Host-dependent frequency offsets in Th 229 \hphantom{{}^{\text{229}}_{\text{}}}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}{}^{\mathchoice{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\displaystyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\textstyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\scriptstyle\vph
U. C. Perera, H. W. T. Morgan, Eric R. Hudson, Andrei Derevianko · 2025
Read Host-dependent frequency offsets in Th 229 \hphantom{{}^{\text{229}}_{\text{}}}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}{}^{\mathchoice{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\displaystyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\textstyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\scriptstyle\vph by U. C. Perera, H. W. T. Morgan, Eric R. Hudson, Andrei Derevianko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20984.txt.
Introduction
Perera and co-authors compute how a crystal host shifts a nuclear clock in a 2025 paper. Thorium 229 holds a rare low energy nuclear transition that lasers can now reach. A clock built on it could outclass atomic clocks and sense new physics. The snag: the frequency shifts with the host material, through the isomer shift between nuclear states.
Atomic many body methods joined solid state theory to value the shift across hosts. A relaxation effect, the electron cloud's readjustment, proved critical to get right. Predictions cover solid hosts and trapped ions. Builders of the first nuclear clocks need exactly this table before choosing where to park their thorium.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | U. C. Perera, H. W. T. Morgan, Eric R. Hudson, Andrei Derevianko |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20984
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Host-dependent frequency offsets in Th 229 \hphantom{{}^{\text{229}}_{\text{}}}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}{}^{\mathchoice{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\displaystyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\textstyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\scriptstyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}{\hbox to0.0pt{\hss$\scriptscriptstyle\vphantom{\smash[t]{\text{2}}}\text{229}$}}}\kern 0.0pt\text{Th} nuclear clockwork U. C. Perera, H. W. T. Morgan, Eric R. Hudson, Andrei Derevianko Abstract Recent advances in laser excitation of the low-energy nuclear isomer transition in Th 229 {}^{229}\textrm{Th} have opened avenues for developing nuclear clocks, a novel quantum technology with exceptional performance and sensitivity to exotic physics. Here we explore the host-dependence of the nuclear clock frequency, focusing on the isomer shift induced by the difference in the nuclear charge distribution between the ground and excited nuclear states. We combine relativistic many-body methods of atomic structure with periodic density functional theory to evaluate the isomer shifts in solid-state hosts. We elucidate the critical importance of the “relaxation” effect in evaluating the isomer shifts. Our analysis predicts nuclear clock frequencies for various solid-state and trapped ion platforms: ω clk ( solid state ) = 2,020,407,384 ( 40 ) MHz \omega_{\text{clk}}(\text{solid state})=2,020,407,384(40)\,\text{MHz} , ω clk ( 229 Th 4 + ) = 2,020,407,648 ( 70 ) MHz \omega_{\text{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th}^{4+})=2,020,407,648(70)\,\text{MHz} , and ω clk ( 229 Th 3 + ) = 2,020,407,114 ( 70 ) MHz \omega_{\text{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th}^{3+})=2,020,407,114(70)\,\text{MHz} . We also determine the nuclear transition energy for the bare Th 229 {}^{229}\textrm{Th} nucleus to be ω nuc = 8.272 ( 22 ) eV \omega_{\text{nuc}}=8.272(22)\,\text{eV} . Our calculated valence-band isomer shifts for different host materials constrain the nuclear transition frequencies to an 80 MHz-wide frequency window, aiding experimental searches for the Th 229 {}^{229}\textrm{Th} nuclear transition in novel materials. Recent observations [ Tiedau2024 , Elwell2024 , Zhang2024-Th229Comb , zhang2024thf ] of laser excitation of a uniquely low-energy nuclear isomer transition in {}^{229}\textrm{Th} pave the road for realizing a novel class of timekeeping devices, nuclear clocks. Beyond timekeeping, this nascent quantum technology can be exquisitely sensitive to a variety of exotic physics [ SafBudDeM2018.RMP ] . One may distinguish between two nuclear clock platforms [ PieTam03 ] 1 1 1 Clocks based on neutral Th atoms would suffer from the rapid internal conversion process whereby the {}^{229}\textrm{Th } nucleus transfers its excitation to the atomic electrons, ionizing the Th atom. : (i) trapped Th ions, e.g., \textrm{Th}^{3+} [ CamRadKuz12 ] and (ii) {}^{229}\textrm{Th} -containing crystals [ Rellergert2010 ] , such as {}^{229}\textrm{Th} : \textrm{LiSrAlF}_{6} , {}^{229}\textrm{Th} : \textrm{CaF}_{2} doped bulk crystals [ Tiedau2024 , Elwell2024 , Zhang2024-Th229Comb ] , or {}^{229}\textrm{Th}\textrm{F}_{4} films [ zhang2024thf ] . The two platforms offer distinct trade-offs between the nuclear clock accuracy and stability. Solid‐state clocks offer superior stability by interrogating macroscopic ensembles of nuclei simultaneously and provide a pathway to truly portable, high‐performance timekeeping. However, solid‐state platforms are prone to inhomogeneous broadening and environment‐dependent shifts, though recent work may show ways to largely mitigate these [ Morgan2025-design-of-Th-materials , morgan2025-spinless ] . By contrast, the trapped‐ion platforms, which should provide superior accuracy, require long integration times to reach their ultimate resolution. It can thus be expected that