Comparison of magnetic diffusion and reconnection in ideal and resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics, ideal magnetodynamics, and resistive force-free electrodynamics
Michael P. Grehan, Tanisha Ghosal, James R. Beattie, Bart Ripperda, Oliver Porth, Fabio Bacchini · 2025
Read Comparison of magnetic diffusion and reconnection in ideal and resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics, ideal magnetodynamics, and resistive force-free electrodynamics by Michael P. Grehan, Tanisha Ghosal, James R. Beattie, Bart Ripperda, Oliver Porth, Fabio Bacchini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-20013.txt.
Introduction
Simulations of magnetized plasma near black holes usually skip real electrical resistance. They trust the grid itself to supply a stand-in. Michael Grehan and co-authors test whether that trust is earned. They compare four model families, from ideal magnetohydrodynamics to force-free electrodynamics, on two basic behaviors: how current sheets decay, and how magnetic field lines reconnect.
In one dimension, the stand-in resistance in ideal models decays too slowly, spreading subdiffusively. Models with explicit resistance match theory properly. In two dimensions, ideal models reconnect at rates tied to grid resolution, a warning sign. At fine resolution they converge toward the resistive result. The study draws a clear line: numerical resistance is not physical resistance, and some questions can only be asked with the real thing switched on.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael P. Grehan, Tanisha Ghosal, James R. Beattie, Bart Ripperda, Oliver Porth, Fabio Bacchini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-20013
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparison of magnetic diffusion and reconnection in ideal and resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics, ideal magnetodynamics, and resistive force-free electrodynamics Michael P. Grehan, Tanisha Ghosal, James R. Beattie, Bart Ripperda, Oliver Porth, Fabio Bacchini Abstract High-energy astrophysical systems and compact objects are frequently modeled using ideal relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) or force-free electrodynamic (FFE) simulations, with the underlying assumption that the discretisation from the numerical scheme introduces an effective (numerical) magnetic resistivity that adequately resembles an explicit resistivity. However, it is crucial to note that numerical resistivity can fail to replicate essential features of explicit resistivity. In this study, we compare the 1D resistive decay and 2D reconnection properties of four commonly used physical models. We demonstrate that the 1D Ohmic decay of current sheets via numerical dissipation in both ideal MHD and magnetodynamics (MD) is subdiffusive (i.e., sub-linear in time), whereas explicit resistive FFE and resistive MHD simulations match the predictions of resistive theory adequately. For low-resolution, reconnecting current sheets in 2D, we show that ideal MHD and MD have an analogue to the Sweet–Parker regime where the scaling of the reconnection rate depends directly on the resolution. At high resolutions, ideal MHD and MD have an asymptotic reconnection rate similar to resistive MHD. Furthermore, we find that guide field-balanced current sheets in ideal MHD and MD have a qualitative structure similar to that of one in resistive MHD. Similarly, a pressure-balanced current sheet in ideal MHD is found to have a qualitative structure similar to that of one in resistive MHD. For a guide field-balanced sheet, resistive FFE is found to have a nearly identical Sweet–Parker regime compared to resistive MHD and a similar asymptotic reconnection rate for large enough Lundquist numbers, but differs in the timescale for reconnection onset in the asymptotic regime. We discuss the implications of our findings for global simulations. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction Relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations have become an essential tool in high-energy astrophysics for modeling the behavior of plasmas in a variety of astrophysical environments, ranging from the dynamics of accretion disks around black holes (e.g. