Identification of Average Treatment Effects in Nonparametric Panel Models

Susan Athey & Guido Imbens · 2025

Read Identification of Average Treatment Effects in Nonparametric Panel Models by Susan Athey & Guido Imbens (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19873.txt.

Introduction

Susan Athey and Guido Imbens tackle a core question in data analysis in a 2025 paper: how to pin down the average effect of a treatment when units are tracked over time. Panel data, the same people or places measured again and again, is rich but tangled, since each unit carries its own hidden traits.

The authors propose a flexible factor model that lets those hidden traits shape outcomes without fixing a rigid form. They prove the average treatment effect can be recovered under it. The proof works by building an estimator that fills in, for each unit and time, what would have happened without treatment. That filler also serves other jobs, like splitting group gaps in pay.

Catalog record

CREATORSusan Athey & Guido Imbens
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19873

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Identification of Average Treatment Effects in Nonparametric Panel Models Susan Athey & Guido Imbens Abstract This paper studies identification of average treatment effects in a panel data setting. It introduces a novel nonparametric factor model and proves identification of average treatment effects. The identification proof is based on the introduction of a consistent estimator. Underlying the proof is a result that there is a consistent estimator for the expected outcome in the absence of the treatment for each unit and time period; this result can be applied more broadly, for example in problems of decompositions of group-level differences in outcomes, such as the much-studied gender wage gap. Introduction There is a large literature on estimating causal effects and predictive estimands using panel data. Various estimators have been proposed, often motivated by different models of the underlying data generating process. There is not a widely used model with an accompanying set of assumptions that is the focal point of this literature, a situation that contrasts with the cross-section setting, where there are several commonly used sets of assumptions such as unconfounded treatment assignment and overlap in the distribution of propensity scores. The panel data literature most commonly relies on estimators that are justified at least in part by functional form assumptions, but the precise role of these assumptions has not been fully described. In this paper we propose a model of the data generating process together with a set of conditions under which the conditional expectations of outcomes given unobserved unit and time components are identified, where the conditions do not include functional form restrictions. Thus, our approach is analogous in spirit to the approach taken in the literature on identification of causal effects under the unconfoundedness and overlap assumptions (see e.g. [ 30 ] ). We the extend these results for predictive estimands to the identification of average causal effects and decomposition estimands. The outcome model is a generative structural model that takes the form of a Nonparametric Panel Model (NPM): (1) Y_{it}(0)=g(\alpha_{i},\beta_{t},\varepsilon_{it}),\hskip 142.26378pt{\bf(NFM)}, where the unobserved components \alpha_{i} , \beta_{t} and \varepsilon_{it} may be vector-valued. Our main results rely on several assumptions about these components. First, the sets \{\alpha_{i}\}_{i=1}^{N}, \{\beta_{t}\}_{t=1}^{T}, and \{\varepsilon_{it}\}_{i,t}, are independent of each other. In addition, the \alpha_{i} are independent across units. However, the \beta_{t} and \varepsilon_{it} may be autocorrelated over time, but we assume stationarity of the process. These assumptions are satisfied if g has an additive form, as in the popular Two-Way-Fixed-Effect (TWFE) models, or if it takes the form of a linear factor model. However, much richer models are consistent with this setup. Although we cannot identify the unobserved unit and time components \alpha_{i} and \beta_{t} under our assumptions, we can both identify and consistently estimate the expected value \mu(\alpha_{i},\beta_{t})=\mathbb{E}[Y_{it}|\alpha_{i},\beta_{t}] , which is a key building block for both our average treatment effect and decomposition results. Beyond the generative model, this result relies solely on smoothness and restrictions on the asymptotic