Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk 2025 Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk – D
Rimpei Chiba, Neige Frankel, Chris Hamilton · 2025
Read Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk 2025 Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk – D by Rimpei Chiba, Neige Frankel, Chris Hamilton (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20869.txt.
Introduction
Rimpei Chiba, Neige Frankel, and Chris Hamilton explain a two-armed spiral pattern Gaia found in the inner Milky Way disk, in a 2025 paper. The pattern shows stars bobbing above and below the disk in a coordinated way, so something symmetric disturbed the disk. Disk bars and spiral arms were suspects, but they change too slowly to shake the inner disk directly.
The authors show a vertical resonance can break that protection. Near the resonance, steady spiral arm tugs plus random kicks from gas clouds build a two-armed spiral that rotates without winding up. Several resonances create local spirals turning at different speeds. The result removes the need for a short-lived disturber.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rimpei Chiba, Neige Frankel, Chris Hamilton |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20869
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk 2025 Origin of the two-armed vertical phase-spiral in the inner Galactic disk – D Rimpei Chiba, Neige Frankel, Chris Hamilton Abstract Gaia recently revealed a two-armed spiral pattern in the vertical phase-space distribution of the inner Galactic disk (guiding radius R g ∼ 6.2 kpc R_{\rm g}\sim 6.2\,{\rm kpc} ), indicating that some non-adiabatic perturbation symmetric about the mid-plane is driving the inner disk out of equilibrium. The non-axisymmetric structures in the disk (e.g., the bar or spiral arms) have been suspected to be the major source for such a perturbation. However, both the lifetime and the period of these internal perturbations are typically longer than the period at which stars oscillate vertically, implying that the perturbation is generally adiabatic. This issue is particularly pronounced in the inner Galaxy, where the vertical oscillation period is shorter and therefore adiabatically shielded more than the outer disk. We show that two-armed phase spirals can naturally form in the inner disk if there is a vertical resonance that breaks the adiabaticity; otherwise, their formation requires a perturber with an unrealistically short lifetime. We predict analytically and confirm with simulations that a steadily rotating (non-winding) two-armed phase spiral forms near the resonance when stars are subject to both periodic perturbations (e.g., by spiral arms) and stochastic perturbations (e.g., by giant molecular clouds). Due to the presence of multiple resonances, the vertical phase-space exhibits several local phase spirals that rotate steadily at distinct frequencies, together forming a global phase spiral that evolves over time. Our results demonstrate that, contrary to earlier predictions, the formation of the two-armed phase spiral does not require transient perturbations with lifetimes shorter than the vertical oscillation period. 1 Introduction One of the most important discoveries made by the Gaia satellite is arguably the remarkable spiral patterns found in the vertical phase-space of the Galactic stellar disk ( Antoja et al. 2018 ) . These phase spirals are clear manifestations of phase mixing ongoing in the Milky Way. Phase mixing occurs because the period of the stars’ vertical oscillation about the disk mid-plane increases with their amplitudes. The phase spiral initially identified in the Solar neighborhood was predominantly one-armed. The one-armed phase spiral implies that stars in the disk have experienced a coherent kick that caused a dipole perturbation in the vertical phase-space distribution, which subsequently sheared into a spiral pattern. Possible sources of the perturbation include the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy ( Binney & Schönrich 2018 ; Laporte et al. 2019 ; Li & Shen 2020 ; Bland-Hawthorn & Tepper-García 2021 ; Hunt et al. 2021 ; Asano et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , the dark matter wake it induced ( Grand et al. 2023 ) , the buckling of the bar ( Khoperskov et al. 2019 ) , bending waves in the disk ( Darling & Widrow 