Conclusions Not Yet Drawn from the Unsolved 4/3-Problem—How to Get a Stable Classical Electron

Manfried Faber · 2025

Read Conclusions Not Yet Drawn from the Unsolved 4/3-Problem—How to Get a Stable Classical Electron by Manfried Faber (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19931.txt.

Introduction

Manfried Faber, writing alone, revisits a century-old puzzle about the classical electron in a 2025 paper. Classical theory treats the electron as a tiny charged ball, but its energy figures do not add up: the famous four-thirds problem. Quantum theories bypass the clash by subtracting infinities, which Faber argues hides the physical cause.

The root problem, he contends, is that a classical electron cannot hold itself together under its own repulsion. No fix inside Maxwell's theory can stabilize it. He asks what smallest change to the base theory could work while keeping Maxwell's laws as a limiting case. A close reading of the four-thirds problem, he argues, points to models that meet those demands.

Catalog record

CREATORManfried Faber
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19931

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Conclusions Not Yet Drawn from the Unsolved 4/3-Problem—How to Get a Stable Classical Electron Manfried Faber Abstract It has been known for over 100 years that there is a discrepancy between Maxwell’s electrodynamics and the idea of a classical electron as the “atom” of electricity. This incompatibility is known under the terms 4/3 problem of the classical electron and radiation reaction force and was circumvented in the currently most successful theories, the quantum field theories, by limit value considerations, by the mutual subtraction of infinities, i.e., by purely mathematical methods that eliminate obvious contradictions but are not really based on an intuitive understanding of its physical causes. The actual origin of the problems mentioned lies in the instability of the classical electron. Stabilization cannot be achieved within the framework of Maxwell’s electrodynamics. This raises the question of what a minimal change to the fundamentals of electrodynamics should look like, which contains Maxwell’s theory as a limiting case. A detailed analysis of the 4/3 problem points to models that fulfill these requirements. 1 Introduction The discussion about the origin of the problems of the classical electron is essentially about the concept of particles. The question is whether the idea of assuming atoms of electricity to describe electrodynamic phenomena, as Helmholtz had already suggested, is expedient. Stoney suggested the name “electron” for these “atoms”. In formulating this description, classical electrodynamics encountered two unsolvable problems, the 4/3 problem and the problem of radiation reaction force [ 1 , 2 ] . In this article, we focus in particular on the cause of the 4/3 problem and examine what conclusions can be drawn from the form of the discrepancy and what kind of models can solve both problems of classical electrodynamics. Early on in the formulation of the dynamics of electrons, an idea emerged that is still generally accepted today: a distinction is made between the dynamics of electromagnetic fields, the dynamics of electrons and the interaction between particles and fields. According to the special theory of relativity, the mass of particles is expected to increase with velocity according to the well-known Equation ( 4 ) with the \gamma factor. It is a characteristic of moving particles that are described in a “stationary” three-dimensional Euclidean reference system \Sigma , see Section 2 and Figure 1 , that the velocity vector u^{\mu}\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{UVonbeta})}{=}\gamma(c,\vec{v}) does not have to be orthogonal to the position vectors x^{\mu}:=(0,\vec{x}) , i.e., the scalar product 1 1 1 We use the metric \eta^{\mu\nu}:=\mathrm{diag}(1,-1,-1,-1) here, i.e., u_{\mu}x^{\mu}:=u_{0}x^{0}-\vec{u}\vec{x} . u_{\mu}x^{\mu}:=-\gamma\vec{v}\vec{x}\leq 0. (1) does not have to vanish. The equal sign only applies to particles at rest. For electrons, which are described by electromagnetic fields, such a particle behavior was already expected by Lorentz and Abraham [ 3 , 2 ] . Rohrlich clearly demonstrated in [ 4 , 5 ] that the formalism of special relativity only guarantees that the four-momentum of a field distribution behaves Lorentz-covariantly. However, the 4/3 problem already established by Abraham [ 1 ] shows that it was not possible to consistently represent electrons moving in \Sigma by fields. The reason lies in the instability of the classical electron. To discuss the 4/3 problem, it is sufficient to consider electrons moving at constant speed. The result of such a field description of the classical electron is given in Section 2 in order to be able to discuss in Section 3 which minimal changes lead to a stable model of classical electrons, so that the energy–momentum relationships also apply in reference systems that are not orthogonal to u^{\mu} , as the inequality ( 1 ) allows. In such a model, which allows a stable classical electron to be formulated, no divergences occur. Maxwell’s electrodynamics would thus no longer contradict Millikan’s famous experiment, which proved the quantization of the electric charge before quantum mechanics moved quantization to the center of scientific interest, as explained in Section 3 . 