Distorting the Top Resonance with Effective Interactions Preprint: DESY-25-044 Preprint: IPPP/25/16
Felix Egle, Christoph Englert, Margarete Mühlleitner, Michael Spannowsky · 2025
Read Distorting the Top Resonance with Effective Interactions Preprint: DESY-25-044 Preprint: IPPP/25/16 by Felix Egle, Christoph Englert, Margarete Mühlleitner, Michael Spannowsky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19841.txt.
Introduction
Felix Egle and three co-authors wrote this 2025 arXiv paper on how new physics could quietly bend a familiar particle signal. Searches for physics beyond the Standard Model often use effective interactions, and their interference with known processes can distort the very resonance peaks analysts rely on. The team studied top quark pairs at the Large Hadron Collider, where certain four-fermion interactions meet the top resonance.
Their calculations show the interactions reshape the peak region about as strongly as they raise the rare high-energy tail that searches usually target. That mismatch could sow tension between data regions. Unfortunately, they find the distortion is likely too subtle for even the high-luminosity collider to catch with current strategies. At a future lepton collider, though, precision could make resonance shapes a real probe. The authors urge global analyses to model the shapes, not just count the tails.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Felix Egle, Christoph Englert, Margarete Mühlleitner, Michael Spannowsky |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19841
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Distorting the Top Resonance with Effective Interactions Preprint: DESY-25-044 Preprint: IPPP/25/16 Preprint: KA-TP-07-2025 Felix Egle, Christoph Englert, Margarete Mühlleitner, Michael Spannowsky Abstract Interference effects in effective field theory (EFT) analyses can significantly distort sensitivity expectations, leaving subtle yet distinct signatures in the reconstruction of final states crucial for limit setting around Standard Model predictions. Using the specific example of four-fermion operators in top-quark pair production at the LHC, we provide a detailed quantitative assessment of these resonance distortions. We explore how continuum four-fermion interactions affect the resonance shapes, creating potential tensions between the high-statistics resonance regions and rare, high momentum-transfer continuum excesses. Our findings indicate that although four-fermion interactions do modify the on-shell region comparably to continuum enhancements, current experimental strategies at the High-Luminosity LHC are unlikely to capture these subtle interference-induced distortions. Nonetheless, such effects could become critical for precision analyses at future lepton colliders, such as the FCC-ee. Our work underscores the importance of resonance-shape measurements as complementary probes in global EFT approaches, guiding robust and self-consistent experimental strategies in ongoing and future high-energy physics programmes. I Introduction Effective field theory (EFT) Weinberg 1979 ; Georgi 1991 is increasingly becoming the new standard for framing the sensitivity to new physics interactions under well-defined theoretical assumptions. From the first proof-of-principle analyses, this has evolved into a cohesive programme spanning many different processes to obtain a global picture, including efforts by the experiments directly. Many approaches to setting constraints on process-relevant interactions rely on a good knowledge of relevant SM correlations to extract the SM null hypothesis used for setting limits. When considering EFT deformations of the SM, this issue is further highlighted by the presence of non-resonant, non-SM contributions, which can lead to interference-related distortions of SM particle thresholds, e.g. through changing the line profile of intermediate unstable particles such as the top quark or the W boson when reconstructed from their decay products. This can implicitly affect any EFT analysis at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and future facilities and needs to be contrasted with direct BSM-related modifications of the particles’ resonance shapes directly. Turning to analyses of top final states Buckley et al. 2016 ; Hartland et al. 2019 ; Brivio et al. 2020 ; Bißmann et al. 2021 ; Ethier et al. 2021 ; Garosi et al. 2023 , the relevance (and limitations) of top-pole measurements are well-documented in the literature. In the SM, non-perturbative effects Beneke and Braun 1994 ; Bigi et al. 1994 are known to create systematic complications in extracting the top quark mass, chiefly from the analysis of top pair final states with a large abundance at the LHC. When turning to EFT modifications and, importantly, to new irreducible contributions to the amplitude of these final states, interference effects can enter the