A cryogenic test-mass suspension with flexures operating in compression for third-generation gravitational-wave detectors

Fabián E. Peña Arellano, Nelson L. Leon, Leonardo González López, Riccardo DeSalvo, Harry Themann, Esra Zerina Appavuravther, Guerino Avallone, Francesca Badaracco, Mark A. Barton, Alessandro Bertolini, Christian Chavez, Andy Damas, Richard Damas, Britney Gallego, Eric Hennes, Gerardo Iannone, Seth · 2025

Read A cryogenic test-mass suspension with flexures operating in compression for third-generation gravitational-wave detectors by Fabián E. Peña Arellano, Nelson L. Leon, Leonardo González López, Riccardo DeSalvo, Harry Themann, Esra Zerina Appavuravther, Guerino Avallone, Francesca Badaracco, Mark A. Barton, Alessandro Bertolini, Christian Chavez, Andy Damas, Richard Damas, Britney Gallego, Eric Hennes, Gerardo Iannone, Seth (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-19169.txt.

Introduction

Fabián Peña Arellano and co-authors present an engineering design paper, published in 2025, on hanging the mirrors of the next great gravitational wave observatory. The Einstein Telescope's low frequency detector needs its test masses cold and quiet, but ordinary suspensions pull with tension, which brings noise, weak margins, and poor heat flow all at once. The team's silicon design turns the problem sideways.

Rigid beams with wide cross sections carry the load, joined by short flexures squeezed in compression, where silicon is many times stronger than in tension. The flexures stay soft in the working direction, so thermal noise stays low, and their shortness conducts heat away for cryogenic cooling. The paper analyzes the concept for the observatory's cryogenic mirrors.

Catalog record

CREATORFabián E. Peña Arellano, Nelson L. Leon, Leonardo González López, Riccardo DeSalvo, Harry Themann, Esra Zerina Appavuravther, Guerino Avallone, Francesca Badaracco, Mark A. Barton, Alessandro Bertolini, Christian Chavez, Andy Damas, Richard Damas, Britney Gallego, Eric Hennes, Gerardo Iannone, Seth
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-19169

