simpler teaching websites to capture performance diversity, including also recordings from Samarpan by Pt. I. Nirody [ 3 ] , following the methodology of Madhumitha [ 4 ] . The audio performance comprises the singing voice accompanied by the tabla supplying the relatively steady beat and defining the rhythmic grid for the chosen tala. A complete acoustic characterisation in terms of musically relevant parameters would need the onset instants of each of the tabla strokes and the sung syllables, and the notes (including pitch inflections or melodic ornamentation). Given the correspondence between the lyric syllables and the notes in the schematic notation of the composition, we expect the timing expressiveness to be manifested in the deviation of the sung syllables from the specified beat locations. The reliable detection of onsets of sung syllables apart from tabla stroke onsets is a component of the automated audio processing. It is necessary also to establish a temporal alignment of the note events between the performances to be compared. This is achieved using the matching of the lyrics or syllable sequences. In this section, we present our manually labeled dataset that facilitates the development of the needed text processing as well as audio processing for onsets. Raga Raga Yaman # bandish 5 # Recordings 14 # Talas 1 # Artists 8 # Canonical lines 33 # Syllable Onsets 2041 # Syllables (canonical) 274 Matra per min range 110-180 Total duration (min) 25.25 TABLE I: Summary of the dataset used for onset detection evaluation II-A Concert audio segmentation Our dataset 1 1 1 The audio files can be accessed in the supplementary material [ 5 ] is largely comprised of recordings from concerts on YouTube aside from the above-mentioned organized collections. We required good-quality audio with clearly intelligible vocals to facilitate our intended audio processing steps. Given our interest in the performance of the lines of the bandish , we extract these segments from the full recital, doing away with the improvisation fillers such as the alap and vistar . Source separation with a commercially available tool - Gaudiolab [ 6 ] was applied to obtain the vocals-only audio and the complementary track with tabla accompaniment, harmonium and the drone. The vocal segments are manually marked for syllable onsets, which are further labelled by the syllable as heard (and also consistent with the lyrics of the composition). The manual detection of onsets is greatly facilitated by using a wideband spectrogram display where the consonant-vowel transitions are relatively prominent [ 7 ] . Similarly, for the accompaniment track, we manually annotated the sam (1 st beat) and khali (9 th beat), the two salient beats in the applicable 16-beat rhythmic cycle teentaal . The intervals between these salient beats were divided into eight equal parts, given that each audio clip in our dataset has a nearly constant tempo as also realised by the tabla

Read the complete text