The importance of exploration: Modelling site-constant foraging
Sarah A. MacQueen, Clara F. Hardy, W. John Braun, Rebecca C. Tyson · 2025
Read The importance of exploration: Modelling site-constant foraging by Sarah A. MacQueen, Clara F. Hardy, W. John Braun, Rebecca C. Tyson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20086.txt.
Introduction
Sarah MacQueen and co-authors model how bees pick a feeding site in a 2025 study. Many animals return again and again to one feeding spot, a habit called site constancy. Before feeding starts, an animal must scout the land and choose the site. Those early steps are rarely modeled. The team built an agent based model with bumble bees in a patchy landscape of crops, wildflowers, and empty ground.
They tested two scouting styles: random search, and loop trips out from the nest. They also tested four choice rules, from random picking to choosing by distance, flower density, or energy gain. Choice rules mattered most for crop pollination and for how much crop food was gathered. Scouting style mattered most for time spent harvesting and trip length. The authors say some patterns could reveal how real bees choose their sites.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sarah A. MacQueen, Clara F. Hardy, W. John Braun, Rebecca C. Tyson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20086
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The importance of exploration: Modelling site-constant foraging Sarah A. MacQueen, Clara F. Hardy, W. John Braun, Rebecca C. Tyson Abstract Foraging site constancy, or repeated return to the same foraging location, is a foraging strategy used by many species to decrease uncertainty and risks. It is often unclear, however, exactly how organisms identify the foraging site. Here we are interested in the context where the actual harvesting of food is first preceded by a separate exploration period. In this context, foraging consists of three distinct steps: (1) exploration of the landscape (site-generation), (2) selection of a foraging site (site-selection), and (3) exploitation (harvesting) through repeated trips between the foraging site and ”home base”. This type of foraging has received scant attention in the modelling literature, leading to two main knowledge gaps. First, there is very little known about how organisms implement steps (1) and (2). Second, it is not known how the choice of implementation method affects the outcomes of step (3). Typical outcomes include the foragers’ rate of energy return, and the distribution of foragers on the landscape. We investigate these two gaps, using an agent-based model with bumble bees as our model organism foraging in a patchy resource landscape of crop, wildflower, and empty cells. We tested two different site-generation methods (random and circular foray exploration behaviour) and four different site-selection methods (random and optimizing based on distance from the nest, local wildflower density, or net rate of energy return) on a variety of outcomes from the site-constant harvesting step. We find that site-selection method has a high impact on crop pollination services as well as the percent of crop resources collected, while site-generation method has a high impact on the percent of time spent harvesting and the total trip time. We also find that some of the patterns we identify can be used to infer how a given real organism is identifying a foraging site. Our results underscore the importance of explicitly considering exploratory behaviour to better understand the ecological consequences of foraging dynamics. keywords keyword1, Keyword2, Keyword3, Keyword4 keywords Agent based model, bumble bee, crop pollination services, model mechanism, foraging site choice, insect foraging behaviour 1 Introduction Repeated use of the same area, variously referred to as as site constancy, site fidelity, or path recursion, is a common behavioural strategy across many different organisms for a variety of purposes, but especially for foraging ( Berger-Tal and Bar-David, 2015 ) . Foraging site constancy has been observed in, for example, penguins ( Baylis et al., 2015 ) , sea lions ( Chilvers, 2008 ) , ants ( Crist and McMahon, 1991 ) , and bees ( Thomson et al., 1997 ) . The benefits of site constancy for individuals include more efficient foraging, due to (i) memory of the site location and a greater familiarity with the spatial structure of resources within the site ( Osborne and Williams, 2001 ; Olsson and Brown, 2010 ) , (ii) increased mean reward from the patch and reduced variance in the reward encountered during trips ( Possingham, 1989 ) , making trips both more profitable and more predictable, (iii) better survivorship resulting from greater knowledge of the environment, which reduces predation risk ( Osborne and Williams, 2001 ; Brown, 2001 ) , and (iv) reduction in competition and conflict ( Paton and Carpenter, 1984 ; Garrison and Gass, 1999 ) . There are many different factors that may affect how individuals choose from among potential foraging sites. These factors include distance from the central place ( Dramstad et al., 2003 ; Dramstad, 1996 ; Saville et al., 1997 ; Westphal et al., 2006 ) ; net rate of energy return/intake ( Cartar, 1991 ; Cresswell et al., 2000 ) ; foraging efficiency (ratio of energetic gain to expenditure) ( Charlton and Houston, 2010 ) ; the type of resources available (preference for certain types, perhaps due to nutritional quality) ( Bobiwash et al., 2018 ; Ruedenauer et al., 2016 ) ; resource density ( Cartar, 2009 ; Dreisig, 1995 ) ; and the presence of conspecifics ( Leadbeater and Chittka, 2007 ) . In reality, individuals probably use some combination of the above factors, but for many organisms it is not known which factors dominate and under what conditions. Modelling studies can be a powerful tool for elucidating how organisms use the landscape they inhabit ( Patterson et al., 2008 ; Cobbold et al., 2015 ; Klappstein et al., 2022 ; Bracis et al., 2015 ; McLane et al., 2011 ; Fagan et al., 2022 ) . Landscape-scale studies can be prohibitively expensive, and generating a sufficiently wide range of landscape configurations to test any particular theory can also be very difficult. Models provide an ideal solution: A near-infinite range of landscape configurations can be investigated, and exact probabilistic foraging distributions or thousands of sample foraging paths can be generated. The theory can then inform empirical work, allowing theory testing to be done with a much smaller array of landscapes. This approach, however, depends on there being a sufficiently detailed understanding of movement behaviour for model predictions to be useful. Currently, it is generally not known exactly how any given organism identifies a foraging site, though some guidance is provided by optimal foraging theory ( Pyke, 1984 ; Cezilly and Benhamou, 1996 ; Fortin, 2002 ; Courant and Fortin, 2012 ) . It appears that memory plays a strong role in many cases ( Ranc et al., 2021 ; Bracis et al., 2015 ; Kulakowska et al., 2014 ) , and even insects have been shown to be capable of developing complex memories ( Collett et al., 2013 ) . Modelling work has shown that, depending on the specific goals of the forager ( Nauta et al., 2020 ) , memory can be advantageous in certain contexts ( Pull et al., 2022 ; Bracis et al., 2015 ) , though is less beneficial than often thought ( Arehart and Adler, 2023 ) . Existing models generally assume that the exploration and exploitation (harvesting) stages are concurrent ( Fagan et al., 2022 ; Capera-Aragones et al., 2022 ; Nauta et al., 2020 ; Avgar et al., 2013 ; Boyer and Walsh, 2010 ) , but many organisms, especially when they are naive, exhibit a separate exploration stage that is individually-driven ( Larsen and Boutin, 1994 ; Popp and Dornhaus, 2023 ; Nowak et al., 2023 ; Osborne et al., 2013a ; Carter et al., 2020 ; Mandal and Brahma, 2019 ) . The existence of separate exploration bouts means that the organism has the opportunity to sample many parts of the landscape to generate a mental list of possible foraging sites from which it will eventually select one. More specifically, in this context, site-constant foraging consists of three distinct steps: (1) exploration of the landscape (site-generation), (2) selection of a foraging site (site-selection), and (3) exploitation (harvesting) through repeated trips between the foraging site and ”home base”. This type of foraging has received scant attention in the modelling literature, leading to two main knowledge gaps. First, there is very little known about how organisms implement steps (1) and (2). Second, it is not known how the choice of implementation method affects