Intrinsic back-switching phenomenon in SOT-MRAM devices
Kuldeep Ray, Jérémie Vigier, Perrine Usé, Sylvain Martin, Nicolas Lefoulon, Chloé Bouard, Marc Drouard, Gilles Gaudin · 2025
Read Intrinsic back-switching phenomenon in SOT-MRAM devices by Kuldeep Ray, Jérémie Vigier, Perrine Usé, Sylvain Martin, Nicolas Lefoulon, Chloé Bouard, Marc Drouard, Gilles Gaudin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19840.txt.
Introduction
Kuldeep Ray, Gilles Gaudin and their co-authors study back-switching in spin-orbit torque memory devices in 2025. Writing in these devices is meant to be reliable with a symmetry-breaking field, yet at high currents the write chance can fall to zero or oscillate.
The team tested tiny magnetic pillars on Hall crosses and varied pulse strength and field direction in a systematic way. Back-switching proved not to be random in its pattern. Computer models with realistic values matched the lab results and pointed to the cause. Shaping the write pulses eased the problem, and full memory cells reached very low write error rates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kuldeep Ray, Jérémie Vigier, Perrine Usé, Sylvain Martin, Nicolas Lefoulon, Chloé Bouard, Marc Drouard, Gilles Gaudin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19840
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Intrinsic back-switching phenomenon in SOT-MRAM devices Kuldeep Ray, Jérémie Vigier, Perrine Usé, Sylvain Martin, Nicolas Lefoulon, Chloé Bouard, Marc Drouard, Gilles Gaudin Abstract The writing process of SOT-MRAMs is considered deterministic when additional symmetry-breaking factors, such as the application of an external magnetic field aligned with the current, are present. Notably, the write probability exhibits a unique behavior as a function of the current: it drops to zero at high currents or even oscillates with the current. This phenomenon is attributed to back-switching, an intrinsic effect of magnetization reversal driven by spin-orbit torques. A systematic investigation of this back-switching phenomenon is conducted on sub-100 nm CoFeB magnetic pillars positioned at the center of β \beta -W Hall crosses. Using a statistical approach, the study examines the impact of various parameters, including the amplitude of current pulses and the application of magnetic fields in different directions. The findings reveal that the back-switching phenomenon is not statistically random. Macrospin simulations, employing realistic magnetic parameter values, accurately replicate the experimental observations and provide insights into the underlying mechanisms of back-switching. These simulations also explore strategies to mitigate the phenomenon, such as optimizing the shape of the writing pulses. Applying this approach to complete SOT-MRAM single cells achieves a write error rate below 2 × 10 − 6 2\times 10^{{-6}} , demonstrating the effectiveness of this strategy in expanding the operational current range for write operations in SOT-MRAMs. I Introduction Magnetic random-access memories (MRAMs) are considered one of the most promising replacements for volatile CMOS memory technologies across all levels of the memory hierarchy. Among the latest generations of MRAMs, spin-orbit torque MRAMs (SOT-MRAMs) are particularly attractive for replacing memories closest to the processing units, as they combine high endurance with sub-nanosecond switching times [ 24 , 26 ] . Nevertheless, while spin transfer torque MRAMs (STT-MRAMs) are commercially available [ 28 ] , SOT-MRAMs must overcome several challenges before they can be adopted by the industry [ 26 ] . One of these major challenges is to achieve deterministic switching, meaning reliably controlling the result of the write operation, over a wide current range. The key metric for deterministic switching is the write error rate, which measures the probability of getting the expected final state after a write operation. In SOT-MRAM technology with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy, which is the most promising solution in terms of scaling, density and data retention, magnetization switching by means of spin-orbit current alone is not deterministic. Indeed, by symmetry, the probabilities of obtaining an ”up” or ”down” magnetization are equal. An additional factor to break this symmetry is required. In early implementations, this breaking of symmetry was induced by the application of an in-plane magnetic field, collinear with the current but external to the system [ 22 , 4 , 19 ] . As this