What quantum matter tells about quantisation of gravity in a statistical mechanics context
Pierre A Mandrin · 2025
Read What quantum matter tells about quantisation of gravity in a statistical mechanics context by Pierre A Mandrin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20837.txt.
Introduction
Mandrin proposes a guide for the long-sought quantum theory of gravity, drawn from quantum matter itself. His starting point is statistical mechanics, the physics of heat and chance. Space near a horizon behaves like a hot system, and quantum field theory's main tool, the path integral, can itself be read as statistical mechanics.
In this picture, gravity relates to matter much as a gas relates to its chemical potential. That link, Mandrin argues, pins down how gravity must be quantized once matter is: the recipe and even the number of quantum space dimensions follow from matter's side. He starts with small ripples around empty space, but claims the core features survive beyond that gentle case. The paper is a program for theory, not a finished model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pierre A Mandrin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20837
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What quantum matter tells about quantisation of gravity in a statistical mechanics context Pierre A Mandrin Abstract We propose a “guide” towards quantisation of gravity based on quantum matter in a statistical mechanics context. On one hand, a statistical mechanics model naturally arises from the thermodynamic interpretation of horizons in Rindler space. On the other hand, the path integral formulation of quantum field theory can be interpreted from the point of view of statistical mechanics. From these perspectives, gravity and matter are related to each other in the same way as a gas and its chemical potential are. This statistical mechanics interpretation of gravity and matter suggests that gravity should be quantised in a precise way which is determined by the quantisation of matter. Although, in a first step, quantisation of gravity applies for small perturbations of the metric with respect to the vacuum, the most central and general features of quantisation (quantisation prescription, quantum space dimensions) are supported from statistical mechanics and remain valid non-perturbatively. 1 Introduction There is, currently, a large uncertainty on how to treat gravity in a quantum mechanics context. Although it is mainly believed that gravity is required to be quantised, it is at least unclear which type of quantisation mechanism should be used, or which variables should be the preferred ones to start with. To a large part, this situation is certainly due to a lack of available experimental data which could give insight to near-Planck scale physics. Nevertheless, important hints should also be available from well-controlled knowledge of quantum matter. Indeed, the consequences are not obvious to investigate because we first need to understand the fundamental role of matter within the framework of gravity. By considering gravity via its statistical mechanics interpretation, matter acquires a new quality in the thermodynamic context, i.e. it acts in the same way as does the fugacity or the chemical potential in a grand canonical ensemble. The chemical potential interpretation of matter has already been proposed in [ 1 ] , but an important new development step is given by identifying the grand canonical ensemble which explicitly deals with open systems both with respect to “gravitational particles” and an “energy-like” extensive quantity which comes from the Lagrangian. With the grand canonical ensemble interpretation, the quantisation of gravity can first be obtained in the perturbative regime (linearised gravity). Due to the statistical mechanical context, important features of quantisation still survive in a non-perturbative concept, namely the path integral quantisation ansatz, the preferred canonical variables for quantisation and the space dimension 3 for gravitational quantum statistical mechanics. Despite the undeniable importance of these conceptual features, their role is not to constitute the full information for presenting a complete quantum theory of gravity. Rather, the importance of the this article relies in improving the confidence for how gravity is quantised. The concept of the statistical mechanics interpretation of the boundary term of gravity is introduced in Section 2 . It is based on an argument in [ 2 ] . The newer interpretation in this article has some different features; the main one is the open system property of a compact space region, thus providing to the total action the quality of a grand canonical potential. To lowest perturbation order, a matter field has the effect to linearly shift the gravitational field away from the classical vacuum solution. There is a subtile connection between matter and gravity: the radiated matter perceived by accelerated observers (Unruh effect) is nothing but the heat (matter particles) crossing the Rindler horizon [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . An equivalent process is the Hawking radiation produced in conjunction with black hole entropy [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . It is therefore natural to interpret the radiated matter as a thermodynamical manifestation of gravity, although this does not mean that gravity itself is specific to or can be identified with particular species of matter or their Hamiltonians. The open system concept and grand canonical ensemble view is introduced in Section 3 . In Section 4 , we conclude from Sections 2 and 3 how quantisation of gravity follows from quantisation of matter. The same type of canonical quantisation procedure as for flat space-time Quantum Field Theory (QFT) applies for linearised gravity, with the requirement that one of the canonical variables has to be the vielbein, and path integral quantisation applies in a similar way as for QFT, appart from the evolution aspect. The path integral concept for gravity and matter has a one-to-one correspondence with the statistical mechanics formulation of gravity, i.e. it is not bound to a perturbative treatment, and the vielbeins therefore must keep their role of canonical functional variable for the non-perturbative quantisation procedure. The matter part in the path integral corresponds to the term containing the chemical potential \mu in the exponent of the grand canonical partition function of a gas. From Section 2 , the general form of quantisation of gravity must have its most natural formulation in 3d-space since this is the dimension of the Rindler horizon hypersurfaces which the initial microcanonical ensemble treatment is originating from. This dimension is automatically recovered in the path integral treatment when the “external time evolution” problem is removed. The reduced dimension 3 indeed corresponds to the requirement for a unitary quantum gravity theory [ 9 ] . 2 Summary of the statistical mechanical interpretation of gravity We first shortly review the required parts from [ 2 ] and references therein and strengthen the required chain of argumentation as well as the physical picture of the statistical mechanical interpretation of space-time. As is well-known from [ 4 , 5 ] , space-time has a thermodynamical interpretation. Any spatial 2-surface on any 3-dimensional null-hypersurface is perceived as a Rindler horizon by a suitably located, uniformly accelerated observer, with an associated temperature T=\kappa/(2\pi) ( \kappa is the accelleration of the observer or Rindler surface gravity) and an entropy S_{hor}=A/(4L_{p}^{2}) related to a surface area A , where L_{p} is the Planck length, and the horizon of the Rindler wedge is equivalent to a black hole horizon. It should be stressed that the unboosted original space with coordinates ( t,x,y,z ) does not need to be flat, it may, in general, have a non-singular metric g_{\alpha\beta}\neq 0,\pm\infty . By the generalised terminology “Rindler space”, we therefore mean the boosted space defined by the coordinates ( T,X,y,z ), t=X\sinh T,\qquad x=X\cosh T. (1) According to [ 10 , 5 ] , a 3-dimensional null-hypersurface in Einstein gravity contributes a surface action \mathcal{A}_{sur} (which corresponds in part to the boundary term), and \mathcal{A}_{sur} is interpreted as the time integrated “heat” \int dt\ Q=\int dt\ TS when evaluated on the Rindler horizon (taking care of the order of evaluation steps for taking the null limit). We have: \mathcal{A}_{sur}=\frac{c^{4}}{16\pi G}\int N^{c}_{ab}\ f^{ab}\ d^{3}\Sigma_{c},\qquad f^{ab}=\sqrt{-g}\ g^{ab},\qquad N^{c}_{ab}\ d^{3}\Sigma_{c}=N^{ab}\ d^{3}x, (2) where, in the notation of [ 5 ] , f^{ab} is the entropy density, N^{c}_{ab} is its conjugate momentum, and d^{3}\Sigma_{c} is the 3-surface element covector. On the right hand side of ( 2 ), N_{ab}=K_{ab}-K^{c}_{c}\gamma_{ab} and K_{ab} is the second fundamental form [ 11 , 12 ] . The interpretation of ( 2 ) and of the elaborations