Large Structural VARs with Multiple Sign and Ranking Restrictions

Joshua C. C. Chan, Christian Matthes, Xuewen Yu · 2025

Read Large Structural VARs with Multiple Sign and Ranking Restrictions by Joshua C. C. Chan, Christian Matthes, Xuewen Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20668.txt.

Introduction

Chan, Matthes, and Yu build tools for large economic models with many shocks in a 2025 paper. Vector autoregression models track many series at once and are a workhorse of macroeconomics. To read them structurally, researchers pin down shocks with sign and ranking rules on the responses. With dozens of variables and over a hundred rules, existing algorithms break down.

The authors offer a fast algorithm that estimates responses and related measures under many restrictions at once. They show it on a 35-variable model with more than one hundred sign and ranking restrictions. Eight structural shocks are identified in that single run. The method opens large models to the rich restriction sets that modern policy questions demand.

Catalog record

CREATORJoshua C. C. Chan, Christian Matthes, Xuewen Yu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20668

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Large Structural VARs with Multiple Sign and Ranking Restrictions Joshua C. C. Chan, Christian Matthes, Xuewen Yu Abstract Large VARs are increasingly used in structural analysis as a unified framework to study the impacts of multiple structural shocks simultaneously. However, the concurrent identification of multiple shocks using sign and ranking restrictions poses significant practical challenges to the point where existing algorithms cannot be used with such large VARs. To address this, we introduce a new numerically efficient algorithm that facilitates the estimation of impulse responses and related measures in large structural VARs identified with a large number of structural restrictions on impulse responses. The methodology is illustrated using a 35-variable VAR with over 100 sign and ranking restrictions to identify 8 structural shocks. Keywords: large vector autoregression, sign restriction, ranking restriction, shrinkage prior JEL classifications: C11, C55, E50 1 Introduction Vector autoregressions (VARs) are a workhorse model in macroeconomic forecasting and structural analysis. Among the many methodological advances in the structural VAR (SVAR) literature since the pioneering work by Sims (1980) , two recent developments are the most prominent. First, there is a growing recognition of the need to exploit more information in structural analyses, motivated by the concern that informational deficiency (using an information set that is too small relative to that of economic agents) substantially distorts estimates of impulse responses and related objects ( Hansen and Sargent, 1991 ; Lippi and Reichlin, 1993 ; Lippi and Reichlin, 1994 ) . Starting from the seminal paper by Leeper, Sims, and Zha (1996) that develops various medium-sized structural VARs to study the effects of monetary policy, large VARs with dozens of endogenous variables are increasingly being used in applications. This trend gained momentum after the influential work by Bańbura, Giannone, and Reichlin (2010) , who demonstrate the benefits of including a large number of variables for both forecasting and structural analysis. Notable applications using large VARs include Carriero, Kapetanios, and Marcellino (2009) , Koop (2013) , Ellahie and Ricco (2017) and Crump, Eusepi, Giannone, Qian, and Sbordone (2021) . The second development relates to the methods for identifying structural shocks. More specifically, there has been a gradual departure from conventional recursive or zero restrictions to alternative structural restrictions that are deemed to be more credible. An important class of identifying restrictions imposes sign restrictions motivated by economic theory, developed in a series of papers by Faust (1998) , Canova and Nicolo (2002) and Uhlig (2005) . Extensions of this identification approach, such as ranking restrictions proposed in Amir-Ahmadi and Drautzburg (2021) , are also widely used in empirical work. The convergence of these two developments naturally requires the estimation of large structural VARs identified by imposing sign and ranking restrictions on the impulse responses. However, this remains practically infeasible in high-dimensional settings. For instance, using the popular accept-reject algorithm of Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) to impose sign restrictions might take days in larger-scale applications. Thus, this computational burden severely limits the use of these more credible restrictions in large systems. We develop a new approach to estimate large SVARs identified using a large number of structural restrictions on impulse responses, which was until now computationally infeasible. In particular, it is applicable to situations where there are far more structural restrictions than identified shocks. The new algorithm builds upon the accept-reject algorithm of Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) , which we now briefly describe to provide some perspective. First, given a uniformly drawn orthogonal matrix (i.e., a matrix drawn according to the Haar measure), Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) check if the implied impulse responses satisfy all restrictions. If all the restrictions are satisfied (the draw is admissible), accept the draw and the implied impulse responses; otherwise, obtain another uniform draw and repeat the procedure. The main computational bottleneck of this algorithm comes from the fact that in high-dimensional settings with a large number of structural restrictions, it is highly unlikely that any orthogonal matrix drawn uniformly is admissible. Consequently, one typically needs to sample a huge number of orthogonal matrices to obtain one that is admissible. The key idea of our proposed algorithm comes from the recognition that, given a uniformly distributed orthogonal matrix, a vast collection of uniform draws can be constructed by permuting its columns and switching the signs of the columns. 1 1 1 Since the Haar measure is invariant under permutations and sign switches, any member of this collection is also uniformly distributed in the orthogonal group. More importantly, all these obtained orthogonal matrices are equivalent, in the sense that they represent exactly the same structural shocks of the original orthogonal matrix, after relabeling the shocks and proper sign normalizations. Additionally, one can effectively search through this collection to locate any members that satisfy all structural restrictions with trivial computations. In this way, the new algorithm significantly increases the probability of obtaining an admissible draw with virtually no additional costs. In our benchmark setting, we impose that any identification restriction is only imposed on impact to allow for fast checking of identification restrictions. Economic theory generally only produces robust restrictions across theoretical models only on impact, giving a justification for this approach. However, we also discuss how to extend our approach to sign restrictions at longer horizons as well as ranking restrictions along the lines of Graeve and Karas (2014) and Amir-Ahmadi and Drautzburg (2021) . To illustrate our proposed algorithm, we consider four applications, three empirical applications based on US data and one set of Monte Carlo simulations. First, we estimate a 15-variable VAR with more than 40 sign and ranking restrictions to identify 5 structural shocks based on empirical applications in Furlanetto, Ravazzolo, and Sarferaz (2019) and Chan (2022) . As a benchmark, we use the algorithm of Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) to uniformly draw orthogonal matrices from the admissible set and compute implied impulse responses. It takes about 3.6 billion orthogonal matrices to obtain 1,000 admissible draws, and the estimation takes about 6 days on a standard desktop. In contrast, the new algorithm requires only about 31,000 orthogonal matrices to obtain 1,000 admissible draws, and the entire exercise takes about 16 seconds. We also confirm empirically that both algorithms give identical impulse responses. Second, we demonstrate how the proposed algorithm can be applied in settings with dynamic sign restrictions by replicating the classic application in Uhlig (2005) . We compare the proposed algorithm to those of Rubio-Ramirez, Waggoner, and Zha (2010) and Read (2022) , and show that while the three algorithms produce the same impulse responses, the proposed algorithm is substantially faster. Third, we conduct a series of Monte Carlo simulations to illustrate the empirical performance of the proposed method, and show that it works well even in settings with large numbers of variables and structural shocks. Our third empirical application considers a larger 35-variable VAR with over 100 sign and ranking restrictions to identify 8 structural shocks: demand, investment, financial, monetary policy, government spending, technology, labor supply and wage bargaining. These macroeconomic and financial variables are broadly similar to those of Crump, Eusepi, Giannone, Qian, and Sbordone (2021) and are closely monitored by policy institutions and market participants. Our high-dimensional model provides a unified framework to study the impacts

Read the complete text