Relative portfolio optimization via a value at risk based constraint
Nicole Bäuerle ∗, Tamara Göll · 2025
Read Relative portfolio optimization via a value at risk based constraint by Nicole Bäuerle ∗, Tamara Göll (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20340.txt.
Introduction
Investors who judge themselves against rivals face a game, not just a lone choice. Nicole Bäuerle and Tamara Göll study that game in a 2025 paper. Each investor wants high expected gain while keeping a set chance of ending richer than the benchmark set by rivals. The market they model is complete and free of arbitrage. Each person's best move depends on what the others do.
For two investors with one common utility type, the authors find all stable outcomes stated in final wealth. For more investors with a simpler utility, they split the problem by how strict the chance rule is. Loose rules let them list all stable outcomes, while strict rules need a narrower search. Number examples show how rivalry changes the chosen portfolios.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicole Bäuerle ∗, Tamara Göll |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 77 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20340
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Relative portfolio optimization via a value at risk based constraint Nicole Bäuerle ∗, Tamara Göll Abstract . In this paper, we consider n n agents who invest in a general financial market that is free of arbitrage and complete. The aim of each investor is to maximize her expected utility while ensuring, with a specified probability, that her terminal wealth exceeds a benchmark defined by her competitors’ performance. This setup introduces an interdependence between agents, leading to a search for Nash equilibria. In the case of two agents and CRRA utility, we are able to derive all Nash equilibria in terms of terminal wealth. For n > 2 n>2 agents and logarithmic utility we distinguish two cases. In the first case, the probabilities in the constraint are small and we can characterize all Nash equilibria. In the second case, the probabilities are larger and we look for Nash equilibria in a certain set. We also discuss the impact of the competition using some numerical examples. As a by-product, we solve some portfolio optimization problems with probability constraints. ∗ Corresponding author Key words : Nash equilibrium; competitive investment; Value at risk; CRRA utility Statements and Declarations: The authors have no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose. Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study. 1. Introduction In standard asset allocation problems, a single agent typically invests in a financial market to optimize an objective, such as expected utility or mean-variance. In reality, however, investors are rarely isolated; they are often influenced by their relative performance compared to others. In this paper, we examine a scenario with n agents investing in a shared financial market, where each agent aims to maximize her expected utility while ensuring, with a specified probability, that her terminal wealth exceeds a benchmark defined by her competitors’ performance. For instance, an agent might require that, with 90\% probability, her final wealth surpasses the average wealth of her competitors. This setup introduces a strategic layer to the optimization problem, where agents’ objectives are interdependent, leading to a search for Nash equilibria under probabilistic constraints. Consequently, our framework integrates strategic interactions among agents with value-at-risk constraints. Before we have a closer look at our results, let us mention the related literature. There have been a number of papers recently which consider strategic interactions between agents in asset allocation problems. The motivation stems from Brown et al., (2001) and Kempf and Ruenzi, (2008) . The majority of papers model the interaction by maximizing the expected utility of relative wealth in financial markets of Black Scholes type. Relative wealth may be measured by a linear function of the terminal wealths of all agents, see e.g. Espinosa and Touzi, (2015) and Espinosa, (2010) , or by a multiplicative function of the terminal wealths, see e.g. Basak and Makarov, (2014) . More precisely, this means that X_{T}^{i,\pi^{i}}-\frac{\theta_{i}}{n-1}\sum_{j\neq i}X_{T}^{j,\pi^{j}} or X_{T}^{i,\pi^{i}}\big(\sum_{j\neq i}X_{T}^{j,\pi^{j}}\big)^{-\frac{\theta_{i}}{n-1}} enter the utility function of agent i where X_{T}^{i,\pi^{i}} is the wealth of agent i at the terminal time T . For example, Basak and Makarov, (2015) consider two agents investing in a Black Scholes model and maximizing the power utility of the ratio of both wealths. The difference between own wealth and arithmetic mean of other agents’ wealth has been treated in Espinosa and Touzi, (2015) . Lacker and Zariphopoulou, (2019) investigate a model where each agent has her own financial market and consider the corresponding mean-field approach. This work has later been extended to investment-consumption in Lacker and Soret, (2020) . Fu and Zhou, (2023) and Fu, (2023) provide a relation between Nash equilibria and systems of forward backward stochastic differential equations for agents with power utility and multiplicative relative performance for investment and consumption. Forward utilities with competition are for example considered in Musiela and Zariphopoulou, (2006) , Dos Reis and Platonov, (2021) and Anthropelos et al., (2022) . Models with more general financial market have been treated in Bäuerle and Göll, (2023) , Kraft et al., (2020) , Hu and Zariphopoulou, (2022) , Aydoğan and Steffensen, (2024) . Papers which model in addition price impacts of the investors are Bäuerle and Göll, (2024) and Curatola, (2024) . On the other hand, there is a stream of literature considering benchmark and value-at-risk constraints for one agent problems. For example Basak and Shapiro, (2001) maximize expected utility under the constraint that, with a certain probability, the terminal wealth is above a given deterministic threshold. This is equivalent to requiring that the value-at-risk at the terminal time of the wealth is below a threshold. Gabih et al., (2005) ; Gabih et al., (2009) ; Gabih et al., (2006) consider a similar point of view replacing the value-at-risk by expected shortfall and Sass and Wunderlich, (2010) and Bäuerle and Chen, (2023) extend this situation to problems with partial information. But in these models there is only a single agent and no competition involved. In our model, we combine these two aspects. We consider n agents who invest into the same financial market. We do not need a specific model for this market. It should be free of arbitrage and complete. The agents aim at maximizing their expected utility at terminal time T . Most of the paper is on logarithmic utility, but we also consider power utility. As a constraint, the probability that one’s wealth exceeds a linear combination of the other agents’ wealth is bounded from below. Thus, we adapt the model of Basak and Shapiro, (2001) to include relative concerns by replacing the constant solvency level in the optimization problem of agent i by a weighted arithmetic mean of the other n-1 agents’ terminal wealth. The motivation for such a model is threefold: First there is a psychological argument for private investors. Whether or not a return feels like a gain or loss is often relative to how other investors (friends, colleagues) performed or how the general stock market performed. This has for example been implemented in the cumulative prospect theory of Tversky and Kahneman, (1992) by introducing a reference point. Thus, investors try to beat such reference points. Second, fund managers often receive a part of their bonuses for outperforming other funds or benchmarks, see e.g. Browne, (1999) . Thus, part of their attention is dedicated to outperform these benchmarks with at least a certain probability. Third, this can equivalently be considered as a portfolio optimization problem with a stochastic value-at-risk constraint, i.e. a value-at-risk constraint where the risk level is stochastic. Bell and Cover, (1980) consider a simple static two-person zero sum game where the payoff is the probability of beating the opponent’s outcome. There are also links to what is known as Colonel Blotto games, see Kovenock and Roberson, (2021) . We incorporate the constraint \mathbb{P}\Big(X_{i}\geq\sum_{j\neq i}\beta_{{\color[rgb]{0,0,0}ij}}X_{j}\Big)\geq\alpha_{i} (1.1) into the optimization problem of agent i , where \alpha_{i}\in[0,1] and \beta_{ij}\in[0,1] for all i,j\in\{1,\ldots,n\} . By X_{j} we denote the terminal wealth of agent j\in\{1,\ldots,n\} . Thus, in a fraction of \alpha_{i} of the possible market scenarios, agent i attains a terminal wealth which is at least as large as the weighted average of her competitors’ terminal wealth. The objective function of agent i is given by