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] ) to the evolution of magnetized outflows in stellar and galactic contexts (e.g. [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] ). Similarly, force-free electrodynamics (FFE) has been used to perform global simulations of magnetospheres (e.g. [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] ) and black hole mergers (e.g. [ 16 ] ). Many of these global simulations often assume ideal frameworks, i.e. lack any explicit non-ideal, dissipative operators in the models, where the plasma is treated as a perfectly conducting fluid, or in the case of FFE, the plasma inertia is entirely neglected. Hence, any dissipation occurs only at a small kernel of the order of the grid scale due to numerical discretisation (typically of the order of 10 grid cells for second-order spatial reconstruction methods; [ 17 , 18 , 19 ] ) of the model. This approach implicitly introduces an effective numerical resistivity, with an unknown diffusion operator, which is widely used to approximate the effects of explicit resistivity without explicitly solving the resistive equations. Resistive processes play a fundamental role in astrophysical plasmas, influencing phenomena across a broad range of energies. In Newtonian settings characterized by low magnetization, where the rest mass energy of the plasma greatly exceeds the energy in the magnetic field, magnetic reconnection is a pivotal mechanism underpinning the dynamics of solar flares [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , geomagnetic storms [ 23 ] , the structure of the geomagnetic tail [ 24 , 25 ] , and MHD turbulence [ 26 ] . In the relativistically magnetized regime, where the magnetic energy greatly exceeds the rest mass energy of the plasma, reconnection is integral to the behavior of plasmas in the equatorial current sheets of rotating neutron stars [ 27 , 28 ] , in accretion flows around black holes [ 3 , 29 , 4 , 30 , 31 ] , and has even been proposed as a potential mechanism behind fast radio bursts [ 32 , 33 ] and fast radio transients [ 34 ] . There are two distinct regimes of magnetic reconnection which we explore, parametrized by the Lundquist number S=\frac{4\pi v_{\rm{A}}\Delta}{\eta c^{2}}, (1) where v_{\rm{A}} is the Alfvén speed [ 35 ] , \Delta is the current sheet half length, \eta is the resistivity of the plasma, and c is the speed of light. In the Sweet–Parker regime [ 20 , 21 ] , the reconnection rate, i.e. the speed ratio between the inflow to the outflow of the current sheet, is directly dependent on the Lundquist number, v_{{\rm{rec}}}=\frac{v_{\rm{in}}}{v_{\rm{out}}}=\sqrt{S^{-1}}, (2) where v_{\rm{in}} and v_{\rm{out}} are the inflow and outflow speeds respectively. This result holds in the relativistic regime [ 36 ] . In the asymptotic, plasmoid-dominated regime where the Lundquist number exceeds the critical threshold of S\gtrsim 10^{4} , the reconnection rate becomes independent of the Lundquist number and plateaus at a value of v_{{\rm{rec}}}=\mathcal{O}(0.01) in MHD [ 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 43 , 44 , 45 , 46 , 47 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 ] . We expect realistic Lundquist numbers in astrophysical plasmas to be in the asymptotic regime, without however restricting the value of v_{{\rm{rec}}} to MHD expectations, due to beyond-MHD effects occurring in real astrophysical systems. Resistive processes also play a key role in particle energization by facilitating the dissipation of magnetic field energy into thermal and kinetic energy [ 52 , 53 ] , and the non-thermal acceleration of particles [ 54 , 55 , 56 , 57 , 58 , 59 ] . This is often associated with the formation of power-law energy distributions, characteristic of accelerated particle populations, as observed in relativistic astrophysical systems such as pulsar-wind nebulae, blazer jets, black hole flares, and gamma ray bursts [ 60 , 61 , 62 , 63 , 64 , 65 ] . A key open question in reconnection-driven particle acceleration is the relative importance of non-ideal electric fields, necessitating a deeper understanding of how resistivity governs energy dissipation [ 66 , 67 ] . This non-ideal electric field is absent in ideal MHD and magnetodynamics (MD), hence it is essential to understand how these models represent the heating of plasma by reconnection. FFE [ 68 , 69 , 70 , 71 , 72 , 73 , 74 , 14 ] and MD [ 75 , 76 , 77 ] are equivalent descriptions of the infinite magnetization limit of ideal MHD, where the plasma inertia is entirely neglected and the dynamics are described solely by the evolution of the electric and magnetic field. FFE and MD differ in the choice of how the system is numerically evolved: FFE solves Faraday’s law and Ampére’s law to evolve the magnetic field, \bm{B} , and the electric field, \bm{E} ; while MD solves Faraday’s law and the momentum equation for the Poynting flux to evolve the magnetic field, \bm{B} , and the Poynting flux, \bm{S}=\bm{E}\times\bm{B} . These models are necessary because MHD becomes numerically unstable at very high magnetization [ 78