Sociotechnical Effects of Machine Translation
Joss Moorkens, Andy Way, Séamus Lankford · 2025
Read Sociotechnical Effects of Machine Translation by Joss Moorkens, Andy Way, Séamus Lankford (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20959.txt.
Introduction
Joss Moorkens, Andy Way, and Seamus Lankford discuss side effects of machine translation in a 2025 book chapter. Translation tools help in many settings, but neural and large model systems carry costs. Training huge corporate models uses much electricity and produces large carbon emissions, while smaller or tuned models can cut that footprint.
The chapter also covers harm to translators and other users, copyright and data ownership, and ethics of data use. It closes on a positive case. Used properly, machine translation in crisis settings can save lives, and the authors give a method for doing so.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joss Moorkens, Andy Way, Séamus Lankford |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20959
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Sociotechnical Effects of Machine Translation Joss Moorkens, Andy Way, Séamus Lankford Abstract While the previous chapters have shown how machine translation (MT) can be useful, in this chapter ( Moorkens et al. 2024d ) we discuss some of the side-effects and risks that are associated, and how they might be mitigated. With the move to neural MT and approaches using Large Language Models (LLMs), there is an associated impact on climate change, as the models built by multinational corporations are massive. They are hugely expensive to train, consume large amounts of electricity, and output huge volumes of kgCO 2 to boot. However, smaller models which still perform to a high level of quality can be built with much lower carbon footprints, and tuning pre-trained models saves on the requirement to train from scratch. We also discuss the possible detrimental effects of MT on translators and other users. The topics of copyright and ownership of data are discussed, as well as ethical considerations on data and MT use. Finally, we show how if done properly, using MT in crisis scenarios can save lives, and we provide a method of how this might be done. 1 Introduction When Weaver 1949 proposed his ideas that prompted work on RBMT (as described in Chapter 1 ( Moorkens et al. 2024b ) ), he felt that even imperfect MT could contribute to “the constructive and peaceful future of the planet” by facilitating cultural interchange and international understanding. Now that imperfect, yet undoubtedly useful (and more than occasionally very good) MT is a reality, the repercussions are broader than Weaver could have imagined. We can safely say that MT facilitates cultural interchange for the over one billion users of the Google Translate Android app ( Pitman 2021 ) , to name just one MT provider, but to what extent does the risk of mistranslation put those users at risk? Is MT safe to use in a crisis, such as an earthquake or pandemic? What is the relationship between MT and sustainability? It should be quite clear by now that we are very positively disposed towards MT, but that does not mean that we are unaware of the risks of its inappropriate use. Mid-century philosophers such as Heidegger 1977 tended to have a negative view of technology, but many current ethicists and philosophers of technology are more open-minded. They generally agree that technology is not necessarily good nor bad, although nor is it neutral ( Kranzberg 1986 ) , but for example, Ihde 1990 feels that it is the interaction with humans that is important, believing that technology “becomes what it “is” through its uses”. So what are the appropriate uses of MT? Way 2013 offers a number of use-cases for MT and post-editing across a range of application areas (as well as where it should not be used) and proposes the following rule of thumb: the level of automation in translation should equate to the value, risk, and shelf-life of a text. We can extend that to the generation of text and media using LLMs. A social media message is unlikely to be reread after a couple of hours, and an online review might be displaced by another in a similarly short time, so the shelf-life is short, and any risk arising from translation of such content is probably low. In contrast, patient instructions from a hospital or ingredients for medicines are high-risk and will need significant human oversight. A three-word slogan on a billboard is of high value, so do we really want to risk automating translation? In this case, it’s probably best not to ‘just do it’ (see Guerberof-Arenas and Moorkens 2023 for more on this topic). The risks and repercussions of the use of MT and LLMs are broader than the decisions to use or not to use them to automatically translate (or produce, in the monolingual LLM context) a text. In this chapter ( Moorkens et al. 2024d ) , we look at a few of these repercussions and ask the key questions laid out in Table 1 . The intention is not to say that MT is good or bad, but that it can have positive or negative effects through its uses. Now that you have learned how MT works and how to create your own MT system, it is important to become a critical and responsible user of MT. In the following sections, we look at some risks in the use of MT, beginning with social and environmental sustainability and MT. We come back to questions of data that we touched upon in Chapter 2 ( Moorkens et al. 2024e ) , then consider bias, power, and diversity. Finally, we look at MT for good, such as its use in crises and show how MT, carefully deployed, can literally save lives. Key questions What are the common ethical issues regarding NMT and LLMs? Are AI tools environmentally sustainable? What is the carbon footprint of an average NMT system? Are AI tools socially sustainable? What are the risks of concentrating technology and power in a small number of multinational companies? How might we apply MT for the common good? How might we empower people with NMT and LLMs? Table 1: What are the sociotechnical effects of MT? 2 Ethical issues in MT The aim of this book is to empower readers with skills and knowledge for translation automation. However, development of MT and LLMs doesn’t happen in a vacuum, and while our small-scale systems are unlikely to have much of an effect on the outside world, it’s worth being aware of some wider context. In this final chapter we will summarise some of the ethical issues regarding MT very briefly. We have touched on these here and there earlier in the book (regarding data in Chapter 2 ( Moorkens et al. 2024e ) , for example, and evaluation in Chapter 5 ( Moorkens et al. 2024g ) ). Publications listed in the Further Reading section will provide you with more detail and discussion, as more work emerges on these important topics as MT use continues to increase. 2.1 MT and sustainability In 1987, the Brundtland Commission ( Brundtland 1987 ) reported that sustainable development “meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs”. With huge numbers of users, MT appears to meet the needs of current users very well, but does it compromise those future generations? In this section, we take a broad view of sustainability, beginning with environmental sustainability and then moving to social sustainability. 2.1.1 MT and environmental sustainability The orthodoxy in much of the language industry and in big tech is that bigger models are always better. We showed in Chapter 2 ( Moorkens et al. 2024e ) that NMT systems typically require amounts of data of larger magnitudes than for SMT in order to ensure good-quality output (although we’ve also seen, in Chapter 1 ( Moorkens et al. 2024b ) and Chapter 6 ( Moorkens et al. 2024h ) , for example, that you don’t need huge resources to build an effective system, especially in well-defined application areas). However, as Cronin 2019 writes, engagement with technology needs to