Quantum Entanglement Generation in the Heterometallic Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} Complexes
Hamid Arian Zad, Michal Jaščur, Nerses Ananikian · 2025
Read Quantum Entanglement Generation in the Heterometallic Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} Complexes by Hamid Arian Zad, Michal Jaščur, Nerses Ananikian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20311.txt.
Introduction
Hamid Arian Zad and co-authors study quantum entanglement in molecular magnets built from four nickel and four gadolinium ions. The complexes form two matching cube-like units joined by acetate and hydroxide links, and are modelled as Heisenberg spin systems. Exact diagonalization under a magnetic field gives the states, and negativity serves as the entanglement measure.
Two families are compared, one with single-ion anisotropy and one without. Without anisotropy, strong entanglement sits mainly between nickel ions and fades by set temperature and field levels. With anisotropy, all forms studied, across two, three and four parties, take sizable values. One measure also flags ground state changes sharply in both families.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hamid Arian Zad, Michal Jaščur, Nerses Ananikian |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20311
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Entanglement Generation in the Heterometallic Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} Complexes Preprint: APS/123-QED Hamid Arian Zad, Michal Jaščur, Nerses Ananikian Abstract We investigate tetrapartite and bipartite quantum entanglement in octanuclear heterometallic 3 d / 4 f 3d/4f complexes denoted as Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} under an external magnetic field using exact diagonalization. These molecular magnets that can be effectively characterized by Heisenberg spin models, consist of two Ni 2 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{2} Gd 3+ 2 {}_{2}^{\text{3+}} cubane subunits bridged by acetate and hydroxide ligands. We detect that their magnetization exhibits intermediate plateaus at low temperatures, reflecting distinct ground states characteristic of Gd-containing compounds. Using negativity as a quantum entanglement measure, we analyze the effects of single-ion anisotropy and magnetic field on tetrapartite and bipartite entanglements in two families of Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes: ( 1 ) without and ( 2 ) with anisotropy. Complex ( 1 ) exhibits strong tetrapartite entanglement, persisting up to T ≈ 2.5 T\approx 2.5 K and B ≈ 4.0 B\approx 4.0 T, but considerably weak bipartite entanglement between Ni ⋯ \cdots Ni and Ni ⋯ \cdots Gd links. Conversely, complex ( 2 ) shows strong bipartite entanglements but negligible tetrapartite entanglement negativity. These findings highlight the critical role of single-ion anisotropy in generating and shaping entanglement properties in heterometallic Ni 4 2+ {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd 3+ 4 {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes. pacs Valid PACS appear here I Introduction Molecular magnets with interacting spins Kahn ; Chiesa2024 ; Chilton2013 ; Law2011 ; Miller2002 provide a powerful platform for advancing quantum science and technology. Their complex low-energy spectra make them promising candidates for quantum information storage and processing Gatteschi2006 ; Carretta2021 . This unique property enables their application as qudits, extending the capabilities of quantum logic beyond conventional qubit-based architectures. One particularly intriguing aspect of low-dimensional Heisenberg spin systems is the emergence of commensurate magnetization plateaus related to the distinct quantum states that arise purely from quantum mechanical effects. These plateaus become especially pronounced at low temperature, where the suppression of thermal fluctuations allows quantum states to manifest clearly Eggert1994 ; Eggert1996 ; Motoyama1996 ; Oshikawa1999 ; Affleck1997 ; Kikuchi2005 ; Hida1994 ; Oshikawa1997 ; Leiner2018 ; ArianPhysA ; ArianZad2025 ; Balents2010 ; Balents2017 . The renewed interest in mixed 3d/4f metal cluster chemistry is driven by the discovery of molecular nanomagnets and their extraordinary magnetic properties which arise from the interplay between transition metal ( 3d ) and lanthanide ( 4f ) ions. Unlike homometallic 3d clusters, the design of 3d/4f molecular clusters requires the strategic incorporation of lanthanide ions, with Gd {}^{\text{3+}} being a promising candidate due to its highly isotropic nature and large spin moment Zhao2014 ; Mukhopadhyay2004 ; Khuntia2011 ; Xie2013 ; BiswasNJC2020 . The significant exchange interactions between 3d and 4f metal centers lead to tunable magnetic behaviors, making these systems ideal for both fundamental research and practical applications. Among these materials, heterometallic Ni {}^{\text{2+}}_{4} Gd {}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes Biswas2020 ; Kalita2018 ; Pasatoiu2014 ; Biswas2016 have drawn considerable attention due to their intriguing magnetic properties. AC magnetic susceptibility measurements revealed fast relaxation dynamics in these complexes, attributed to quantum tunneling of magnetization (QTM). As a result, neither of these compounds exhibits the slow relaxation characteristic of single-molecule magnets (SMMs). The absence of magnetic hysteresis makes these non-SMM systems particularly valuable for quantum statistical physics, as they can be effectively analyzed using statistical methods. The precise engineering and control of magnetic interactions at the molecular level make these clusters promising candidates for advanced molecular spin-based devices. Their potential applications can span cutting-edge technologies, including quantum information processing Troiania2011 , spintronics Wernsdorfer2008 , and the development of quantum states for next-generation quantum computing Bagai2009 ; Christou2000 ; Hill2003 . Low-spin molecular nanomagnets, particularly those exhibiting antiferromagnetic interactions or anisotropy, provide an optimal setting for studying quantum entanglement Wootters1996 ; Wootters1997 ; Wootters1998 ; Aldoshin2014 ; Peres1996 ; Vidal2002 ; Horodecki2009 . Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property required for utilizing molecular nanomagnets as spin cluster quantum states Chiesa2024 ; Troiania2011 ; Aldoshin2014 . Negativity is a widely used measure of quantum entanglement Peres1996 ; Vidal2002 ; Horodecki2009 , applicable to mixed states of bipartite and multipartite systems, such as qutrit-qutrit and qutrit-qutrit-qudit-qudit configurations. The study of magnetic properties of the polycrystalline samples Ni {}^{\text{2+}}_{2} Gd {}_{2}^{\text{3+}} such as ( 1 ) [\text{Ni}_{4}\text{Gd}_{4}(\text{HL})_{4}(\mu_{2}-\text{OH})_{2}(\mu_{3}-\text{OH})_{4}(\mu-\text{OOCCH}_{3})_{8}]\cdot(\text{NO}_{3})\cdot 12\text{H}_{2}\text{O} Biswas2020 indicated a ferromagnetic {\mathrm{Gd}\cdots\mathrm{Gd}} and an antiferromagnetic {\mathrm{Ni}\cdots\mathrm{Ni}} interaction. Similarly, a related study on ( 2 ) [\text{Ni}_{4}\text{Gd}_{4}(\mu_{2}-\text{OH})_{2}(\mu_{3}-\text{OH})_{4}(\mu-\text{OOCCH}_{3})_{8}(\text{LH}_{2})_{4}] Kalita2018 revealed a ferromagnetic interaction between the lanthanide and nickel centers, with an estimated exchange coupling of J_{\mathrm{Ni}\cdots\mathrm{Gd}}=+0.86\;\text{cm}^{-1} . However, these complex does not exhibit SMM behavior due to weak \text{Ni}\cdots\text{Gd} and \text{Gd}\cdots\text{Gd} interactions. In this work, we consider the Heisenberg model describing \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes and rigorously investigate their low-temperature magnetization, tetrapartite entanglement and bipartite quantum entanglement between Ni \cdots Ni and Ni \cdots Gd pairs within each cubane unit. These complexes consist of two butterfly-shaped heterometallic \text{Ni}_{2}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{2}^{\text{3+}}\text{O}_{4} distorted cubanes, connected via acetate and hydroxide bridging ligands. The presence of non-negligible single-ion anisotropy in Ni ions introduces additional complexity, as this property competes with exchange interactions in determining the magnetic and quantum characteristics of these molecular magnets. To reveal the low-temperature magnetization curves and entanglement negativities of these octanuclear nickel-containing complexes, we employ full exact diagonalization (ED) methods. The study of multipartite entanglement between spin pairs in heterometallic mixed 3d/4f \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes remains relatively unexplored due to the complexity of the Hamiltonian. Therefore, the main objective of this article is to investigate the tetrapartite entanglement negativity together with bipartite entanglement negativity between Ni \cdots Ni and Ni \cdots Gd pairs in a single cubane \text{Ni}_{2}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{2}^{\text{3+}} unit of the octanuclear \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes with very weak intercubane interaction zJ^{\prime} . The paper is structured as follows: In the next section, we provide a detailed description of the magnetic structure of \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes and introduce the corresponding effective Hamiltonian. Section III presents the ground-state phase diagram and low-temperature magnetization of these complexes, comparing key theoretical predictions with experimental data from two specific compounds: ( 1 ) [\text{Ni}_{4}\text{Gd}_{4}(\text{HL})_{4}(\mu_{2}\text{-OH})_{2}(\mu_{3}\text{-OH})_{4}(\mu\text{-OOCCH}_{3})_{8}]\cdot(\text{NO}_{3})\cdot 12\text{H}_{2}\text{O} Biswas2020 , and ( 2 ) [\text{Ni}_{4}\text{Gd}_{4}(\mu_{2}\text{-OH})_{2}(\mu_{3}\text{-OH})_{4}(\mu\text{-OOCCH}_{3})_{8}(\text{LH}_{2})_{4}] Kalita2018 . Hereafter, for simplicity, we refer to these compounds as ( 1 ) and ( 2 ). Additionally, we discuss the degree of tetrapartite and bipartite quantum entanglement in these complexes across different parameter regimes. Finally, Section IV summarizes our key findings and conclusions. II Model Our motivation for studying the \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes stems from previous experimental investigations of these systems Kalita2018 ; Biswas2020 . In this work, we consider the two interconnected heterometallic \text{Ni}_{2}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{2}^{\text{3+}}\text{O}_{4} distorted cubane units as a single subsystem, as depicted in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Schematic representation of the molecular structure of \text{Ni}_{4}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{4}^{\text{3+}} complexes. Orange spheres represent nickel ions, while light blue spheres denote gadolinium ions. The intra-cubane exchange interactions are defined as follows: blue solid lines indicate the exchange interaction J_{\text{nn}} between Ni ions, black dotted lines represent the exchange interaction J_{\text{ng}} between Ni and Gd ions, and red dashed lines correspond to the interaction J_{\text{gg}} between Gd ions. The orange dashed line, labeled zJ^{\prime} , represents the intercubane interaction between the two \text{Ni}_{2}^{\text{2+}}\text{Gd}_{2}^{\text{3+}} cubane units. The Hamiltonian of the octanuclrear complexes