2 Particle and Field Description of the Classical Electron Particles are lumps of matter that remain undestroyed when scattered with sufficiently low energies. Such particles can be assigned an invariant mass m_{0} and the concepts of kinematics can be applied without contradiction. To understand what this means, it is helpful to look at the definitions and relationships of relativistic kinematics and their relationship to the non-relativistic terms, see Appendix A . From the assignment of the space–time coordinates x^{\mu} to time t and the position vector \vec{x} x:=(c_{0}t,\vec{x}) (2) and the four-momentum p^{\mu} to the energy E and the spatial momentum \vec{p} p:=(\frac{E}{c_{0}},\vec{p}) (3) it follows that the mass m of the particles depends on the ratio of their velocity v to the speed of light c_{0} m(\beta)\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{pvonbeta})}{=}\gamma m_{0}\quad\textrm{with}\quad\gamma:=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\beta^{2}}}\quad\textrm{and}\quad\beta:=\frac{v}{c_{0}} (4) so the four-momentum results in \displaystyle p\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{pvonbeta})}{=}\gamma m_{0}(c_{0},\vec{v}). (5) A closer look shows that definition ( 3 ) follows from definition ( 2 ) if a suitable action function for a free particle is defined and the momentum is derived from it as the temporal component of the energy–momentum tensor p^{\mu}\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{ImpulsAbgeleitet})}{=}\int_{\Sigma}\Theta^{\mu 0}(x)\,\mathrm{d}^{3}\sigma. (6) The integration here takes place over that three-dimensional space-like volume \Sigma in which the velocities \vec{v} are determined, i.e., in principle over any three-dimensional space-like volume. Precisely this arbitrariness of \Sigma is obviously one of the characteristics of a particle, see Figure 1 . Figure 1: We describe an electron in the laboratory system \Sigma and in the comoving system \stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{\Sigma}} according to the rules of special relativity, as shown in this Minkowski diagram. Note that the points A and \stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{A}} connected by dashed lines have the same spatial coordinates \stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{x}} and only differ in time \stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{t}} . Since the electron is at rest in the comoving system, the field strengths measured in the comoving system are the same at A as in \stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{A}} . To determine the field strength measured in \Sigma at A , the coordinates x and t at A must be taken into account and the field strength tensor must be transformed according to the transformation rules of a tensor. The relationships valid for A apply accordingly for B . In the field description, we assume, like Abraham [ 1 ] , that the mass of the electron is purely electromagnetic in nature, see Appendix B , and calculate energy and momentum according to Equation ( 6 ) for the field of a charge e=-e_{0} from the symmetric energy–momentum tensor \Theta^{\mu\nu}\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{symmEITEdyn})}{=}-\frac{1}{\mu_{0}}\eta^{\mu\kappa}F_{\kappa\lambda}F^{\nu\lambda}+\frac{1}{4\mu_{0}}\eta^{\mu\nu}F_{\kappa\lambda}F^{\kappa\lambda}. (7) In a reference frame \Sigma , in which the electron moves at a speed \vec{v}=c\vec{\beta} , see Figure 1 , the field strengths transform according to the Lorentz transformation of the field strength tensor F^{\mu\nu} to \displaystyle\begin{aligned} &\vec{E}(\vec{\beta})\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{EBbewegt})}{=}\vec{E}_{\parallel}(0)+\gamma\vec{E}_{\perp}(0)\quad\textrm{with}\quad\vec{E}_{\parallel}:=\frac{\vec{\beta}(\vec{\beta}\vec{E})}{\beta^{2}},\quad\vec{E}_{\perp}:=\vec{E}-\vec{E}_{\parallel},\\ &c\vec{B}(\vec{\beta})\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{EBbewegt})}{=}\gamma\vec{\beta}\times\vec{E}(0).\end{aligned} (8) For a charge at rest, each of the three electric field components contributes to the energy density ( B.4 ) with one third of the rest energy density \mathcal{E}_{0}(\vec{r}) . This leads to an energy of the moving charge e E_{e}(\beta)\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{eneBew0})}{=}E_{e}(0)\,\frac{4\gamma^{2}-1}{3\gamma}, (9) that does not have the form expected for particles ( 5 ), E_{e}(\beta)=\gamma E_{e}(0) . The momentum \vec{P}_{e}(\vec{\beta})\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{ImpBew0})}{=}\frac{\varepsilon_{0}}{c_{0}}\int_{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{\Sigma}}}\mathrm{d}^{3}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\circ}}{{\sigma}}\left[-\vec{E}_{\perp}(0)\left(\vec{E}_{\parallel}(0)\vec{\beta}\right)+\gamma\vec{\beta}\vec{E}_{\perp}^{2}(0)\right]\overset{\footnotesize(\ref{ImpBew1})}{=}\vec{\beta}\gamma\frac{4}{3}\frac{E_{e}(0)}{c_{0}} (10) shows momentum densities normal to the velocity -\frac{\varepsilon_{0}}{c_{0}}\vec{E}_{\perp}(0)\left(\vec{E}_{\parallel}(0)\vec{\beta}\right) (11) and thus internal stresses in the classical electron, which cancel each other out and therefore do not contribute to the total momentum. The factor 4/3 in \vec{P}_{e}(\vec{\beta}) means a discrepancy between the gravitational mass E_{e}(0)/c_{0}^{2}

Read the complete text