Deep Learning approaches for nuclear binding energy prediction: A comparative study of RNN, GRU and LSTM Models
Amir Jalili 1, Feng Pan 2,3, Ai Xi Chen 1, Jerry P. Draayer 3 · 2025
Read Deep Learning approaches for nuclear binding energy prediction: A comparative study of RNN, GRU and LSTM Models by Amir Jalili 1, Feng Pan 2,3, Ai Xi Chen 1, Jerry P. Draayer 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19348.txt.
Introduction
Amir Jalili, Feng Pan, Ai Xi Chen, and Jerry Draayer predict nuclear binding energies in two thousand twenty-five. Three deep learning models face off on the task. Recurrent nets, gated recurrent units, and long short term memory nets compete. Data come from the Atomic Mass Evaluation of twenty twenty.
Inputs span proton and neutron counts plus liquid drop terms. Shell effect terms join the feature set as well. The gated recurrent unit wins with the lowest error score. Garvey-Kelson checks confirm the predictions hold up well. Extrapolation tests near the driplines stay robust too. Deep learning thus strengthens classic nuclear models.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amir Jalili 1, Feng Pan 2,3, Ai Xi Chen 1, Jerry P. Draayer 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19348
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deep Learning approaches for nuclear binding energy prediction: A comparative study of RNN, GRU and LSTM Models Amir Jalili 1, Feng Pan 2,3, Ai Xi Chen 1, Jerry P. Draayer 3 Abstract This study investigates the application of deep learning models-recurrent neural networks, gated recurrent units, and long short-term memory networks-for predicting nuclear binding energies. Utilizing data from the Atomic Mass Evaluation (AME2020), we incorporate key nuclear structure features, including proton and neutron numbers, as well as additional terms from the liquid drop model and shell effects. Our comparative analysis demonstrates that the gated recurrent units model achieves the lowest root-mean-square error ( σ RMSE \sigma_{\mathrm{RMSE}} ) of 0.326 MeV, surpassing traditional regression-based approaches. To assess model reliability, we validate predictions using the Garvey-Kelson relations, obtaining an error of 0.202 MeV, and further test extrapolation capabilities using the WS, WS3, and WS4 models. The extrapolation analysis confirms the robustness of our approach, particularly in predicting binding energies for nuclei near the driplines. These results highlight the effectiveness of deep learning in nuclear BE predictions, highlighting its potential to enhance the accuracy and reliability of theoretical nuclear models. I Introduction The precise determination of nuclear binding energy (BE) is crucial for understanding the stability and structure of atomic nuclei, as well as the fundamental interactions that govern them. Traditional global models, such as the liquid drop model (LDM) ldm and the Bethe-Weizsäcker (BW) formula ws1 ; ws2 , have long served as the foundation for nuclear mass predictions. While subsequent refinements, including the finite-range droplet model (FRDM) mol and Weizsäcker-Skyrme (WS) model ws4 , have improved predictive accuracy, significant discrepancies persist, particularly near the nuclear drip lines. Different kinds of nuclear mass models have been developed to incorporate more effects, which are known microscopic mass models based on the relativistic r1 ; r2 ; r3 ; r4 ; r5 ; r6 ; r7 ; r8 ; r9 ; r10 ; r11 , and nonrelativistic density functionals with other theoretical models n1 ; n2 ; n3 ; n4 ; n5 ; n6 ; n7 ; n8 ; n9 ; n10 . These challenges necessitate the exploration of alternative approaches that can effectively capture the complex nonlinear dependencies within nuclear data. Theoretical models for nuclear mass predictions can generally be categorized into two main types: global models and local models l1 ; l2 ; l3 ; l4 . Global theoretical models, such as macroscopic-microscopic approaches and nuclear density functional theories pw , aim to describe nuclear masses across the entire nuclear chart by utilizing a unified theoretical framework. While these models provide valuable insights into nuclear structure and large-scale trends, their accuracy may vary in regions where experimental data are scarce. In contrast, local models rely on the assumption of strong correlations between neighboring nuclei and establish predictive relationships based on known experimental masses. These approaches, often referred to as local-type theoretical models, have distinct advantages in regions where experimental data are available, as they can achieve higher predictive accuracy by using well-established nuclear interactions. Among the most notable local models is the Garvey-Kelson (GK) relation gk1 ; gk2 ; gk3 ; gk4 , which exploits linear mass relationships between neighboring nuclei to estimate unknown masses with remarkable precision. Another widely used local approach is the neutron-proton interaction-based mass relation, which incorporates the effects of nucleon interactions to refine mass predictions. Due to their reliance on empirical data, local models demonstrate exceptional accuracy within experimentally known regions. For instance, the GK relation and similar mass relations typically achieve an accuracy of approximately 0.2 MeV l3 , significantly outperforming many global models in these well-characterized regions. However, their extrapolation capabilities are inherently limited, making them less reliable for predicting masses far from experimentally measured nuclei. Consequently, the integration of both global and local models, along with advanced machine learning (ML) techniques, presents a promising avenue for enhancing the precision and robustness of nuclear mass predictions across the entire nuclear landscape. In this paper, we will extend our analysis by testing and evaluating our models using the GK relations, further assessing their reliability and accuracy in predicting nuclear BE. In recent years, ML and deep learning (DL) techniques have emerged as powerful tools for nuclear physics applications, enabling accurate predictions of various nuclear properties. In recent years, neural networks (NN) with various algorithms, along with advanced ML techniques, have been successfully applied to nuclear physics studies boe ; wu . Examples include convolutional NNs lu , support vector machines yuk , and Kolmogorov-Arnold networks ren . Additionally, several NN-based models have been employed for predicting nuclear properties, such as binding energies liu ; niu1 ; zhao ; xie ; niu2 ; gao ; liu2 ; uta ; lov ; zeng ; zhang ; mum , energy spectra he ; wang2 , charge radii jalili1 ; dong ; wu6 , \alpha -decay half-lives li ; jalili2 , and \beta -decay half-lives jalili3 ; niu3 , among others wu7 ; shang1 ; shang2 ; za . Furthermore, kernel ridge regression has been applied for nuclear mass predictions, demonstrating its effectiveness in refining mass models and improving predictive accuracy wu1 ; wu2 ; wu5 . These advancements underscore the increasing role of ML in nuclear physics, providing robust and data-driven approaches for modeling complex nuclear phenomena. Their ability to analyze complex patterns within large datasets has significantly enhanced our understanding of nuclear structure and decay processes, offering new insights beyond traditional theoretical models. Unlike conventional models that rely on predefined functional forms, ML-based methods can extract intricate patterns from large datasets, enabling improved generalization and predictive performance. Among these, recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and their variants-gated recurrent units (GRUs) and long short-term memory (LSTM) networks-are particularly well-suited for sequential data modeling, making them promising candidates for nuclear properties predictions rnn1 ; rnn2 ; rnn3 ; rnn4 ; gru ; lstm . The advantage of RNNs stems from their feedback mechanism, which allows them to retain memory of previous inputs, effectively capturing long-range correlations in nuclear structure. In this study, we employ RNN-based architectures to predict nuclear BE using data from the Atomic Mass Evaluation (AME2020) ame . Our approach integrates nuclear structure features derived from the BW formula, including volume, surface, Coulomb, and pairing terms, alongside shell effects. By dynamically learning weights and feature interactions, our models surpass conventional regression-based approaches. The results demonstrate that GRUs achieve the lowest \sigma_{\mathrm{RMSE}} of 0.326 MeV, significantly outperforming traditional models. To further validate our predictions, we apply the GK relations, which are highly accurate in regions where experimental data are available. To evaluate the reliability of our approach, we embed the mass predictions from three different RNN models into the GK relations and obtain an error of approximately 0.202 MeV for the GRU case. This confirms the effectiveness of DL models in capturing nuclear mass trends with high precision. Given that more than 11,000 nuclei require extrapolation, DL algorithms provide a powerful tool for extending nuclear BE predictions into unmeasured regions. Additionally, we investigate the extrapolation capabilities of our models in regions where experimental data are unavailable. Our study considers the WS ws , WS3 ws3 , and WS4 ws4 models with both relu and tanh activation functions, ensuring the reliability