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A cryogenic test-mass suspension with flexures operating in compression for third-generation gravitational-wave detectors Fabián E. Peña Arellano, Nelson L. Leon, Leonardo González López, Riccardo DeSalvo, Harry Themann, Esra Zerina Appavuravther, Guerino Avallone, Francesca Badaracco, Mark A. Barton, Alessandro Bertolini, Christian Chavez, Andy Damas, Richard Damas, Britney Gallego, Eric Hennes, Gerardo Iannone, Seth Linker, Marina Mondin, Claudia Moreno, Kevin Pang, Stefano Selleri, Mynor Soto, Flavio Travasso, Joris Van-Heijningen, Fernando Velez, Morgane Zeoli Abstract This paper presents an analysis of the conceptual design of a novel silicon suspension for the cryogenic test-mass mirrors of the low-frequency detector of the Einstein Telescope gravitational-wave observatory. In traditional suspensions, tensional stress is a severe limitation for achieving low thermal noise, safer mechanical margins and high thermal conductance simultaneously. In order to keep the tensional stress sufficiently low, we propose the use of rigid beams with large cross sections, combined with short flexures under compressional load. This configuration takes advantage of the many times higher strength of silicon in compression to respect to its strength in tension. The flexures are mechanically robust and at the same time soft in the working direction, thus producing low suspension thermal noise and, by being short, provide high thermal conductance for cryogenic cooling. The rigid beams, located between the test mass and an intermediate mass, allow the elimination of the recoil mass used conventionally for applying control forces for interferometer lock, and the use of optical anti-springs to reduce the pendulum resonant frequency to further improve the vibration isolation of the test mass. The configuration has the capability to reach a lower mirror operational temperature, which is expected to produce a substantial reduction of the thermal noise in the mirrors of the interferometer. January 2025 1 Introduction The Einstein Telescope (ET) is a project for the construction of a third-generation interferometric gravitational-wave detector. It is being designed to extend the astronomical observation frequency down to a few hertz, to detect inspirals of heavier, intermediate-mass binary back hole coalescences up to cosmological distances, and also to provide early warning for multi-messenger events [ 2 , 3 ] . One of the most difficult requirements is to minimize thermal noise. Because of quantum noise restrictions, the ET will employ two kinds of detectors, a cryogenic one for low-frequency detection and a room temperature one for the high-frequency end. The design configuration proposed here is intended for the cryogenic detector. Thermal noise of the test-mass mirrors and of their suspensions is a fundamental limit to the detector low-frequency sensitivity. Thermal noise refers to the fluctuations of the mirror positions arising from mechanical dissipation at finite temperatures, as described by the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and Levin’s theorem [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . The two strategies considered effective to reduce it are to operate at cryogenic temperatures and to minimize the amount of energy being dissipated in each oscillation. In turn, there are two strategies to reduce the amount of energy that can be dissipated in an oscillating pendulum. The first is to build the suspension with a material that exhibits low intrinsic structural dissipation. The second is to choose a mechanical configuration that minimizes the amount of elastic potential energy, which is the only one exposed to the dissipation process. This requires making the pendulum elastic constant negligible with respect to the gravitational spring constant, using a longer pendulum, or both. The light power stored in the Fabry-Perot cavities is kept low to minimize the radiation pressure noise on the mirrors, but an optical power of 18 kW is still needed to achieve the desired sensitivity [ 7 ] . A tiny fraction of this power is dissipated into heat in the reflective coating of the mirrors and in the substrates of the input test masses. It is anticipated that up to 0.5 W will be dissipated in each of the 200 kg mirrors [ 7 ] . Thermal radiation is negligible at cryogenic temperatures; therefore, the system must be able to extract sufficient heat via thermal conduction to maintain a stable low operational temperature of the suspensions and mirrors. Since the suspension is the only way in which the cryogenic mirror couples mechanically to the external environment, a pendulum is also required to be an effective means for extracting heat from it. A typical structure optimized to extract heat will have a large cross section, a short length, or both [ 8 , eq. 18-32] , making the pendulum rigid and thus increasing the elastic energy stored in the material during oscillations and the suspension thermal noise. Monocrystalline silicon and sapphire have been identified as the best materials for this application due to their low mechanical dissipation and high thermal conductivity at cryogenic temperatures, with silicon being preferred because it is softer with a relatively small Young’s modulus. However, the limited strength of all monocrystalline materials in tension imposes the additional constraint of requiring large cross sections. When subjected to even limited tensional stresses, cleavage along crystalline planes leads to catastrophic failure, with microscopic surface defects being sufficient to initiate the process. Therefore, it is required that crystalline components under tensional or shear stress have sufficiently large cross sections to drastically reduce the tensional stress. This document describes a method to solve this conundrum by taking advantage of the many times higher compressive strength of silicon with respect to its tensile strength [ 9 ] . The key elements are flexures that work in compression [ 10 , p. 70] , and therefore, without the risk of cleavage and capable of withstanding higher stress. These flexures can be thin and, therefore flexible, but also short to allow efficient heat extraction. The values of the strength of silicon used in this paper, 165 and 3200 MPa for tension and compression respectively, are provided by a commercial vendor and are rather conservative [ 9 ] , for they likely correspond to unpolished samples [ 9 ] . In recent months, within the ET Collaboration, innovative techniques of manufacturing [ 11 ] and polishing have been developed, increasing the strength of silicon rods in tension. Some gain may be expected for compressive strength as well, because surface defects may also trigger shear failure along inclined crystalline planes, the typical failure mode of elements in compression. Whereas the details of the components described below will need to be reviewed as more definitive data and criteria become available, the goal of the paper of presenting the feasibility of a concept rather than a final design stands. Therefore, this study is limited to a conceptual design. It describes qualitatively how to use flexures to design a double-pendulum cryogenic payload and provides a semi-quantitative evaluation of a pendulum hinged with flexures. The aim is to point out the technical opportunities offered for future developments. Considering this scope, the selected dimensions of the components are reasonable, nevertheless, a true optimization can only be performed by considering all the requirements from a holistic point of view. In this article, the term suspension refers to a multiple-pendulum cryogenic assembly, which is the payload hanging from a room-temperature multi-stage vibration isolation chain. While guided by the necessity to generate a soft system with a high thermal conductance, the ensuing design offers solutions

Read the complete text