Inferring fine-grained migration patterns across the United States

Gabriel Agostini, Rachel Young, Maria Fitzpatrick, Nikhil Garg, Emma Pierson · 2025

Read Inferring fine-grained migration patterns across the United States by Gabriel Agostini, Rachel Young, Maria Fitzpatrick, Nikhil Garg, Emma Pierson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20989.txt.

Introduction

Gabriel Agostini, Rachel Young, Maria Fitzpatrick, Nikhil Garg, and Emma Pierson published a study in 2025 on mapping fine-grained migration across the United States. Public data are too coarse, while detailed private data carry biases. Their method fuses both sources into annual flow matrices between census block groups, thousands of times finer than public data. The product is called MIGRATE.

Checks against outside ground truth show strong agreement and better accuracy than raw private data. Nationally, the maps reveal how sameness of neighbors, upward moves, and travel distance vary by group and year. Locally, they expose patterns such as wildfire-driven departures that coarse data hide. The team releases MIGRATE as a public resource.

Catalog record

CREATORGabriel Agostini, Rachel Young, Maria Fitzpatrick, Nikhil Garg, Emma Pierson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20989

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Inferring fine-grained migration patterns across the United States Gabriel Agostini, Rachel Young, Maria Fitzpatrick, Nikhil Garg, Emma Pierson Abstract Fine-grained migration data illuminate important demographic, environmental, and health phenomena. However, migration datasets within the United States remain lacking: publicly available Census data are neither spatially nor temporally granular, and proprietary data have higher resolution but demographic and other biases. To address these limitations, we develop a scalable iterative-proportional-fitting based method which reconciles high-resolution but biased proprietary data with low-resolution but more reliable Census data. We apply this method to produce MIGRATE , a dataset of annual migration matrices from 2010 - 2019 which captures flows between 47.4 billion pairs of Census Block Groups — about four thousand times more granular than publicly available data. These estimates are highly correlated with external ground-truth datasets, and improve accuracy and reduce bias relative to raw proprietary data. We publicly release MIGRATE estimates and provide a case study illustrating how they reveal granular patterns of migration in response to California wildfires. 1 Introduction Fine-grained migration data, which record the number of people relocating from one geographic area to another, are essential for understanding a range of social, environmental, and health phenomena. Migration patterns illuminate responses to environmental disasters and climate change Hoffmann et al. 2024 ; Kaysen 2025 ; McConnell et al. 2024 ; responses to economic stresses and opportunities Diamond et al. 2020 ; Wilkerson 2010 ; Niva et al. 2023 ; patterns of social change DePillis 2024 ; effects of the COVID-19 pandemic Ramani et al. 2024 ; and political polarization Kaysen and Singer 2024 . But migration data within the United States have serious limitations. The most fine-grained freely available datasets track migration at the county level. While widely used, these datasets lack sufficient spatial resolution to study a number of phenomena where previous research has revealed important variation at the sub-county level. For example, research on flood-risk-induced migration uses models at the much more granular Census block level Shu et al. 2023 , arguing that this spatial granularity is necessary due to the highly localized nature of flood risk Craig 2024 . Research on neighborhoods which are vulnerable to climate-induced eviction or displacement similarly models risk at a sub-county (Census tract) level Tedesco et al. 2021 . Movers within the same county have accounted for more than half of migratory flows in the United States in all years from 2006 to 2019 Kerns-D’Amore et al. 2023 . Publicly available, county-level migration datasets render these patterns entirely invisible. Proprietary migration datasets offer greater granularity. Data aggregators like Infutor Infutor Data Solutions, LLC 2019 combine many data sources — including voter files, property deeds, credit files, and phone books Diamond et al. 2019 — to attempt to infer address histories for individual-level movers. Such datasets have been widely used because they are extremely temporally and spatially fine-grained Phillips 2020 ; Diamond et al. 2020 ; Bernstein et al. 2022 ; Asquith et al. 2019 ; Qian and Tan 2021 . Previous work also suggests these data do contain valuable signal which correlates with external datasets, as validated by cross-referencing the data with hurricanes or public housing foreclosures Phillips 2020 , and with marginal population counts in the region of interest Diamond et al. 2019 . However, these proprietary datasets have three major disadvantages. First, they are not publicly available, limiting their utility to researchers. Second, they require extensive computational pipelines, and substantial computational resources, to clean and map to standardized geographical areas to facilitate subsequent analysis. Third, and most fundamentally, they combine multiple imperfect data sources using proprietary algorithms, and thus contain noise and biases. For example, Infutor and other consumer record datasets have been shown to overrepresent higher-income and majority-group populations in some settings Ramiller et al. 2024 . To address these limitations of existing migration data, we create and release MIGRATE ( M igration I nference for GRA nular T rend E stimation): fine-grained migration estimates which combine the strengths of both aforementioned types of data by harmonizing biased but fine-grained proprietary data with reliable but coarse Census data. To produce our estimates, we develop a method based on iterative proportional fitting (IPF), an algorithm which repeatedly scales a noisy matrix to reconcile it with constraints Deming and Stephan 1940 , to reconcile the raw Infutor migration matrix with the more reliable Census constraints. We accommodate uncertainty in address mapping and incorporate data on births, deaths, and immigration. The output of our method is a set of yearly inferred migration matrices at the Census block group (CBG) level from 2010-2019 covering the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Our matrices capture migration flows between 47.4 billion pairs of CBGs, making MIGRATE approximately 4,600 times more granular than the county-county flows which are currently available on the 5-year level, and 18 million times more granular than the state-state flows which are currently available on the 1-year level. We comprehensively validate MIGRATE by comparing it to external data sources. We show that our estimates correlate well with fine-grained Census and ACS data on population counts and migration flows. We show that MIGRATE improves accuracy relative to raw Infutor data: in particular, it reduces the deviation from ground truth ACS county-to-county migration estimates by 90%. We document systematic demographic biases in the Infutor data, which overcounts rural, older, white, and home-owning populations, and show that MIGRATE almost entirely eliminates these biases. To illustrate the benefits of granular migration data, we provide a case study using our estimates to study migration in response to California wildfires, showing that MIGRATE reveals dramatic increases in out-migration which county-level data obscures. To provide a foundation for more precise migration research in the social, environmental, and health sciences, we release MIGRATE for other researchers at migrate.tech.cornell.edu . 2 Creating MIGRATE Here we provide a high-level summary of our method for inferring fine-grained migration matrices by harmonizing Census and Infutor data. In the Appendix, we provide full details of processing the Infutor dataset (Appendix 6 ), processing Census data (Appendix 7 ), and harmonizing the two data sources (Appendix 8 ). Preprocessing the raw Infutor dataset We first preprocess the raw Infutor data into yearly migration matrices. The raw Infutor data consists of sequences of addresses for individual people. We use this information to compute the number of people moving between each pair of geographic areas. In particular, we estimate the matrices E^{(t)} , where entries E^{(t)}_{ij} represent the number of people who reside in CBG j some time during year t and resided in CBG i a year prior. We provide descriptive statistics for the raw Infutor data and the processed migration matrices for the 2010-2019 time period in Table 1 and additional descriptive statistics in Appendix Table 2 . Individuals with active records (any time in 2010-2019) 374,217,253 Individuals with active records in a given year (average across 2010-2019) 231,270,602 US population in 2010 309,327,143 US population in 2019 328,329,953 Address records per active individual (mean) 2.67 Address records per active individual (median) 2 Table 1 : Summary statistics for raw Infutor data and Census data during the period of interest (2010-2019). We define “individuals with active records” as those whose [earliest Infutor date observed, latest

Read the complete text