Cell differentiation can underpin the reproducibility of morphogenesis
Dominic Devlin, Austen RD Ganley, Nobuto Takeuchi · 2025
Read Cell differentiation can underpin the reproducibility of morphogenesis by Dominic Devlin, Austen RD Ganley, Nobuto Takeuchi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19375.txt.
Introduction
Dominic Devlin, Austen Ganley, and Nobuto Takeuchi wrote a 2025 paper on why growing bodies end up the same shape each time. Body building, called morphogenesis, is noisy at the cell level. Yet embryos of one species grow into near-identical forms, and the source of that steadiness was unclear.
The team built a computer model that evolves complex shapes on its own. Many evolved shapes turned out steady across runs, though nothing pushed for steadiness. The trick was a split of labor among cells. Mover cells shape the form, while still cells hold it in place. That split, called cell differentiation, pins the shape down. The finding hints at why real embryos differ into cell types so early.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dominic Devlin, Austen RD Ganley, Nobuto Takeuchi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 123 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19375
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cell differentiation can underpin the reproducibility of morphogenesis Dominic Devlin, Austen RD Ganley, Nobuto Takeuchi Abstract Summary Morphogenesis of complex body shapes is reproducible despite the noise inherent in the underlying morphogenetic processes. However, how these morphogenetic processes work together to achieve this reproducibility remains unclear. Here, we ask how morphogenetic reproducibility is realised by developing a computational model that evolves complex morphologies. We find that evolved, complex morphologies are reproducible in a sizeable fraction of simulations, despite no direct selection for reproducibility. We show that high reproducibility is caused by segregating moving cells that “shape” morphologies from stationary cells that “maintain” morphologies during morphogenesis. Strikingly, most highly reproducible morphologies also evolved cell differentiation, where proliferative, moving stem cells (i.e., progenitor cells) irreversibly differentiate into non-dividing, stationary differentiated cells. These results suggest that cell differentiation observed in natural development plays a fundamental role in morphogenesis in addition to the production of specialised cell types. This previously-unrecognised role of cell differentiation has major implications for our understanding of how morphologies are generated and regenerated. 1 Introduction Morphogenesis is the multifaceted process that transforms relatively homogeneous starting materials—such as a zygote or fields of progenitor cells—into the complex morphological structures, such as organs, tissues and appendages, that constitute a mature organism Hogan (1999) ; Wolpert et al. (2015) . This transformation occurs through a combination of chemical-level pattern formation and cellular-level shape formation Goodwin et al. (1993) ; Kauffman and others (1993) . At the chemical level, reacting and diffusing chemicals produce spatial patterns, such as stripes and segments Tautz (2004) ; Staps et al. (2023) . At the cellular-level, processes such as cell motion, division, contraction and differential adhesion interact with chemical-level pattern formation to produce morphological shapes, such as tails, tubes, branches and limbs Hogan (1999) ; Wolpert et al. (2015) ; Zuniga (2015) ; Iruela-Arispe and Beitel (2013) ; Miao et al. (2023) . For extant animals, the morphological structures produced by these processes are not only complex, but also reproduced across generations. Understanding how complex morphogenesis is made reproducible has intrigued the minds of thinkers since Pythagoras and Aristotle Aristotle (1984) , and is a focal point of developmental biology Kauffman and others (1993) ; Félix and Barkoulas (2015) ; Green et al. (2017) ; Osterwalder et al. (2018) . The reproducibility of morphogenesis requires both cell-level and chemical-level processes to be robust to noise Swain et al. (2002) ; Tsimring (2014) . Much attention has been devoted to understanding the robustness of chemical-level pattern formation to molecular sources of noise, such as fluctuations in chemical concentrations Briscoe and Small (2015) , resulting in the characterisation of chemical-level processes that enhance pattern reproducibility, such as genetic feedback loops and signal transduction pathways Crampin et al. (1999) ; Freeman (2000) ; Eldar et al. (2002) ; Kitano (2004) ; Rogers and Schier (2011) ; Madamanchi et