Reproducibility of Large Eddy Simulations for mixing in stirred tank reactors Journal: ArXiv

Cees Haringa, Ryan Rautenbach, Héctor Maldonado de León, Pieter Brorens, Michael Schlüter · 2025

Read Reproducibility of Large Eddy Simulations for mixing in stirred tank reactors Journal: ArXiv by Cees Haringa, Ryan Rautenbach, Héctor Maldonado de León, Pieter Brorens, Michael Schlüter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20622.txt.

Introduction

Cees Haringa and co-authors published this study in 2025. It tests whether big turbulence simulations of stirred tanks give the same answer twice. Such simulations guide mixing design in chemical and biotech plants. In theory they are exact and repeatable. In practice, tiny rounding errors grow in the swirling flow, and parallel computers add their own shuffling. Repeat runs can drift apart.

The team ran repeat simulations of a thirty-liter stirred vessel in two commercial codes. Mixing times spread across runs, even on the same machine setup. The spread matched well with what real experiments show. The physics, in other words, is right; the exact path is chaotic. The authors advise reporting confidence ranges for such simulations, as one would for lab data.

Catalog record

CREATORCees Haringa, Ryan Rautenbach, Héctor Maldonado de León, Pieter Brorens, Michael Schlüter
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20622

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reproducibility of Large Eddy Simulations for mixing in stirred tank reactors Journal: ArXiv Cees Haringa, Ryan Rautenbach, Héctor Maldonado de León, Pieter Brorens, Michael Schlüter Abstract CFD simulations are widely used to quantify mixing performance of stirred tanks, for various applications in chemical engineering and biotechnology. Due to advances in GPU computing, more and more often these simulations make use of Large Eddy Simulations (LES), which explicitly simulate the dynamics of large-scale turbulence. Although these simulations are fully deterministic and hence theoretically reproducible, small numerical variations induced by round-off errors combined with differences in distribution and order of operations in parallel computing lead to separation of trajectories, i.e. different flowfield evolutions and different mixing times between repeat simulations, even on the same architecture. We investigate the impact of repeat simulations on the mixing time distribution observed in a 30 30 stirred vessel with two commercial CFD packages, and compare to experimental variability. While the distribution between simulations and experiments is in very good agreement, we do conclude confidence intervals should be reported for CFD simulations of mixing. 1 Introduction Mixing is a common operation in many industrial operations, and as such has been thoroughly researched over many decades, both experimentally [ 1 , 2 ] and numerically [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Many methods have been developed to experimentally quantify mixing, from invasive probe-based (single-point) approaches to detailed spatial methods based on pH indicators [ 6 ] . This makes it impossible to assign a single mixing time to a system, as both the means of measurement and the mixing criterion (e.g. 90 or 95 \% homogenization) vary; furthermore, prior work has shown that even mimicking identical setups between different facilities may lead to variability in the order of 15 \% [ 7 ] . What is not surprising, however, is that a mixing time distribution is practically observed in turbulent stirred vessels (single phase); measurement errors aside, turbulent mixing is a stochastic process, that may additionally be impacted by macro-instabilities that can lead to strong mixing time variations [ 8 ] . Still, many experimental studies regularly report a single mixing time, or an average over multiple repeats without confidence interval (e.g. [ 9 , 10 ] , although insight in the variability in mixing times is a relevant characteristic. CFD simulations, on the other hand, are fully deterministic numerical simulations and should in principle yield a single, repeatable mixing time. This is certainly true for the Reynolds Averaged Navier Stokes (RANS) simulations which are commonly used to assess mixing behavior, and under the assumption of negligible rotor-stator interaction and macro-instability effects, can even be operated in steady-state [ 11 ] . But also for dynamic methods, including Large Eddy Simulations (LES) which do resolve the larger scales of the turbulent spectrum explicitly, their deterministic nature should lead to reproducibility. In practice, we did not observe this reproducibility for LES, though. Rerunning the same simulation yields a different mixing time, leading to two questions: 1. What is the origin of non-deterministic behavior in LES-mixing simulations? 2. How does the non-deterministic behavior compare to experimental mixing time distributions? We conducted an initial experimental assessment combined with repeated mixing studies in two commercial CFD codes; through this short communication we share our initial observations, and want to invite the CFD community to further contribute to expanding this study. 2 Origin of variability in LES simulations Large Eddy Simulations, as any numerical simulation, are strictly deterministic. This means that if the same calculations are performed in the same manner, they should yield the same outcome. However, in practice executing simulations in exactly the same way is challenging, especially when employing parallel computing – which is essential to keep LES computationally tractable. When the order of calculations is slightly changed, this will lead to slightly different round-off of floating-point numbers, and as shown by Senoner et al. [ 12 ] this will inevitably lead to ‘separation of trajectories’ in LES simulations, similar to what is observed in direct numerical simulation (DNS): after some time, exponential growth of the initial numerical round-off error leads to completely different instantaneous realizations of the flowfield. This effect could be delayed by using higher numerical precision, but eventually the same separation is observed, with the rate determined by the physical response of the system rather than numerical considerations. This distinguishes LES and DNS from RANS and laminar flow situations, where (numerical) perturbations are quenched by the diffusivity of the system. Senoner et al. do note that indeed, if the exact same simulation is conducted on the exact same system with the exact same order of calculations, LES will be fully deterministic. However, as most parallelization algorithms are based on flexible message passing, this will hardly ever be observed in practice. And even then: considering the stochastic nature of turbulence, we should wonder whether a fully determined LES simulation is truly representative of the real mixing behavior, or if it presents a particular unlikely representation of the possible realizations. 2.1 Quantifying variability: methodology With the notion that LES results will inevitably be variable in practical context, we set out to quantify this variability in comparison with experimental data. Whilst more advanced experimental methods are available, we opted here for an often-used method for mixing quantification, determination of \tau_{95} using a single-point conductivity measurement. We opted for this method due to (1) frequency of use, (2) ease of data processing and (3) rapid response of the conductivity probe, which in combination with an expected mixing time of ca. 25 in a 30 bioreactor should lead to minor measurement error. Figure 1: Geometry used in the current study 2.2 Experimental setup We conducted 11 repeats of a mixing experiment in a 30 bioreactor with the geometry reported in figure 1 , running at 200 RPM. The mixing time was determined based on 95\% homogenization using two WTW - IDS TetraCon ® 925 conductivity probes, with a response time of 1 . The probe locations and injection location are outlined in table 1 . Table 1: Location of the probes and tracer injection location used in the simulations and experiment. Feature x [m] y [m] z [m] Probe 1 0.1270 0.4324 0.0180 Probe 2 0.1270 0.4324 0.1180 Injection 0 0.4658 0.1164 2.3 Numerical setup Large Eddy Simulations were conducted using the commercial CFD packages M-Star CFD 3.12.21 and ANSYS Fluent 2024R1, which use the lattice Boltzmann (LB) and finite volume (FV) approach, respectively. In both cases the Smagorinsky subgrid model was used, with C_{S}=0.1 . Due to time constraints, a mesh dependency study was not conducted in either software at this stage, as prior studies indicate mixing time determinations to be reasonably independent for this mesh resolution [ 13 ] . M-Star Setup: A standard D3Q19 lattice is employed with the Bhatnagar-Gross-Krook (BGK) relaxation method [ 14 ] , with explicit time integration and a courant number of Co = 0.1. A grid spacing of 0.95 mm per point was used, yielding 90 million lattice points. A single simulation was set up with 10 different tracers, injected with a 1 second time starting at t = 25s, the first 25 seconds allows for the flowfield to establish. The simulation

Read the complete text