Measuring work in quantum many-body systems using a dynamical “work agent”
Cheolhee Han, Nadav Katz, Eran Sela · 2025
Read Measuring work in quantum many-body systems using a dynamical “work agent” by Cheolhee Han, Nadav Katz, Eran Sela (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20729.txt.
Introduction
Cheolhee Han, Nadav Katz, and Eran Sela propose a way to measure work in quantum many-body systems in a paper from 2025. Work done on a driven quantum system is a basic quantity in quantum thermodynamics. Standard schemes need full control of the system's energy levels. That control fails for large, many-body systems.
Their trick turns the driving knob into a physical agent: a harmonic oscillator in a bright coherent state. The agent absorbs the bookkeeping of the drive. In the bright limit, its readings match the standard two-point measurement protocol. Average work then follows from energy conservation alone. The scheme opens work measurement to systems far beyond a few levels. Quantum engines could finally be metered.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cheolhee Han, Nadav Katz, Eran Sela |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20729
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Measuring work in quantum many-body systems using a dynamical “work agent” Cheolhee Han, Nadav Katz, Eran Sela Abstract We consider a generic quantum many-body system initiated at thermal equilibrium and driven by an external parameter, and discuss the prospect for measuring the work done by the varying parameter on the system. While existing methods are based on a full control of the system’s Hamiltonian and are thus limited to few-level quantum systems, measuring work in many-body quantum systems remains challenging. Our approach relies on transforming the external parameter into a dynamical “work agent”, for which we consider an harmonic oscillator in a semiclassical coherent state with a large photon number. We define a work generating function which coincides with the standard two-point measurement protocol for work measurement in the limit of a large photon number. While in principle it allows to relate the moments of work ⟨ W n ⟩ \langle W^{n}\rangle to observables of the work agent, we focus on the average work, which is obtained from energy conservation by the change of the energy of the agent, which can be measured using photon number detection. We illustrate this concept on a transmon-microcavity system, which displays various quantum coherent effects including Landau-Zener Stükelberg interference and collapse and revival of Rabi oscillations. We discuss how our setup allows to measure work in a variety of quantum many-body systems. I Introduction Work and its statistics have been identified as a promising observable of quantum many body systems driven out of equilibrium. General theoretical studies explored work statistics in quantum many body systems all the way from the adiabatic limit of slow driving [ 1 , 2 ] to the quenched limit [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] and near quantum phase transitions [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . However, measurements of work statistics remain elusive in quantum systems with many degrees of freedom. To be concrete, we consider a quantum many-body system described by a Hamiltonian H_{ext}(X(t)) controlled by an external time dependent parameter X(t) , and we are interested in measuring the work done by X(t) on the system, where the system is initially at thermal equilibrium. The challenge we propose to overcome is to allow for work measurements based on the two-point measurement (TPM) protocol [ 12 ] , involving two projective measurements of the energy of the system. Although this definition does not capture coherence of energy eigenstates in the initial state, here we are concerned with an initial thermal state. In this case, the TPM scheme still captures coherence generated during the process. The associated work distribution function (WDF) satisfies non-equilibrium fluctuation theorems [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . Let us first clarify the inadequacy of a direct application of existing methods for the many-body case. Some of the first measurements of the WDF in the quantum case have been formulated using an ancilla qubit [ 17 , 18 ] and demonstrated experimentally using nuclear magnetic resonance [ 19 ] ; Soon after, the TPM was formulated as a single positive operator-valued measurement which can be realized by extending the system using an ancilla coordinate [ 20 ] acting as a “work meter”, see also [ 21 ] , which is entangled with the system via a quantum operation conditioned by the system’s Hamiltonian, before being measured. This protocol had been realized using cold atoms [ 22 ] , and similar approaches had been applied in a variety of quantum systems including nitrogen-vacancy centers [ 23 ] , trapped ions [ 24 ] , and quantum optics [ 25 , 26 ] , to name a few. This allowed to measure the WDF and verify fluctuation theorems in the quantum case, however all of these systems are essentially few-level systems. In a many-body quantum system with many interacting degrees of freedom, it seems hopeless to run the protocols of Refs. [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] and directly entangle the many-body system’s Hamiltonian with a simple ancillary degree of freedom. Thus, practically these methods are not directly applicable in many-body systems. As explained in Sec. II , our approach is as follows. Our target is a many-body Hamiltonian H_{ext}(X(t)) controlled by an external time dependent parameter X(t) . We replace the external parameter X(t) by a dynamical degree of freedom described by an operator \hat{X} . Its Hamiltonian and its initial condition are selected to reproduce X(t) in average with as small fluctuations as possible. For example, a quantum oscillator corresponds to a sinusoidal time dependent parameter, and the small fluctuation limit is achieved using a semiclassical coherent state. The combined system and “parameter” evolve under a time-independent Hamiltonian H_{tot} . Therefore the sum of the average energy of the oscillator alone, and of the rest of the Hamiltonian H(\hat{X}) , which includes the system and its interaction with the oscillator, are constant in time. Using energy conservation, our elementary statement is that by initiating the oscillator in a semi-classical coherent state with a large number of photons, the average work as defined by the TPM scheme can be measured via the change of the energy stored in the oscillator. The idea of treating the work agent dynamically and autonomously is fundamental in quantum thermodynamics and goes beyond the need to measure the WDF. In earlier works, to mention a few, it was referred to as a “weight system” [ 27 , 28 ] having just a gravitational potential and interacting via unitary evolution with the system. Many other works consider the work agent as an harmonic oscillator. In a quantum heat engine this oscillator can be used to alternate the coupling of a system between hot and cold heat reservoirs [ 29 ] , again within a fully unitary description with a time-independent Hamiltonian. This oscillator was referred to as a “quantum flywheel” [ 30 , 31 ] and experimentally realized [ 32 ] . The resonator can also serve as a “quantum battery” [ 33 , 34 ] . Since this oscillator evolves with the system in an autonomous way, measurement of its energy fluctuations acts as an embedded quantum work meter [ 35 ] , as realized experimentally with a superconducting qubit coupled to a resonator [ 36 ] . Based on Ref. [ 37 ] , we recently explored the possibility to use the work agent approach to verify the JE [ 38 ] . With the motivation of using the work agent approach to measure the WDF in complicated quantum many-body systems, our key technical advancement described in Sec. II is to formulate a generating function which coincides with that of the TPM scheme (corresponding to an external time-dependent parameter) in the classical limit of infinite number of photons in the coherent state. This generating function allows in principle to measure any desired moment of the WDF by inspecting solely the single-coordinate work agent. Adhering to what is practically measured in experiment, the first moment, i.e. the average work, is nothing but (minus) the change in the number number of photons in the oscillator times \hbar\omega , with \omega the oscillator frequency. The main purpose of this work,