Enhancing wave-particle duality
Arwa Bukhari, Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Robert Purdy, Almut Beige · 2025
Read Enhancing wave-particle duality by Arwa Bukhari, Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Robert Purdy, Almut Beige (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20077.txt.
Introduction
Arwa Bukhari, Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Robert Purdy, and Almut Beige set out in 2025 to treat particles and waves on equal quantum footing. In an earlier line of work they quantized light in a physically guided way. Here they apply the same approach to plain mechanical point particles, aiming for a tighter match between the two descriptions.
A particle can sit at any position with any velocity, so they take those paired states as the basic orthogonal states of the theory. They then demand that the states evolve by Newton's equations of motion. The resulting theory does not depend on mass when Newton's laws do not. Ordinary quantum mechanics in space emerges as a semi-classical approximation after a fixed mass is imposed. Readers get a foundation where particles are quantized first, not as an afterthought to fields.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arwa Bukhari, Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Robert Purdy, Almut Beige |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20077
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Enhancing wave-particle duality Arwa Bukhari, Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Robert Purdy, Almut Beige Abstract To enhance the consistency between the quantum descriptions of waves and particles, we quantise mechanical point particles in this paper in the same physically-motivated way as we previously quantised light in quantum electrodynamics [Bennett et al. , Eur. J. Phys. 37 , 014001 (2016)]. To identify the relevant Hilbert space, we notice that mechanical particles can occupy any position x x while moving at any velocity v v . Afterwards, we promote the classical states ( x , v ) (x,v) to pairwise orthogonal quantum states | x , v ⟩ |x,v\rangle and demand that these evolve according to Newton’s equations of motion. The resulting quantum theory is mass-independent, when Newton’s equations of motion are mass-independent, as one would expect. The basic formulation of quantum mechanics emerges from quantum mechanics in configuration space as a semi-classical approximation when a fixed mass is imposed and several other adjustments are made. I Introduction In classical physics, Hamilton’s formulation of the laws of mechanics specifies the motion of a point particle moving in one-dimension in terms of two quantities: its position x and its momentum p [ 1 ] . The dynamics of the position x and the momentum p can be found by solving Hamilton’s equations of motion [ 2 , 3 ] , \displaystyle\frac{\partial x}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial H}{\partial p}\,,~~\frac{\partial p}{\partial t}=-\frac{\partial H}{\partial x}\,, (1) where H=H(x,p) is the relevant Hamiltonian. When solving these equations, we obtain a function x(t) which defines the trajectory of the particle. As pointed out by Dirac [ 4 ] , if the Hamiltonian H of the system is not appropriately defined, Eq. ( 1 ) can lead directly to inconsistencies in the theory. Nevertheless, Hamiltonian mechanics lends itself naturally to the quantisation of mechanical point particles. In canonical quantisation, this is done by identifying the observables for the position and the momentum of quantum mechanical point particles with a pair of canonically conjugate operators which we denote \hat{x} and \hat{p} [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . Notice that Hamiltonian mechanics provides just one formulation of classical mechanics, and other alternative descriptions are available. One example is the earlier Newtonian description [ 12 , 3 ] , which we adopt in the following as the starting point for a physically-motivated quantisation of mechanical point particles that move in the presence of a non-zero potential V(x) along the x axis. Newton’s second law states that the force F(x)=-\partial V(x)/\partial x experienced by a particle at position x equals \displaystyle F(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle m\,\ddot{x} (2) where m and \ddot{x}=\partial^{2}x/\partial t^{2} denote its rest mass and its acceleration respectively. To turn the second order differential equation ( 2 ) into two first order differential equations, Newton, and also Leibniz, described mechanical particles by specifying not only their position x but also their velocity v . The result is Newton’s equations of motion, \displaystyle\frac{\partial x}{\partial t}=v\,,~~\frac{\partial v}{\partial t}=f(x) (3) with the function f(x) representing a position-dependent force per mass, \displaystyle f(x) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-{1\over m}\,\frac{\partial V(x)}{\partial x}\,. (4) This variable is the key variable which fully determines the dynamics of a mechanical point particle in a potential V(x) with given initial conditions, like its initial position and velocity, x(0) and v(0) . The starting point for the quantisation of mechanical point particles in the basic formulation of quantum mechanics (QM) which we review in Section II is Hamilton’s formalism. In this paper, we quantise instead Newton’s equations of motion while taking the whole configuration space and not only a subspace of states of mechanical point particles into account. The term configuration space is the fundamental space of all possible states that a physical system can be in. As we shall see below, the resulting formalism, which we refer to as QM in configuration space , has several advantages. For example, its Schrödinger equation is mass independent, if the same is true for Newton’s equations of motion in Eq. ( 3 ). This connection increases the consistency between quantum and classical mechanics. Moreover, QM in configuration space enhances wave-particle duality, i.e. the consistency between the quantum descriptions of wave and particles, by quantising mechanical point particles in the same physically-motivated way as we quantise the electromagnetic field and its photonic carriers in free space [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . The first step of physically-motivated quantisation schemes is to identify the relevant configuration space. Afterwards, we associate its classical states with pairwise orthonormal quantum states. These are the most classical quantum states of the physical system and form a complete basis of its Hilbert space {\cal H} . In addition, we assume in the following that all quantum states evolve according to the Schrödinger equation based on a dynamical Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{\rm dyn} . This Hamiltonian can be derived by demanding that the most classical quantum states evolve in a way that is consistent with classical physics. As we have seen already in the case of photons, \hat{H}_{\rm dyn} is in general unbounded from below [ 14 , 15 ] . It therefore does not coincide with the energy observable of the quantum system, although there is a close connection between the energy observable and H_{\rm dyn} [ 16 ] . Notice also that our quantisation approach [ 13 ] has some similarities with the quantum reconstruction program [ 17 , 18 ] which already attracted some attention [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . As mentioned previously, in Newtonian mechanics we describe the dynamics of a mechanical point particle by specifying its position x and its velocity v at all times t . In fact, the initial position x(0) and the initial velocity v(0) of the particle can be chosen independently. To ensure that position and velocity are of equal importance in the corresponding quantum theory, we promote the distinguishable classical states (x,v) to orthonormal quantum states |x,v\rangle with \displaystyle\langle x,v|x^{\prime},v^{\prime}\rangle \displaystyle=\delta(x-x^{\prime})\,\delta(v-v^{\prime})\,. (5) These states form a basis in the Hilbert space {\cal H} , i.e. the configuration space, of quantum mechanical point particles. Although the |x,v\rangle states have some similarities with the coherent states |z\rangle=|x+{\rm i}p\rangle that represent the classical phase space in alternative formulations of QM [ 24 , 25 , 23 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] ), they are not the same. While the |x,v\rangle states describe individual particles, the |z\rangle states are many-body quantum states. An important difference between basic QM and QM in configuration space is that the Hilbert space {\cal H} of the latter is significantly larger and allows quantum mechanical point particles to be simultaneously localised in position and in velocity. As we shall see below, the momentum and the velocity of a particle represent two independent physical observables. In general, the quantum state |\psi(t)\rangle of a quantum mechanical point particle is a superposition of the |x,v\rangle states with |\langle\psi(t)|x,v\rangle|^{2} representing the probability for finding the particle at time t at position x while moving at velocity v . Figure 1: The classical phase space trajectories (red) of three mechanical point particles with energies E_{n} (n=1,2,3) moving along