al. (2021) ; Reinitz et al. (2023) ; Majka et al. (2024) . In contrast, much less is known about the cellular processes underlying the robustness of morphogenesis to cell-level sources of noise, such as stochasticity in the motion and geometry of cells Gilmour et al. (2017) . To address this issue, previous studies have taken a targeted approach in which they selected a set of cell-level processes, such as cell-cell signalling and adhesion between cell types, and examined each process to determine whether it increases morphogenetic reproducibility Hagolani et al. (2019) ; Cano-Fernández et al. (2023) . Here, we instead asked whether morphogenetic reproducibility is an emergent by-product of morphogenesis that evolves even if reproducibility is not explicitly selected for, and, if so, how this reproducibility is realised—a non-prescriptive approach developed by Hogeweg, Ten Tusscher & Vroomans Hogeweg (1998) ; Hogeweg (2000a) ; Hogeweg (2000b) ; Ten Tusscher and Hogeweg (2011) ; Vroomans et al. (2016) ; Vroomans et al. (2018) . To determine whether reproducibility is a by-product of morphogenesis, we computationally generated an ensemble of “morphogeneses” by repeatedly evolving a population of morphologies selected for geometrically complex, multicellular shapes. We found that a sizeable fraction of evolved morphologies had high reproducibility, even though reproducibility was not explicitly selected. Strikingly, these morphologies shared one cell-level feature responsible for morphogenetic reproducibility: a “morphogenetic division of labour”, where moving and dividing progenitor cells “shape” morphologies, while non-moving and non-dividing differentiated cells spatially “anchor” this shaping process, thereby enhancing morphogenetic reproducibility. 2 Results 2.1 Multi-scale model We set out to investigate whether complex, evolvable morphogenesis is intrinsically reproducible by constructing a deliberately simplified model of real morphogenesis. To capture the noisy dynamics of real morphogenesis, we employed the Cellular Potts Model (CPM), which uses a Metropolis algorithm to simulate stochastic cell motion and cell shape dynamics (Methods 4.1 ) Graner and Glazier (1992) ; Hirashima et al. (2017) . The CPM models the development of a group of cells on a two-dimensional square grid ( 250\times 250 pixels). Each group of cells on the CPM grid represents a segment of developing tissue that we term a “morphology”. Each cell of a morphology consists of a collection of neighbouring pixels on the grid (Fig. 1 A). Pixels not occupied by cells represent the medium (Fig. 1 A), which is akin to an extracellular matrix or fluid Rozario and DeSimone (2010) . Cell motion occurs through stochastic extensions and retractions of cell boundaries that are generated by pixel copying at these boundaries (Fig. 1 A; Methods 4.1 ). Pixels on the grid are chosen in a random order with replacement for copy attempts. The unit of time is the number of pixel copy attempts equal to the total number of pixels on the grid, hereafter referred to as a developmental time step (DTS). The probability that a pixel copy occurs is determined by the minimisation of free energy arising from cell-cell adhesion, cell-medium adhesion, cell shape and cell size, as described later. Figure 1: Multi-scale model of morphogenesis evolution. A Three neighbouring cells on a CPM grid. A cell consists of one or more pixels. Each cell is coloured by its “cell state” defined by the concentrations of all its proteins converted to boolean values (the medium is represented by white pixels). Pixels with alternating stripes indicate pixel copies at cell boundaries. Each cell contains a genome that encodes transcription factors (TFs; circles, squares, triangles), adhesion proteins (sticks with a lock or key) and membrane tension proteins (not shown). Arrows indicate regulation of gene expression by TFs (arrow head for activation, blunt head for inhibition). Double harpoon arrows indicate diffusion of morphogens (membrane-permeable TFs). B Adhesion proteins facilitate the binding of cells to each other via a lock and key mechanism, or to the surrounding medium (not shown). C . A population consists of 60 morphologies (only three depicted). Morphologies undergo a developmental phase on separate CPM grids for 12,000 DTS, and then a reproduction phase, where morphologies with complex shapes are selected. Reproduction can occur without mutation (black arrows) or with mutation (orange arrow), with mutation determined probabilistically. Mutations change the topology of the GRN (dashed orange arrow), with the example showing a change from inhibition of gene y by gene x to activation of gene y by gene x . DE Illustration of the