both types of nuclear clocks will find great use and it is important to understand their relationship. In particular, the nuclear transition energy, which defines the “ticking” rate of the clock, can be expected to vary due to the interaction of nuclei with the electronic degrees of freedom in various hosts. Here we evaluate isomer shifts induced by the difference in the nuclear charge distribution between the ground and excited nuclear states. These primarily govern differences (offsets) in nuclear clock frequencies between various {}^{229}\textrm{Th} hosts. Our analysis predicts nuclear clock frequencies for these platforms, which both aids the experiments and relates the results for the two classes of nuclear clocks allowing them to be refined together. The nuclear clock transition frequency \omega_{\mathrm{clk}} is affected by the host environment of the {}^{229}\textrm{Th} nucleus. So far the nuclear transition signal has been observed only in the solid-state platforms with the measured transition frequencies [ zhang2024thf , Zhang2024-Th229Comb , Elwell2024 ] : \omega_{\mathrm{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th}\textrm{F}_{4})=2,020,407.4(3)_{\mathrm{stat}}(30)_{\mathrm{sys}}\,\mathrm{GHz} , \omega_{\mathrm{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th:LiSrAlF}_{6})=2,020,407.3(5)_{\textrm{stat}}(30)_{\textrm{sys}}\,\mathrm{GHz} , and \omega_{\text{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th:CaF}_{2})=2,020,407,384.335(2)\,\text{MHz} . While the already measured frequencies agree at the stated 30 GHz level of accuracy, we show that a difference arises below roughly 100 MHz resolution, well above the demonstrated kHz VUV frequency comb resolution [ Zhang2024-Th229Comb ] . There is a wide variety of other hosting materials proposed [ Morgan2025-Th229NonLinear , morgan2025-spinless , Morgan2025-design-of-Th-materials , Ellis2014 , RN552 ] . A practical challenge faced by an experimentalist is to pinpoint the narrow nuclear transition by scanning the laser frequency. We simplify this tedious process by exacting a \sim 100\,\mathrm{MHz} -wide scanning window for the nuclear clock spectroscopy. We predict the nuclear clock frequencies for both the solid state and trapped ion platforms: \displaystyle\omega_{\text{clk}}(\text{solid state})= \displaystyle 2,020,407,384(40)\,\text{MHz}\,, (1) \displaystyle\omega_{\text{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th}^{4+})= \displaystyle 2,020,407,648(70)\,\text{MHz}\,, (2) \displaystyle\omega_{\text{clk}}(^{229}\textrm{Th}^{3+},5f_{5/2})= \displaystyle 2,020,407,114(70)\,\text{MHz}\,. (3) We also deduce the nuclear transition energy in the bare {}^{229}\textrm{Th} nucleus (i.e., the {}^{229}\textrm{Th} 90+ ion) \omega_{\text{nuc}}=8.272(22)\,\text{eV}\,. (4) To this end, we examine how the nuclear clock frequency depends on the local electronic environment of the {}^{229}\textrm{Th } nucleus. This dependence arises from the isomer (chemical) shift, which results from the differences in the nuclear charge distributions between the nuclear ground and isomeric states. Remarkably [ morgan2025-spinless ] , a competing second-order Doppler shift is significantly reduced for {}^{229}\textrm{Th} compared to nuclear transitions used in Mößbauer spectroscopy because the nuclear transition energy in {}^{229}\textrm{Th} , Eq. ( 4 ), is several orders of magnitude smaller. Otherwise, the chemical shifts are often masked by the Doppler shifts [ gibb1976-MossbauerBook ] . We develop a method to evaluate the isomer shift in solid-state hosts. While compatible with periodic density functional theory (DFT) approaches, our method incorporates essential relaxation effects that are difficult to account for in DFT in a relativistic framework required for heavy thorium. The nuclear transition of interest is nominally between the ground |g\rangle=|(5/2)^{+}[633]\rangle and the isomer |e\rangle=|(3/2)^{+}[631]\rangle nuclear states of {}^{229}\textrm{Th} , where we use the Nilsson quantum numbers. Since the two nuclear states possess different charge distributions and electromagnetic moments interacting with electrons, the clock frequency is determined by the eigenenergies of the compound nucleus-electron system. Namely, transitions between the eigenstates of the compound system are probed in laser spectroscopy. We distinguish between the monopole (electric charge distribution), magnetic dipole, and electric quadrupole interactions of the nucleus with the electrons. The effects of the magnetic and quadrupolar couplings interacting with the local electronic environment can be removed by proper weighted averaging of transition frequencies between various magnetic sublevels [ Zhang2024-Th229Comb ] . It is the resulting frequency that we refer to as the clock frequency \omega_{\mathrm{clk}} . This averaging cannot, however, remove the effects of the electrons interacting with the nuclear charge distributions due to the scalar nature of the interaction and \omega_{\mathrm{clk}} depends on the electronic environment (leading to the isomer shift \delta\omega_{\mathrm{iso}} of the clock frequency). Formalism — We start with the conventional parameterization [ Filatov2009-review ] of the isomer shift (also known as the chemical shift) in Mößbauer spectroscopy and later demonstrate its inadequacy for the {}^{229}\textrm{Th} solid-state hosts. The conventional parameterization reads \delta E_{\mathrm{iso}}=\frac{4\pi}{5}ZS(Z)R^{2}\frac{\Delta R}{R}\rho(0)\,, (5) where Z and R are the nuclear charge and the r.m.s charge radius, respectively, \Delta R=R_{e}-R_{g} is the difference in the r.m.s nuclear charge radii for the isomer and the ground states, and \rho(0) is the electron density at the nucleus. In