pp\to\bar{t}t alongside the top quark decay. More concretely, the extraction of the top threshold that fundamentally underpins any signal-vs-background analysis of a t\bar{t} system may be impacted by the presence of new physics contributions, e.g. by how much contact interactions in the vicinity of the W threshold sculpt the kinematic correlations used to “tag” the top quark. Concretely, the squared SM-like matrix element in the vicinity of a resonance is well-described for widths \Gamma\ll m by a Breit-Wigner distribution {\cal{M}}_{\text{SM}}\underset{s\simeq m^{2}}{\simeq}{1\over s-m^{2}+i\Gamma m} (1) in the vicinity of the resonance mass for a relevant kinematic distribution s . Any additional, approximately constant contribution {\cal{M}}_{\text{BSM}} for s\simeq m^{2} therefore ‘tilts’ the Breit-Wigner at interference-level \text{d}\sigma\sim\,2\,\text{Re}({\cal{M}}_{\text{SM}}{\cal{M}}_{\text{BSM}}^{\ast}) . In doing so, the Breit-Wigner suppression can be numerically mitigated, however, it will decouple as a function of the SM width and the mass scale of the BSM theory \Lambda , see Fig. 1 . * * * Such effects have been discussed in the literature in the SM (for a recent review see e.g. Dreiner et al. 2010 ; Denner and Dittmaier 2020 including discussions of scheme dependencies). The fact that such interference effects can severely impact and limit the experimental sensitivity to new physics is well-established in searches for exotic Higgs bosons Gaemers and Hoogeveen 1984 ; Jung et al. 2015 ; Hespel et al. 2016 ; Basler et al. 2020 , which drives experimental searches, cf. e.g. Aaboud et al. 2017 . Figure 1: Representative normalised Breit-Wigner distribution for the W mass of (m_{W},\Gamma_{W})\approx(80.4,2.08)~\text{GeV} . The Breit-Wigner suppression of the differential cross section is comparable with a loop suppression of a new physics contribution, which is assumed to be constant here. A phenomenologically relevant question therefore arises: Can effective contributions affect the reconstruction of SM candles which are used to set constraints on these interactions in the first place? If the answer to this question were yes, such modifications would enable a process-specific test for new physics from reconstructed SM particle thresholds at the price of increased experimental complexity in defining the SM null hypothesis. A sizeable effect could also, in part, address the anomalous measurement of the W mass as observed by the CDF collaboration Aaltonen et al. 2022 and open up new possibilities for new physics searches at future precision facilities, such as an FCC-ee. Of course, any such new contribution might also be visible in the tails as a function of s . In the case of, e.g., four-fermion interactions, these effects are even kinematically enhanced. Therefore, it is not clear whether the limit setting from distribution tails is already constraining enough to render on-shell modifications (beyond total width and, hence, branching ratio fits) relevant. This note aims to reach a quantitative estimate of these effects within the SMEFT Grzadkowski et al. 2010 framework. We focus on the t\bar{t} final state as it is one of the most abundant processes at the LHC and, therefore, prone to provide good a priori sensitivity to SMEFT relevant deformations. We organise this work as follows: In Sec. II , we provide a short overview of our analysis setup before we consider representative effects in detail in Sec. III . Section IV provides a summary and conclusions with a positive message for the experimental community: We gather evidence that within the limits observed from tails, no significant on-shell distortion is observed. Current approaches can therefore be considered self-consistent and robust. II Elements of the Analysis In this study, we use the SMEFT framework at dimension six Grzadkowski et al. 2010 {\cal{L}}={\cal{L}}_{\text{SM}}+\sum_{i}{c_{i}\over\Lambda^{2}}O_{i}\,, (2) where O_{i} denote the dimension-six operators and \Lambda the new physics scale, to investigate the influence of new physics on top quark pair production at the LHC. In our analysis, we isolate the contributions from new EFT physics by adjusting the Wilson coefficients c_{i} . Only one Wilson coefficient was set to a non-zero value at a time (which enables a full fit at interference level between \langle{\cal{L}}_{\text{SM}}\rangle and \langle O_{i}\rangle ), allowing us to disentangle the effects of individual operators. For the generation of our event samples we employ MadGraph_aMC@NLO Alwall et al. 2014 together with SMEFTsim3.0.2 Brivio 2021 . In practice, we generate around 2 million events for the SM as well as 1 million events for the EFT operator interference (we comment on the so-called quadratic dimension-six effects below), which is enough statistics for a smooth extrapolation to the high-luminosity phase of the LHC (3/ab) whilst capturing subtle