2019 ) , and the cumulative effect of many weak perturbations from dark matter substructures ( Tremaine et al. 2023 ; Gilman et al. 2024 ) . Recently, Hunt et al. 2022 mapped the phase spiral across the disk using the Gaia’s third data release (DR3), and discovered a two-armed phase spiral in the inner disk 1 1 1 We refer to stars in the “inner disk” as those with small guiding radius ( R_{\rm g}\sim 6.2\,{\rm kpc} ) and not necessary those located in the inner disk. The stars analysed in Hunt et al. 2022 are in fact all restricted to the Solar neighborhood. (Fig. 1 ). This finding came as a surprise, since both analytical theories ( Widrow et al. 2014 ; Banik et al. 2022 ; Banik et al. 2023 ) and N -body simulations ( Hunt et al. 2021 ) predicted that encounters with satellite galaxies will produce two-armed phase spirals in the outer disk rather than the inner disk 2 2 2 In the outer disk, satellites cross the disk on a timescale shorter than the stars’ orbital period. As a result, those approaching from above impart a net downward (upward) kick to stars near zenith (nadir), as the star-satellite distance is greater (smaller) before the encounter than after. This creates a quadrupole distortion in phase space, which evolves into a two-armed spiral. . To date, the two-armed phase spiral has been detected in various quantities, including the mean radial velocity ( Li et al. 2023 ) and the mean metallicity ( Alinder et al. 2024 ) , both of which are less affected by selection effects. Figure 1: The two-armed phase-spiral discovered in Gaia DR3. We select stars with parallax error p/\sigma_{p}>3 , magnitude G<15 , cylindrical distance from the sun d<1\,{\rm kpc} , angular momentum J_{\varphi}\in[1400,1600]\,{\rm kpc}^{2}\,{\rm Gyr}^{-1} , and azimuthal angle variable |\theta_{\varphi}-{\varphi_{\odot}}|<5{{}^{\circ}} . The angle variables are computed using the Milky Way potential from McMillan (2017) and the Stäckel fudge ( Binney 2012 ) as implemented in AGAMA ( Vasiliev 2019 ) . Top panel shows the full distribution, while the bottom panel shows the fractional density contrast relative to the smooth distribution obtained using a Gaussian filter with scale 80\,{\rm pc} in z and 6.4\,{\rm kpc}\,{\rm Gyr}^{-1} in v_{z} . Hunt et al. 2022 demonstrated using high-resolution N -body simulations that two-armed phase spirals can be generated in the inner disk by the disk’s internal perturbations, such as the galactic bar and spiral arms. More recently, Asano et al. 2025 confirmed their finding with an even higher-resolution simulation and proposed a scenario in which the two-armed phase spirals were created by spiral arms tidally induced by the impact of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy. These simulations demonstrate a clear causal link between the two-armed phase spiral and the internal disk perturbation. However, the underlying physical mechanism remains puzzling. While it has been known that bars and spiral arms induce breathing motions in the disk ( Debattista 2014 ; Faure et al. 2014 ; Monari et al. 2015 ; Monari et al. 2016 ; Khachaturyants et al. 2022 ; Asano et al. 2024 , e.g.,) , it is unclear how they could generate phase spirals, which specifically require a non-adiabatic perturbation to the disk, i.e., the timescale of the perturbation must be short compared to the vertical oscillation period – otherwise, the star’s vertical action would be conserved. Li et al. 2023 provide an example of a disk perturbed by a bar and a spiral arm which exhibits a breathing motion, but no phase spirals. Banik et al. 2022 ; Banik et al. 2023 conducted a linear analyses of the disk response to various perturbations and suggested that the formation of a two-armed phase spiral requires the internal perturber to rapidly grow and decay over a timescale comparable to the vertical oscillation period, which is as short as 70\,{\rm Myr} in the inner disk. This paper provides a theoretical explanation as to why two-armed phase spirals can form in the inner disk using a combination of linear analysis, nonlinear analysis, and test-particle simulations. The key ingredients are resonance and diffusion. It is well known that resonances can break the adiabaticity of the system even in a slowly varying potential [see Weinberg 1994 for a general discussion]. However, while resonant perturbations can temporarily generate