Multimodality in the search for new physics in pulsar timing data and the case of kination-amplified gravitational-wave background from inflation
Bohua Li, Joel Meyers, Paul R. Shapiro · 2025
Read Multimodality in the search for new physics in pulsar timing data and the case of kination-amplified gravitational-wave background from inflation by Bohua Li, Joel Meyers, Paul R. Shapiro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-18937.txt.
Introduction
Bohua Li, Joel Meyers, and Paul Shapiro study a case where pulsar timing data fit two unlike stories about the early universe about equally well, in a 2025 paper. Pulsar timing groups recently reported a background hum of gravitational waves. One reading blames waves from inflation, boosted by a later phase in which motion energy ruled the young cosmos.
That reading splits into two modes: one with the boost and one without it. The authors use a sampling method built for such splits to weigh both modes on current data and on fake data with a stronger signal. The fake-data test cleanly found the two modes and ruled out a third. The real data gave a mild edge to the no-boost mode.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bohua Li, Joel Meyers, Paul R. Shapiro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-18937
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multimodality in the search for new physics in pulsar timing data and the case of kination-amplified gravitational-wave background from inflation Bohua Li, Joel Meyers, Paul R. Shapiro Abstract We investigate the kination-amplified inflationary gravitational-wave background (GWB) interpretation of the signal recently reported by various pulsar timing array (PTA) experiments. Kination is a post-inflationary phase in the expansion history dominated by the kinetic energy of some scalar field, characterized by a stiff equation of state w = 1 w=1 . Within the inflationary GWB model, we identify two modes which can fit the current data sets (NANOGrav and EPTA) with equal likelihood: the kination-amplification (KA) mode and the ordinary, non-kination-amplification (no-KA) mode. The multimodality of the likelihood motivates a Bayesian analysis with nested sampling. We analyze the free spectra of current PTA data and mock free spectra constructed with higher signal-to-noise ratios, using nested sampling. The analysis of the mock spectrum designed to be consistent with the best fit to the NANOGrav 15 yr (NG15) data successfully reveals the expected bimodal posterior for the first time while excluding the reheating mode that appears in the fit to the current NG15 data, making a case for our correct and comprehensive treatment of potential multimodal posteriors arising from future PTA data sets. The resultant Bayes factor is ℬ ≡ 𝒵 no − KA / 𝒵 KA = 2.9 ± 1.9 \mathcal{B}\equiv\mathcal{Z}_{\mathrm{no-KA}}/\mathcal{Z}_{\mathrm{KA}}=2.9\pm 1.9 , indicating comparable statistical significance between the two modes. Given the theoretical model-building challenges of producing highly blue-tilted primordial tensor spectra, the KA mode has the advantage of requiring less blue primordial spectra, compared with the no-KA mode. The synergy between future cosmic microwave background polarization, pulsar timing and laser interferometer measurements of gravitational waves will help resolve the ambiguity implied by the multimodal posterior in PTA-only searches. cobaya [ 87 , 88 ] , PolyChord [ 49 , 50 ] , FortEPiaNO [ 42 ] , stiffGWpy ( https://github.com/bohuarolandli/stiffGWpy ), show][email protected] I Introduction The field of gravitational-wave (GW) astronomy recently witnessed a major breakthrough brought by various pulsar timing array (PTA) collaborations, NANOGrav [ 5 ] , EPTA & InPTA [ 36 ] , PPTA [ 76 ] and CPTA [ 91 ] , who concurrently reported strong evidence for a stochastic gravitational-wave background (SGWB) signal in the nanoHertz frequency band. The signature interpulsar Hellings-Downs (HD) correlation curve [ 51 ] has been measured up to 4.6 \sigma statistical significance. While the confirmation of this signal is underway, interpretation of the existing data has already drawn tremendous attention among the broader astrophysics and high-energy physics community. Beyond the standard interpretation that the nanohertz SGWB is sourced by inspiraling supermassive black hole binaries [ 74 , 53 , 81 , SMBHBs;] , new-physics models