sequences. We do so by constructing sets of units {\cal J}(i)\subset\{1,\ldots,N\} with increasing cardinality such that for units j\in{\cal J}(i) in this set the function \mu(\alpha_{j},\beta) is similar to \mu(\alpha_{i},\beta) as a function of \beta . We construct these sets by finding units j such that, for all other units k , the covariance over time between Y_{it} and Y_{kt} is similar to the covariance between Y_{jt} and Y_{kt} . We then estimate \mu_{it} by averaging Y_{jt} for units in such sets {\cal J}(i). For the causal problem, we focus on a setting with a binary treatment W_{it} that affects only unit i in period t (thus ruling effects of the treatment that persist over time). This allows the potential outcomes to be defined in terms of the contemporaneous treatment, Y_{it}(0) and Y_{it}(1) . We focus on identification of the average treatment effect for the treated, (2) \tau\equiv\frac{1}{\sum_{i,t}W_{it}}\sum_{i,t}W_{it}\Bigl(Y_{it}(1)-Y_{it}(0)\Bigr),\hskip 85.35826pt{\bf(ATT)}, although our results can be generalized to other average treatment effects. The primary condition for our result is that conditional on \alpha_{i} and \beta_{t} , assignment to treatment is independent of Y_{it}(0) : (3) W_{it}\perp\!\!\!\perp\ Y_{it}(0)\ \Bigl|\ \alpha_{i},\beta_{t},\hskip 56.9055pt{\bf(Latent\ Factor\ Unconfoundedness)}. In addition we need an overlap condition that the probability of receiving the treatment conditional on \alpha_{i} and \beta_{t} is bounded away from zero. This Latent Factor Unconfoundedness assumption is analogous to unconfoundedness in the cross-section setting. A final condition is that for \mu(\alpha,\beta)\equiv\mathbb{E}[Y_{it}|\alpha_{i}=\alpha,\beta] , \mathbb{E}_{\beta}[\mu(\alpha,\beta)-\mu(\alpha^{\prime},\beta))^{2}]=0 implies \alpha=\alpha^{\prime} . Our main result for the treatment effect setting is that given sufficient smoothness on g(\cdot) , the average effect for the treated \tau is identified in this setting when both T and N go to infinity. In addition to causal problems, the methods may also be applied to other purely predictive problems that rely on identification and estimation of \mu_{it} . One such category of problems is decomposition of a difference in outcomes (e.g. by demographic group or other categorization) into explained and unexplained components, as is common in the literature on gender wage gaps [ 15 ] . We develop this application further in Section 6 . Related Literature There are a number of distinct literatures that the current paper builds on. One is the econometric literature on panel data. Much of this literature has focused on Two-Way-Fixed-Effect (TWFE) models and related Difference-In-Differences (DID) estimators, and more recently linear factor models [ 11 ] . See [ 19 , 7 , 10 , 12 , 28 , 39 , 3 ] for textbook discussions and [ 8 , 37 ] for recent surveys. Extensions allowing for nonlinear functions of linear factor models are considered in [ 18 , 40 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 41 , 2 ] . The current study is also related to the literature on synthetic control methods, [ 6 , 5 , 4 , 1 , 33 , 26 ] . In that literature the generative models are often not specified explicitly, with the focus on algorithms that lead to effective estimators. Another literature that is relevant is the research on row and column exchangeable arrays, see [ 9 , 34 , 35 ] . Nonparametric models motivated by the double exchangeability have been considered in network settings, where they are referred to as graphons. The focus in this literature is on estimating the conditional probability of links between nodes in the network, assuming the probability depends in an unrestricted way on unit specific components for both nodes. See for key insights [ 13 , 14 , 42 , 27 , 20 ] . Very relevant is also the work by [ 17 , 16 , 21 ] on grouped heterogeneity. In this line of work units are grouped through k-means clustering so that units in the same group have the same values for the unobserved unit components. Set Up We are interested in estimating causal effects in a panel data setting. We focus on a setting with a binary treatment, with {\bf W} the N\times T matrix of treaments, with typical element W_{it}\in\{0,1\} . There are two matrices of potential outcomes {\bf Y}(0) and {\bf Y}(1) . We observe the matrix of realized outcomes {\bf Y} with typical element Y_{it}=Y_{it}(W_{it}) . This notation already imposes the stable unit treatment values assumption or SUTVA [

Read the complete text