Mathematical Models for Self-Adaptive Response to Cancer Dynamics

Christian Kuehn · 2025

Read Mathematical Models for Self-Adaptive Response to Cancer Dynamics by Christian Kuehn (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20632.txt.

Introduction

Christian Kuehn models, in a 2025 math paper, the race between fast cancer growth and the body's power to adapt its defense, a balance that immune therapy tries to tip. Two deliberately simple models capture that contest. The aim is insight into when outside help can let self-defense win, not a full picture of any one cancer.

The first model, a set of four linked equations, has three regimes set by the level of outside push. A mid-level push can leave only a cancer-free steady state, but a dangerous spike in cancer often comes first. A second, random micro-level model shows a sharp tipping point. Memory plus rare lucky adaptation events move that point to where therapy wants it.

Catalog record

CREATORChristian Kuehn
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20632

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mathematical Models for Self-Adaptive Response to Cancer Dynamics Christian Kuehn Abstract We consider two minimal mathematical models for cancer dynamics and self-adaptation. We aim to capture the interplay between the rapid progression of cancer growth and the possibility to leverage and enhance self-adaptive defense mechanisms of an organism, e.g., motivated by immunotherapy. Yet, our two models are more abstract and generic encapsulating the essence of competition between rapid cancer growth and the speed of adaptation. First, we propose a four-dimensional ordinary differential equation model on a macroscopic level. The model has three main parameter regimes and its most important features can be studied analytically. At small external stimulation of adaptation, cancer progresses to a deadly level. At intermediate external input, a bifurcation is observed leaving behind only a locally stable cancer-free steady state. Unfortunately, in a large parameter regime after the bifurcation, a transient cancer density spike is observed. Only for a combination of external input and speeding up adaptation, cancer does not reach critical levels. To study the adaptation speed-up in the initial dynamics phase, we switch to a microscopic probabilistic model, which we study numerically. The microscopic model undergoes a sharp transition under variation of the self-adaptation probability. It is shown that a combination of temporal memory and rare stochastic positive adaptation events is crucial to move the sharp transition point to a desired regime. Despite their extreme simplicity, the two models already provide remarkably deep insight into the challenges one has to overcome to leverage/enhance the self-adaptation of an organism in fighting cancer. 1 Introduction On the one hand, cancer is a highly multi-faceted disease [ 22 , 36 , 48 ] . There are many causes, different forms, and progressions [ 5 , 21 ] . On the other hand, all cancers follow similar macroscopic principles, i.e., the main disease mechanism is simply based around uncontrolled cell division [ 52 ] . Regarding potential therapies, there is an analogous situation [ 46 ] . For different cancer types, the currently most successful therapies often require specific treatment [ 44 ] , or even combinations of different methods [ 51 ] . Yet, trying to contain the basic mechanism of uncontrolled cell division is the common principle among many therapies such as chemotherapy [ 6 ] , radiation therapy [ 3 ] or immunotherapy [ 37 ] . In this work, we are interested in developing simple multiscale mathematical models to understand, whether it would be possible to design more generic therapies for cancer treatment. We shall point out immediately that this approach should be viewed as a basic research question that cannot be practically relevant already at this early stage. The main idea is to turn the common view of cancer dynamics completely around. Instead of understanding very precise, sometimes even molecular, details, we simply accept that any organism is a highly complex system and cancer is a systemic disease. It is impossible to model all the details of an organism to a sufficiently detailed systemic level. The key thought is to turn an intractable complex system into an advantage. Indeed, organisms are complex systems with highly adaptive capabilities. Not only can humans adapt their knowledge and skills by learning [ 18 ] but also the immune system [ 13 ] , hormone regulation [ 10 ] , as well as many other functions of a complex organism only work because they are adaptable to a range of possible situations [ 20 ] . As a basic assumption, we could then postulate that an untreated cancer progresses too fast and thereby evades our adaptive capabilities. Nevertheless, one may ask, whether it is possible to leverage and enhance adaptive capabilities more efficiently. For example, this route is emphasized in immunotherapy [ 7 , 12 , 15 , 37 ] . In fact, the adaptive capabilities of the immune system have been recognized in the context of cancer dynamics [ 16 , 33 ] . Furthermore, it is clear that adaptive effects of cells also play a key role in cancer cells being able to evade immunotheraphy [ 7 , 12 , 15 , 37 ] . In the context of immunotherapy, a quite significant controlled intervention is necessary, e.g., to extract, prepare, and grow T-cells in a laboratory setting. One may hence ask, whether a fully adaptive approach is possible for certain therapy concepts, i.e., to just present the body with a sufficient input that shares partial features with cancer cells but which can already be regulated/cured in an adaptive feedback loop. As a concrete example, consider again the immune system, which certainly can fight already a wide range of diseases. As long as it got presented a diverse enough set of features of cancers within harmless diseases, one could make the assumption that it eventually will learn, how to also fight the cancer itself and also learn how to avoid cancer cell evasion to immune system attacks. Of course, this assumption is not restricted to the immune system but should apply to train other regulatory organism components relevant for cancer progression. One may wonder, why it could be beneficial to also consider cancer models with less details, even if more detailed knowledge is available. In many scientific disciplines, a reductionist abstract approach has moved our understanding significantly forward. As a biological example, consider reduced neuron models just representing the basic excitability properties of neurons [ 11 ] . A similar remark applies to a variety of biological (phase) oscillator models for synchronization or swarming [ 30 , 50 ] . Epidemiology does often not require sophisticated models but standard SIS- and SIR-models provide a remarkably accurate description of qualitative dynamics of epidemic spreading [ 26 ] . The list could be continued to many other disciplines. Here we shall suggest the viewpoint that more abstract models of cancer dynamics could be extremely useful as well since the basic principles are more visible, and hence also more easy to understand, or even to exploit. In this work, we propose two abstract models to describe cancer dynamics. First, we are interested in the macroscopic view of adaptivity. We are going to consider an ordinary differential equation (ODE) model [ 40 , 39 ] of just four variables: (I) an input variable r providing a reservoir of cells that share some feature with cancer cells but are essentially harmless, (II) a variable i of body components (e.g. immune cells) that can remove the input r to progress via adaptation to more efficient components, (III) a variable s of components that arise due to adaptation of i but so that cancer cells can be attacked (e.g. “super-immune” cells), and (IV) the density/proportion of cancer cells c . The main results from the analysis of this macroscopic density-based model are: (R1) Due to the large cell division rate inherent in cancer cells, the first commonly observed behavior is cancer progression and ensuing death if the density of cancer cells reaches a certain threshold. For large parameter regimes, there is even a steady state with a large/deadly proportion of cancer cells in the model. The vicinity of this steady state gets reached from large regions of initial data. As such, the model

Read the complete text