solution is not suitable for embedded applications, a number of propositions have been published in recent years, aimed at developing deterministic and integrated ”field-free” SOT-MRAM cells, based on tilted anisotropy [ 37 ] , combination of SOT and STT effects [ 3 ] , exchange bias [ 34 ] , embedded magnet in the material stack [ 9 ] and unconventional torques from new materials [ 11 ] (for a more complete list, please consult review articles such as [ 15 ] ). However, the presence of symmetry breaking does not guarantee a perfectly deterministic reversal of magnetization, and consequently a deterministic writing. It has been observed that increasing the write current beyond the threshold for reversal leads, as expected, to an increase in the probability of magnetization switching. However, if the current is increased further, the probability then decreases and may even oscillate as a function of the applied current [ 16 , 36 , 5 ] . Similar back-switching (BSW) phenomenon has previously been observed and studied in STT-MRAMs [ 21 ] . One origin of this phenomenon has been attributed to the instability of the reference layer magnetization in magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJ), an instability that can even lead to the reversal of this magnetization [ 13 , 6 ] . In SOT-MRAMs, magnetization is switched by means of a current injected in the plane of the layers [ 22 , 19 ] , without the need for an MTJ-type structure to obtain a spin-polarized current. Observation of the back-switching phenomenon in simple structures, such as non-magnetic/ferromagnetic/insulator trilayer stacks, demonstrates that in SOT-MRAM this BSW is intrinsic to the magnetization dynamics induced by spin-orbit torques and not related to the dynamics of the reference layer. This BSW phenomenon is a challenge for the efficient design of memories based on SOT-MRAMs (Fig. 1 (a)). Its study is essential to our understanding of the magnetization dynamics induced by spin-orbit torques, and for finding effective means of mitigating BSW in SOT-MRAMs. Figure 1: (a) To design a memory array, the statistical variation in device properties must be taken into account. To ensure reliable writing, the distribution of the current supplied by the write transistor (I {}_{\text{Transistor}} ) should be higher than the distribution of SOT-MRAM write current (I {}_{\text{Write}} ) and should not overlap with the distribution of the current inducing a back-switching phenomenon (I {}_{\text{Back-switching}} ). Ideally, I {}_{\text{Transistor}} should be in the middle of I {}_{\text{Write}} and I {}_{\text{Back-switching}} . (b) A schematic representation of the studied magnetic stack and the device used for electrical measurements is shown: a magnetic pillar patterned onto a \beta -tungsten Hall cross (see the representative SEM image). The applied writing current I {}_{\text{SOT}} is injected through the longitudinal arms of the Hall cross, while the anomalous Hall voltage is measured across the transverse arms. H {}_{\text{X}} , H {}_{\text{Y}} , and H {}_{\text{Z}} denote the applied magnetic field components along the respective axes. Despite its importance, relatively few studies have been devoted to it. Most are numerical studies based on macrospin simulations. The existence of this BSW phenomenon was reported as early as the first macrospin SOT switching simulations, whether with or without the Field-Like (FL) term [ 17 , 23 ] . The importance and the role of the FL term on the BSW phenomenon were then highlighted [ 18 , 31 , 38 ] . The existence of this BSW phenomenon has been explained by energy arguments: at the end of the write current pulse, if the energy of the system is higher than the saddle point energy, the magnetization will relax in either a first potential well corresponding to a first direction of magnetization or in the other corresponding to the opposite state of magnetization [ 23 , 31 ] . This explains the high sensitivity of the phenomenon to damping, as reported in particular by [ 17 , 23 , 30 ] . Experimentally, this phenomenon has been reported in some publications - for example, in Pt/Co/AlO {}_{\text{X}} layers, where the magnetization is reported to switch back to its original orientation above a certain threshold of applied planar magnetic field [ 5 ] ; or in Ta/CoFeB/MgO-based magnetic tunnel junctions, where a decrease in the probability of the magnetization switching is observed when the write current is increased [ 14 ] . Only two publications from the same group report a