may provide a better fit to the measured free spectrum [ 4 , 37 , 79 ] . Hence, this potential SGWB signal offers abundant opportunities for early-Universe cosmology [ 89 , 38 , 35 , e.g.,] . Cosmological interpretations of the PTA data can be roughly classified as inflationary or non-inflationary signals. Inflationary SGWBs are expected from tensor vacuum fluctuations of the inflaton [ 48 , 84 , 2 ] or spectator fields [ 27 , 70 , 23 ] , and their post-inflationary amplification [ 44 , 45 , 17 , 65 ] . Non-inflationary SGWBs are produced by causal physics such as first-order phase transitions [ 57 , 52 , 80 , 69 , 9 , 92 ] , topological defects [ 29 , 10 , 34 , 16 , 75 ] , preheating [ 58 , 33 , 54 ] , scalar fluctuations [ 7 , 12 , 20 , 31 , 22 , 40 , 66 , 67 ] , etc. In view of the plenitude of models to be tested by the same PTA data sets, carefully implemented methodology for model selection/comparison is key to drawing robust conclusions about any potential new physics. Current model selection methods are mainly based on the Bayes factor, \mathcal{B}_{10}\equiv\mathcal{Z}_{1}/\mathcal{Z}_{0} , defined as the ratio of the evidence of two models. However, it is understood that the current PTA data are not informative enough to make the Bayes factors free from the “prior volume effect”, i.e., their exact values depend strongly on the range of priors adopted for the parameters [ 4 , 37 ] . Better measurements of the SGWB spectrum are required, therefore, to minimize the prior volume effect and derive stable Bayes factors for new-physics models. In this paper, we shall address another subtlety in the analysis and interpretation of PTA data regarding the search for new physics, namely the multimodal posterior distribution of model parameters. Such a posterior contains disjoint high-likelihood clusters (modes), while each mode may bear a distinctive physical interpretation. As an example, A. Afzal et al. [4] performed a Bayesian fit to the NANOGrav 15yr (NG15) data using the inflationary SGWB model that allows for a primordial blue tilt (positive tensor spectral index n_{\mathrm{t}} ), and found a bimodal posterior where the signal can be explained by either the tensor perturbations that reentered the horizon during radiation domination (RD) or those that reentered during reheating. However, this “reheating mode” has a spectral index of n_{\mathrm{t}}-2 in the SGWB spectrum today, which requires a notably large n_{\mathrm{t}} to fit the PTA signal. Its best-fit parameters may thus be in conflict with the linearity of primordial tensor fluctuations, as we show in this paper. Instead, we herein consider another case for a potential multimodal posterior: the inflationary SGWB with kination amplification [ 60 , 65 , 24 , 39 , 47 , 25 ] . Kination is an early phase in the expansion history in which the Universe is dominated by the kinetic energy of some scalar field [ 83 , 56 , 26 ] , also dubbed a “stiff phase,” since the equation of state (EoS) during kination is that of a relativistically-stiff perfect fluid, i.e. w\equiv\bar{P}/\bar{\rho}=1 [ 63 ] . When kination is present, the kination-amplified (also referred to as “stiff-amplified”) part of the inflationary SGWB spectrum today has index n_{\mathrm{t}}+1 , instead of the primordial index n_{\mathrm{t}} , which introduces a new mode that can fit the same PTA data within the inflationary SGWB model [ 64 ] . In contrast to the prior volume effect, multimodality in the posterior becomes more substantial as data get more informative. Therefore, it is crucial to take into account the possibility of multimodality in the analysis of future PTA data. In addition to the common model selection exercise, “mode selection” within one model needs to be performed when possible. To this end, nested sampling [ 82 ] provides a robust method to explore multimodal posteriors. We here apply the nested sampler implemented by the PolyChord package [ 49 , 50 ] and evaluate the Bayes factor between the two modes of the inflationary SGWB (with kination amplification or without). The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the necessity of considering multimodality (and hence nested samplers) when interpreting the current and future PTA data sets, by the case study of the kination-amplified inflationary SGWB model, a noteworthy model per se. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. We describe